Page 1 of 1

Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Posted: March 4 26, 4:50 pm
by mikechamp
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' writer Steve Adams that occurred on March 3. (If you like him, you can find him on Twitter @Adams_Steve and Bluesky @adams-steve.bsky.social.)

Fewer questions than last week, and one bonus Q&A about music. Enjoy!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://live.jotcast.com/chat/chat-with ... 23996.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Seems like Yanks aren't planning to invest in Chisholm long term. Doesn't it make sense to trade him now, when value is high? They could balance the lineup with a Jazz-for-Nico deal, or trade Jazz to HOU in a three-team deal that nets Paredes. What say you?

Steve Adams
Hoerner and Jazz are both one-year guys, so not sure that really makes sense. Sending Jazz to Houston and getting Paredes back still leaves the Astros with more infielders than spots to play them.

A lot of fans seem aghast at the idea of a contending team losing a free agent for "only" the draft pick associated with a QO -- hence the incessant Skubal speculation, which has never seemed plausible -- but the Yankees are always in clear win-now mode. Trading Chisholm because he's a free agent in eight months isn't likely to make their 2026 club better.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Any sleeper picks this year? Miami? Pittsburgh? My Orioles should be much better.

Steve Adams
I'm not sure the Pirates count as one since they've had a decent offseason and have all that vaunted young pitching, but they're a decent one. Can I count the A's?
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Why is everyone picking Milwaukee to finish 3rd or 4th in the Central? Have people not learned over the last 10 years?!

Steve Adams
I would say because no, they have not learned. I have Milwaukee second in the NLC right now and my consistent caveat has been that they'll make me feel stupid for it.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
E. Suarez finally crosses the 50 Homer Run mark. You taking the over/under/exact?

Steve Adams
I'd take the under on 40, let alone 50. No disrespect to him, but he's only topped 40 twice and will turn 35 next July.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Brewers trading away their best pitcher from a season ago with the best record in baseball, are they trying NOT to win the division this year??

Steve Adams
It's just how they always operate. They also traded a pair of All-Star closers while contending (Hader, Williams) and another former ace off the back of a winning season (Burnes). The Brewers are good every year despite having no money from ownership precisely because they avoid getting sentimental and hanging onto guys to run out their contention window.

When it comes to a team like Milwaukee, I get the idea of biting the bullet and trading Peralta. Ownership was probably never going to pay market value to keep him.

It's different (for me anyway) when it's a Skubal situation or the Jazz Chisholm one someone asked about earlier. The Yankees can easily pay Jazz if they want to keep him and can add another high-end 2B if he walks.

Tigers are a bit different since Skubal's price will be SO huge, but they have basically no long-term money on the books and have run payroll up to the 200 range in the past, so I don't think they should be treated with the same "well they'll never pay him" approach.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Would E Duran be enough for Jo Jo Romero?

Steve Adams
Not with the way he's hit (or rather, hasn't hit) for the past two seasons.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who will be the best player going forward: Bobby Witt Jr. or Ella De La Cruz?

Steve Adams
Love Elly but easy BWJ here for me.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Cards fan can be happy about what?

Steve Adams
JJ Wetherholt?
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is Lars Nootbaar a legit trade candidate for the Cards? Considering he’s getting a bit older & could help the rebuild if he’s moved.

Steve Adams
Yeah but I think more midseason. He's coming off the double heel surgery and I don't think there's a huge market/demand right now, save for the Astros maybe.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------

What was the first CD you ever bought?

Steve Adams
Superunknown, by Soundgarden
Incredible record to this day
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Posted: March 5 26, 8:44 am
by heyzeus
Bobby Witt Jr is a 25 year old whose down year was 8.0 WAR. He's the best player in baseball (non-Ohtani division) moving forward. Elly is an exciting player, but c'mon.

Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Posted: March 5 26, 6:20 pm
by Magneto2.0
heyzeus wrote: ↑
March 5 26, 8:44 am
Bobby Witt Jr is a 25 year old whose down year was 8.0 WAR. He's the best player in baseball (non-Ohtani division) moving forward. Elly is an exciting player, but c'mon.
I know he's older, but Judge is so much better than everyone else by a country mile offensively, I still say he's the best.

Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Posted: March 6 26, 7:56 am
by heyzeus
Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
March 5 26, 6:20 pm
heyzeus wrote: ↑
March 5 26, 8:44 am
Bobby Witt Jr is a 25 year old whose down year was 8.0 WAR. He's the best player in baseball (non-Ohtani division) moving forward. Elly is an exciting player, but c'mon.
I know he's older, but Judge is so much better than everyone else by a country mile offensively, I still say he's the best.
I can't argue with that. He's on a legendary run. My gut says this year Judge declines with age/injury while Witt continues to post insane numbers, but Judge has been a 10 WAR player (and MVP) 3 of the last 4 years. That's wild.

Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Posted: March 6 26, 10:21 am
by mikechamp
Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
March 5 26, 6:20 pm
heyzeus wrote: ↑
March 5 26, 8:44 am
Bobby Witt Jr is a 25 year old whose down year was 8.0 WAR. He's the best player in baseball (non-Ohtani division) moving forward. Elly is an exciting player, but c'mon.
I know he's older, but Judge is so much better than everyone else by a country mile offensively, I still say he's the best.
Ohtani begs to differ.

Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Posted: March 6 26, 10:28 am
by Magneto2.0
mikechamp wrote: ↑
March 6 26, 10:21 am
Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
March 5 26, 6:20 pm
heyzeus wrote: ↑
March 5 26, 8:44 am
Bobby Witt Jr is a 25 year old whose down year was 8.0 WAR. He's the best player in baseball (non-Ohtani division) moving forward. Elly is an exciting player, but c'mon.
I know he's older, but Judge is so much better than everyone else by a country mile offensively, I still say he's the best.
Ohtani begs to differ.
I don't know, Ohtani is great, but he's "normal great" hitter status, if that makes sense. 168 wRC+ over the last 4 seasons, which is incredible, but we've seen that plenty of times. But Judge averages a 200 wRC+ over the last 4 years. That's insane. Last hitter to do that was peak Bonds over 20 years ago. And before that, I think you have to go to Ted Williams to find a hitter to average a 200 wRC+ over a 4 year span.

Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Posted: March 6 26, 11:16 am
by Lesson
heyzeus wrote: ↑
March 5 26, 8:44 am
Bobby Witt Jr is a 25 year old whose down year was 8.0 WAR. He's the best player in baseball (non-Ohtani division) moving forward. Elly is an exciting player, but c'mon.
Aside from the aforementioned discussion related to Judge, Raleigh's doing some crazy things at C and I'd argue his position is much more demanding physically than Witt's.