Page 1 of 3

What happens with Arenado this offseason?

Posted: January 6 26, 10:47 am
by heyzeus
Vote!

Re: What happens with Arenado this offseason?

Posted: January 6 26, 11:41 am
by Famous Mortimer
It would be genuinely insane to release him, I think. 2-ish WAR a season isn't the most exciting thing in the world, but neither would any other option at 3B and at least we can be warmed by the thought of the cap he wears in Cooperstown.

On reflection, I think it's more likely he stays. But I am a very bad predictor.

Re: What happens with Arenado this offseason?

Posted: January 6 26, 12:05 pm
by Fat_Bulldog
I don't think he's a good fit for a rebuild. I'd be happy to release him and give playing time to one of the kids.

Re: What happens with Arenado this offseason?

Posted: January 6 26, 12:37 pm
by dmarx114
Very confident he will be traded with the Cards picking up a significant remainder of the contract and only getting a flyer type of prospect in return.

Re: What happens with Arenado this offseason?

Posted: January 6 26, 2:03 pm
by cardsfantx
keep him, just cause I don't think they have a choice

Bloom already said he will not release him, and I don't think any team wants him; even with us picking up almost all of his salary.

If his name wasn't Nolan Arenado, he's already have been released or stuck on the end of some team's bench

Re: What happens with Arenado this offseason?

Posted: January 6 26, 2:25 pm
by jagtrader
He won’t be on the team. Just a question of whether they can find a trade.

Re: What happens with Arenado this offseason?

Posted: January 6 26, 3:33 pm
by CardsofSTL
I expect him to be traded after Bregman signs somewhere.

But I would rather they kept him.

Re: What happens with Arenado this offseason?

Posted: January 6 26, 4:50 pm
by TGantz
No, he isn't 100% worth his contract, but how many 31+ year old players actually are? He's a potential HOF that is aging pretty much as expected. He's a well above average defender but should bat at the bottom of the order. If they keep Donovan, I really hope they trade Arenado. If they trade Donovan, I hope they keep Arenado.

It'll be tough to watch the drop in defense if it's Gorman at 3B. Releasing Nolan Arenado would be disastrous PR.

Re: What happens with Arenado this offseason?

Posted: January 7 26, 9:31 am
by dmarx114
I think he's worth a flyer if I am running a contending team and need a 3rd baseman. You know you're getting excellent defense.

Bat him 7th or 8th and see if his bat comes back. As long as the Cards/Rockies are paying most of the contract, there isn't much downside risk.

Re: What happens with Arenado this offseason?

Posted: January 7 26, 9:45 am
by Famous Mortimer
He was worth a lot more than his contract in those first couple of Cardinals years, which is (as we all know but sometimes forget) how pretty much all these bigger contracts work.