Page 1 of 2

Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Posted: January 21 26, 8:52 pm
by Magneto2.0

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Posted: January 21 26, 9:02 pm
by phins
Brewers out here showing everyone how it's done.

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Posted: January 22 26, 7:44 am
by cardsfantx
I’m not a fan of Williams…will stick at SS, but don’t like the bat (plus he’s tiny).

Sproate I do like though; should be in the rotation right away.

Even with peralta being a FA at the end of the season, I feel the brewers should’ve gotten more?

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Posted: January 22 26, 8:11 am
by heyzeus
Being a baseball fan is just punishment for like 80% of us.

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Posted: January 22 26, 8:27 am
by dmarx114
Mets got fleeced.

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Posted: January 22 26, 9:56 am
by Magneto2.0
A 97 win team trading their best pitcher and another good pitcher for some prospects because they don't want to pay him (Peralta) is just as bad or not worse than the Dodgers signing everybody imo.

Teams that are good should not be trying to shed payroll and not pay their good players. But that's just my thoughts.

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Posted: January 22 26, 10:07 am
by dmarx114
Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 9:56 am
A 97 win team trading their best pitcher and another good pitcher for some prospects because they don't want to pay him (Peralta) is just as bad or not worse than the Dodgers signing everybody imo.

Teams that are good should not be trying to shed payroll and not pay their good players. But that's just my thoughts.
He's only making $8M, so I don't think this is a salary dump. I think it's turning a depreciating asset (age 30, final year of contract) into 2 really good prospects.

Didn't think my 25,000th post would be analyzing a Mets-Brewers trade, but here we are.

Hopefully post 50,000 in 2045 is about a Cards world series win.

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Posted: January 22 26, 10:17 am
by Magneto2.0
dmarx114 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:07 am
Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 9:56 am
A 97 win team trading their best pitcher and another good pitcher for some prospects because they don't want to pay him (Peralta) is just as bad or not worse than the Dodgers signing everybody imo.

Teams that are good should not be trying to shed payroll and not pay their good players. But that's just my thoughts.
He's only making $8M, so I don't think this is a salary dump. I think it's turning a depreciating asset (age 30, final year of contract) into 2 really good prospects.

Didn't think my 25,000th post would be analyzing a Mets-Brewers trade, but here we are.

Hopefully post 50,000 in 2045 is about a Cards world series win.
Where the Brewers are currently, their sole focus should be "What can I do in 2026 to maximize our teams chances to win the WS", and trading your best pitcher for a couple of prospects does not achieve that. This is all due to owners being a cheap. There's a reason they haven't sniffed a WS in over 40 years. Brewers will continue to be good like they always are in the regular season and get smacked in the wildcard series or the LDS like they do every year.

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Posted: January 22 26, 10:23 am
by dmarx114
Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:17 am
dmarx114 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:07 am
Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 9:56 am
A 97 win team trading their best pitcher and another good pitcher for some prospects because they don't want to pay him (Peralta) is just as bad or not worse than the Dodgers signing everybody imo.

Teams that are good should not be trying to shed payroll and not pay their good players. But that's just my thoughts.
He's only making $8M, so I don't think this is a salary dump. I think it's turning a depreciating asset (age 30, final year of contract) into 2 really good prospects.

Didn't think my 25,000th post would be analyzing a Mets-Brewers trade, but here we are.

Hopefully post 50,000 in 2045 is about a Cards world series win.
Where the Brewers are currently, their sole focus should be "What can I do in 2026 to maximize our teams chances to win the WS", and trading your best pitcher for a couple of prospects does not achieve that. This is all due to owners being a cheap. There's a reason they haven't sniffed a WS in over 40 years. Brewers will continue to be good like they always are in the regular season and get smacked in the wildcard series or the LDS like they do every year.
I don't think the Brewers share your outlook. I think they look at it through the lens of "what can I do to maximize my chances of making the playoffs year in and year out?"

Re: Mets acquire Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers from Brewers

Posted: January 22 26, 10:26 am
by Magneto2.0
dmarx114 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:23 am
Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:17 am
dmarx114 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 10:07 am
Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
January 22 26, 9:56 am
A 97 win team trading their best pitcher and another good pitcher for some prospects because they don't want to pay him (Peralta) is just as bad or not worse than the Dodgers signing everybody imo.

Teams that are good should not be trying to shed payroll and not pay their good players. But that's just my thoughts.
He's only making $8M, so I don't think this is a salary dump. I think it's turning a depreciating asset (age 30, final year of contract) into 2 really good prospects.

Didn't think my 25,000th post would be analyzing a Mets-Brewers trade, but here we are.

Hopefully post 50,000 in 2045 is about a Cards world series win.
Where the Brewers are currently, their sole focus should be "What can I do in 2026 to maximize our teams chances to win the WS", and trading your best pitcher for a couple of prospects does not achieve that. This is all due to owners being a cheap. There's a reason they haven't sniffed a WS in over 40 years. Brewers will continue to be good like they always are in the regular season and get smacked in the wildcard series or the LDS like they do every year.
I don't think the Brewers share your outlook. I think they look at it through the lens of "what can I do to maximize my chances of making the playoffs year in and year out?"
"The Cardinals Way 2015-2023"