Page 1 of 1

Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: February 2 26, 8:33 pm
by mikechamp
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on February 1.

Just about the same amount of questions this week, but 3 bonus questions: 2 about music and one about a possible lockout effect. Enjoy the read!!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/02/ ... t-104.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Cardinals need a veteran starter, no question, is a 1 year Scherzer worth the price to them since they are shedding money?

Mark Polishuk
Scherzer’s not going to sign with a rebuilding team.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Eugenio is confirmed as going to Cincinnati. Why did the Mariner’s allow him to sign elsewhere, leaving them with Williamson whom I think is not ready to play 3B everyday?

Mark Polishuk
Williamson is an everyday player in terms of defense, though I agree that his bat is very much a work in progress at best. The M’s may feel Suarez’s best days are behind him, or is just too inconsistent a player for a big financial commitment.

That said, I wonder if Suarez’s willingness to take one year and $15MM was limited to just the Reds due to his past familiarity, because if that offer was also a possibility for Seattle, the M’s should’ve jumped.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I am disappointed that the Dbacks didn’t add Suarez for such a good price. Their offense seems very light to me. Does this make the Dbacks a longer shot to make playoffs?

Mark Polishuk
Now this would’ve been a creative way for Arizona to add a RHH first baseman. Re-sign Suarez and use him primarily as a DH, but also in a platoon at 1B. Again, however, not sure if the price was right for the D’Backs or any other team besides the Reds, especially if Suarez was turning down a larger offer from the Pirates.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
More likely – A’s sign somebody like Chris Bassitt or Lucas Giolito OR trade for somebody like Brady Singer or Kris Bubic?

Mark Polishuk
A trade seems more likely, just because I find it doubtful that Bassitt or Giolito would sign to pitch in a hitter-friendly minor league ballpark if they had other options elsewhere.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are all the Fan Duel sports teams just gone go to MLB?

Mark Polishuk
That seems like the most plausible outcome.
Maybe not every single one, but you have to imagine most or all of the teams are very fed up with all of the bankruptcy drama over MSS in the last few years.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Brendan Donovan and JoJo Romero situations? What’s holding deals up? Cards asking too much or just not getting what they want exactly? Thanks.

Mark Polishuk
There appears to be enough interest in both guys that the Cards are holding out for the best possible offer, or to see if a team with an offer on the table is willing to go a bit further.

The risk, of course, is that one of those interested teams could pivot elsewhere, like the Giants with Arraez.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Should us as Reds fans be happy we got Eugenio back or should we be worried for another Candelario, just as a one year deal

Mark Polishuk
I think Cincy fans should be delighted at Suarez, and at a bargain price, no less. “There’s no such thing as a bad one-year deal,” as the cliche goes.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If Hoerner is a Cub on opening day, do you think they will extend him or let him walk?

Mark Polishuk
Leaning towards no, due to Shaw’s presence. (Or maybe depending on how the Cubs feel about Jefferson Rojas.)
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Now that the Pirates have fallen out on Suarez, who do you see as a possible player that is left in free agency or trade that could bring in a bat and decent glove?

Mark Polishuk
Since we just mentioned him earlier, Miguel Andujar would work for the Buccos as well, as a third baseman/corner OF.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Hey Mark, best guess – Donovan traded prior to season or at the deadline?

Mark Polishuk
I think he’ll still get dealt during the offseason.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
With the Reds carrying three catchers into Spring Training and Duno down the pipeline, is it possible Stephenson is moved in the coming weeks?

Mark Polishuk
Seems unlikely, since a catching tandem of Trevino/Rortvedt isn’t exactly elite. While Stephenon’s 2025 season wasn’t great, he still has more upside.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Matt Shaw from the Cubs to the Red Sox for Kristian Campbell. Who says no?

Mark Polishuk
Chicago. Why trade your own prospect who’s cost-controlled for another prospect who might be a worse player, and is already guaranteed serious money?
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Pat Murphy is entering the last year of his deal, are lame duck managers more common in MLB than other sports? I think in the NFL coaches almost never go into the last year of a deal.

Mark Polishuk
I don’t think it’s super common, and in Murphy’s case, the Brewers will surely work out an extension in the next couple of months. Don’t forget, teams routinely table all extension business (for players, managers or executives) until closer to the midpoint of Spring Training, when almost all the offseason work is done.

If you want a rundown of which managers and top front office executives are entering their lame-duck year, well hey, a certain MLBTR writer published a post on this topic the other day….
https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/01/ ... cts-7.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What are the chances Konnor Griffin starts the season in Pittsburgh?

Mark Polishuk
He has never played a day at Triple-A, and he has only 21 games of Double-A ball to his name. It would be mighty bold of the Pirates to have Griffin break camp, even if he has a huge spring. The PPI might be tempting for the Pirates, but I’d lean towards Griffin starting the year at Triple-A.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Am I completely off base thinking Masataka Yoshida could thrive in a place like Pittsburgh or Colorado? Boston could send some salary relief and a decent prospect. Everyone wins right?

Mark Polishuk
The DH spot is already too full for Yoshida in Pittsburgh, but since the Rockies are an open book, sure.

The issue with dealing Yoshida, however, is either that the Red Sox will have to eat a lot of money, or sent more than “a decent prospect” to get the other team to cover more of Yoshida’s contract. Look at the Hicks trade as a model, then consider that Yoshida makes $12MM more than Hicks does.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Guardians’ gave Ramirez a legacy contract as the Cards did with Yadi and Wainwright. Good for PR but bad for the team as aging players disappoint.

Mark Polishuk
As noted, the restructuring gives the Guardians more money right now, plus the deferred money allowed them to kick the financial can down the road to some extent.

J-Ram hasn’t at all started to slow down, so it’s not out of the question that he’ll keep being a productive player for some time yet. Also, the organization surely doesn’t mind giving Ramirez a bit of “legacy” money if it comes down to it, since he’s been such a galactic bargain for them over the years.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
How does the Reds starting lineup shake out after the Suarez signing? Who is the odd man out? Bleday, Steer, Stewart, others?

Mark Polishuk
Bleday didn’t hit at all last year, and there’s no guarantee he’ll bounce back.

Maybe because he’s “the new guy,” the Reds are also less committed to giving him at-bats than their own prospects or a big signing like Suarez.

Correction: Steer isn’t really “their” prospect, but you get my drift.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
As a batter what would your walk up song be? As a closer what would you pick as your walk out song?

Mark Polishuk
I feel like I’ve answered this question in many different ways over the years in these chats. My current answers are either Ghostbusters or the Log Driver’s Waltz.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If there is no baseball in 2027, what are the chances the players ensure that a year of service time is subtracted? Also, will we see an influx of in-season extensions this year as a result of that possibility?

Mark Polishuk
I’ll sidestep this question by stating that I highly doubt the 2027 season doesn’t happen. That would kill the sport.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Now you’ve got me ’birling down and down white water’. Thanks lol.

Mark Polishuk
That song is such a nostalgic earworm. If Carney wanted to make it the new national anthem, I wouldn’t complain.
-----------------------------------------------------------------