Page 1 of 2

Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: February 10 26, 11:23 am
by mikechamp
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on February 8.

Fewer questions than last week. Sadly, the Cards have sunk to a new low. (See below.) You get 1 bonus question about worst contract evar. Enjoy the read!!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/02/ ... t-106.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do the Jays make a consolidation trade before opening day? Always thought they’d turn their surplus (Schneider, Loperfido) for someone like Jo Jo Romero.

Mark Polishuk
This seems possible, since I find it hard to believe Romero will still be a Cardinal by Opening Day. But, the Jays might value having all of their depth back, since in my view there’s a lot of uncertainty over how many of their players will be able to replicate their 2025 numbers.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Any chances that Posey pulls something else off to complete the offseason? I feel like he fixed some holes in the roster but could still use some help, especially on the pitching side. Maybe trade for a solid reliever (JoJo Romero) or free agent (Danny Coulombe) or hunt down one of the starters remaining on a lesser deal (Gallen, etc). It can’t be enough on the pitching side for them for sure, in my opinion, and do you think Posey has a strategy to wait out the market for some prices to drop?

Mark Polishuk
With the lineup more or less set, any remaining Giants moves will surely come on the pitching end. The bullpen adds you suggest make sense, and I’d prefer Gallen over any of the SF starters beyond the big two.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Mountcastle and Honeycutt to STL for Romero?

Mark Polishuk
The rebuilding Cardinals have no need for Mountcastle.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do the Pirates end up with Perades or Vientos?

Mark Polishuk
Paredes would be a huge coup for the Bucs, but I’m not sure how well they line up with the Astros in terms of Houston wanting a LHH outfielder. The Pirates could dangle another pitcher, potentially, or this might another case of the Pirates and Astros bringing in a third team to work out a trade.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
STL doesn’t have a first baseman after trading Contreras. I could see them taking a flier on Mountcastle or pushing for Mayo for Romero.

Mark Polishuk
Firstly, Burleson will be getting most of the Cardinals’ 1B playing time. The Orioles aren’t moving Mayo for one year of a decent reliever.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will the Pirates acquire anybody to play third?

Mark Polishuk
Triolo is a very good defender, so going glove-only isn’t the worst result in the world at third base. But, Triolo works even better as a utility guy, so I’d prefer to see the Bucs add a bat.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Realistic opinion and grade on the Suárez deal?

Mark Polishuk
Solid B+, maybe A- give the one-year commitment and salary. The Reds badly needed a big bat and they’ve got one with upside. There are some natural concerns over Suarez’s strikeouts and hot-and-cold nature, but in general, I really like the signing.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the Brewers really going to pocket the 8 million they were going to pay Freddie, particularly when one considers the obvious lack of infield depth?

Mark Polishuk
I wonder if the Brewers are one of the teams in on Paredes. This is pure speculation on my part, but adding Paredes would be a very nice add.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Winner of NL Central this year?

Mark Polishuk
Who wins the NL Central?

Brewers (25.7% | 200 votes)
Cubs (46.7% | 363 votes)
Pirates (12.7% | 99 votes)
Reds (14.8% | 115 votes)

Total Votes: 777

(Sorry to Cardinals fans, but I’m realistically leaving them out of the mix.)
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Why isn’t Lenyn Sosa more highly regarded by teams looking for a power hitting infielder (Red Sox and Pirates)?

Mark Polishuk
Because he doesn’t bring much to the table beyond power. Sosa never walks, and his contact numbers are only so-so.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Any chance the Brewers extend Turang or Frekick?

Mark Polishuk
Frelick has four years of control remaining, and he doesn’t reach arbitration eligibility until next winter. Turang is making $4.15MM this season, and he has three arb years left as a Super Two player.

Turang is repped by Excel, who usually take their clients to free agency rather than sign extensions. So between that and the money Turang is already slated to earn through his arb years, Frelick is the likelier extension candidate of the two, since Turang’s window for inking a long-term deal may have already passed.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I’m a little shocked Romero hasn’t been moved yet. You’d think he would of been the easiest.

Mark Polishuk
That’s actually more of a reason why Romero is still on the team, probably. Because he’s a fit on so many rosters, the Cards are likely getting a lot of offers, and are comfortable waiting things out until teams start getting a little more desperate.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Worst contract in baseball history?

Mark Polishuk
Anthony Rendon or Kris Bryant come to mind. In terms of dollars against virtually no return, Strasburg’s second contract with Washington should be #1, but Strasburg’s past history with the Nats at least adds a bit of “I get it” logic to that signing.
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: February 10 26, 12:25 pm
by dmarx114
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Winner of NL Central this year?

Mark Polishuk
Who wins the NL Central?

Brewers (25.7% | 200 votes)
Cubs (46.7% | 363 votes)
Pirates (12.7% | 99 votes)
Reds (14.8% | 115 votes)

Total Votes: 777

(Sorry to Cardinals fans, but I’m realistically leaving them out of the mix.)

My goodness. Is this how far we have fallen, lol?

I think it's possible for things to break right and win the division.

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: February 10 26, 12:34 pm
by Popeye_Card
I think it is more likely that the Cardinals lose 100 games than win the division.

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: February 10 26, 12:35 pm
by mikechamp
dmarx114 wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 12:25 pm

I think it's possible for things to break right and win the division.
I don't see how you can think that with the current members of the starting rotation.

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: February 10 26, 12:46 pm
by dmarx114
mikechamp wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 12:35 pm
dmarx114 wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 12:25 pm

I think it's possible for things to break right and win the division.
I don't see how you can think that with the current members of the starting rotation.
Won 78 last year with Fedde, Mikolas, and Pallante starting half the games.

Seems like there could be room for some improvement there.

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: February 10 26, 12:54 pm
by Popeye_Card
There's room, but we haven't exactly filled it in with anything better. Just cheaper.

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: February 10 26, 1:00 pm
by dmarx114
Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 12:54 pm
There's room, but we haven't exactly filled it in with anything better. Just cheaper.
May could be an upgrade.

I am optimistic about a full year of McGreevy.

Libby could take another step forward.

Leahy, Dobbins, Doyle, and Mathews could all be helpful as the year progresses.

Now, I don't actually expect everything to break right for us. But it also doesn't seem impossible in this division.

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: February 10 26, 1:07 pm
by Popeye_Card
Alternatively, the defense will probably be worse, the offense will probably be worse, and the relief pitching will probably be worse. Our pythag record was 74-88, which is where you should probably place last year's true talent. I think it is much more likely that we lose 12 more games (to lose 100) than winning 16 more (to win 90, which is probably the minimum bar to win the division).

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: February 10 26, 1:09 pm
by mikechamp
dmarx114 wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 1:00 pm
Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 12:54 pm
There's room, but we haven't exactly filled it in with anything better. Just cheaper.
May could be an upgrade.

I am optimistic about a full year of McGreevy.

Libby could take another step forward.

Leahy, Dobbins, Doyle, and Mathews could all be helpful as the year progresses.

Now, I don't actually expect everything to break right for us. But it also doesn't seem impossible in this division.
I'm just hoping they don't finish in the cellar... and I wouldn't be surprised to be disappointed.

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: February 10 26, 1:12 pm
by dmarx114
Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 1:07 pm
Alternatively, the defense will probably be worse, the offense will probably be worse, and the relief pitching will probably be worse. Our pythag record was 74-88, which is where you should probably place last year's true talent. I think it is much more likely that we lose 12 more games (to lose 100) than winning 16 more (to win 90, which is probably the minimum bar to win the division).
I would agree.

But I still think there is some path where things break right for us, however unlikely it may be. Maybe somewhere between a 5-10% chance to win the division. But definitely not 0%.