Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments
Posted: January 5 26, 1:13 pm
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on January 3.
More questions than last chat, and one bonus question. Enjoy the read!!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/01/ ... at-97.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Has the Cardinals trade stuff stalled? It’s been a while since any updates.
Mark Polishuk
Not surprising that things slowed down over the holidays. The Cards have already moved Gray and Contreras, leaving Arenado as the last big contract remaining, and Donovan/JoJo/maybe Gorman or Nootbaar as less-expensive but more sought-after trade chips.
The Cardinals certainly aren’t done with their swaps yet, and it feels like Donovan, Romero, and Arenado will all be elsewhere by Opening Day.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What’s stopping the Reds from being in on Okamoto? Seems like a great fit at 1B/DH along with Sal Stewart and have Steer as super utility again?
Mark Polishuk
Good question. Maybe they are in on him, and this’ll be another outta-nowhere signing like Murakami to the ChiSox and Imai to Houston.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The rumor mill quieted on Peralta. You think that picks back up now that the holidays are over or do you think the Brewers are more likely to give the season a go with him?
Mark Polishuk
It always felt likelier that Milwaukee would just keep Peralta, since they’d need a ton in return to say yes to a trade. It could be things get rolling a bit now that Imai is off the board, though it’s interesting to remember that the Astros were one of the teams reportedly interested in Peralta. That may no longer be the case now that Imai and Burrows are on board.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you see Ian Happ starting for the cubs this year?
Mark Polishuk
Yes. He had a no-trade clause, so he probably isn’t going anywhere.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is Emerson plus a lottery ticket for Donovan possible? Donovan is what the Mariners would hope Emerson could be.
Mark Polishuk
Zero chance Emerson is traded. He’s a top-10 prospect in baseball.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the Pirates wild card contenders if they get Okamoto or Suarez for 3B with that rotation?
Mark Polishuk
I’d say so. Their lineup would be a lot better and the pitching is still strong, so that might be enough for Pittsburgh to get over the playoff line amidst a number of NL teams with comparable weaknesses.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
if the Jays are able to get Bo, Tucker or Bregman, do Straw or Lukes have any trade value or are they more DFA candidates?
Mark Polishuk
If they get Tucker specifically, Lukes is probably traded. Straw sticks around in any scenario as a backup OF.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Cubs seem to be sniffing around INFs. If they sign one, who is the odd man out? I have terrible feeling it’s Hoerner, even though he brings elite contact to a lineup that needs it. Any chance, if the Cubs sign a Bregman or whomever, that Shaw is the odd man out and they could trade him for pitching?
Mark Polishuk
Nico makes a ton of contact but it isn’t exactly quality contact. He is also a free agent after the season, so it would make sense that the Cubs are looking to deal him now if Nico isn’t part of their future plans.
That either opens up 2B for an acquisition, or perhaps they get Bregman and move Shaw to 2B.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What would the Reds have to give up for Yandy Diaz? Chase Petty?
Mark Polishuk
2026 is Diaz’s final guaranteed year, plus there’s a club option for 2027. So two seasons of Diaz for Petty probably isn’t something Cincinnati is open to doing, though these could be elements of a multi-player swap
-----------------------------------------------------------------
How can the scouts all be so wrong about players like Jordan Walker, or Jo Adell since he HAS to be mentioned in every chat?
Mark Polishuk
Scouting players and identifying future stars is incredibly hard. Still plenty of time for Walker to get clicking at the MLB level, just as it took Adell several years to finally have a breakout.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
When was the last time a team did a pre-career (or very early career) extension with a pitcher?
Mark Polishuk
These don’t happen too often. Ashby’s extension with Milwaukee is the most recent, after some brief checking on the MLB Contract Tracker.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the cubs involved for Okamoto?
Mark Polishuk
They were mentioned as one of the teams in the hunt. The depth of their interest isn’t known, however.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Brewers have no depth at shortstop, and a marginal hitter at best manning the position. What are you hearing about the Kiner-Filefa market, and is there a chance he could fall to the Brewers?
Mark Polishuk
IKF should fall within the Brewers’ price range for bench depth.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Why do players wait so long to sign? If it was me, I’d sign as soon as possible to get acclimated with my new squad.
Mark Polishuk
If the offers aren’t interesting, players aren’t just going to grab the least-uninteresting lowball offer just for the sake of signing.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
More questions than last chat, and one bonus question. Enjoy the read!!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/01/ ... at-97.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Has the Cardinals trade stuff stalled? It’s been a while since any updates.
Mark Polishuk
Not surprising that things slowed down over the holidays. The Cards have already moved Gray and Contreras, leaving Arenado as the last big contract remaining, and Donovan/JoJo/maybe Gorman or Nootbaar as less-expensive but more sought-after trade chips.
The Cardinals certainly aren’t done with their swaps yet, and it feels like Donovan, Romero, and Arenado will all be elsewhere by Opening Day.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What’s stopping the Reds from being in on Okamoto? Seems like a great fit at 1B/DH along with Sal Stewart and have Steer as super utility again?
Mark Polishuk
Good question. Maybe they are in on him, and this’ll be another outta-nowhere signing like Murakami to the ChiSox and Imai to Houston.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The rumor mill quieted on Peralta. You think that picks back up now that the holidays are over or do you think the Brewers are more likely to give the season a go with him?
Mark Polishuk
It always felt likelier that Milwaukee would just keep Peralta, since they’d need a ton in return to say yes to a trade. It could be things get rolling a bit now that Imai is off the board, though it’s interesting to remember that the Astros were one of the teams reportedly interested in Peralta. That may no longer be the case now that Imai and Burrows are on board.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you see Ian Happ starting for the cubs this year?
Mark Polishuk
Yes. He had a no-trade clause, so he probably isn’t going anywhere.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is Emerson plus a lottery ticket for Donovan possible? Donovan is what the Mariners would hope Emerson could be.
Mark Polishuk
Zero chance Emerson is traded. He’s a top-10 prospect in baseball.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the Pirates wild card contenders if they get Okamoto or Suarez for 3B with that rotation?
Mark Polishuk
I’d say so. Their lineup would be a lot better and the pitching is still strong, so that might be enough for Pittsburgh to get over the playoff line amidst a number of NL teams with comparable weaknesses.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
if the Jays are able to get Bo, Tucker or Bregman, do Straw or Lukes have any trade value or are they more DFA candidates?
Mark Polishuk
If they get Tucker specifically, Lukes is probably traded. Straw sticks around in any scenario as a backup OF.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Cubs seem to be sniffing around INFs. If they sign one, who is the odd man out? I have terrible feeling it’s Hoerner, even though he brings elite contact to a lineup that needs it. Any chance, if the Cubs sign a Bregman or whomever, that Shaw is the odd man out and they could trade him for pitching?
Mark Polishuk
Nico makes a ton of contact but it isn’t exactly quality contact. He is also a free agent after the season, so it would make sense that the Cubs are looking to deal him now if Nico isn’t part of their future plans.
That either opens up 2B for an acquisition, or perhaps they get Bregman and move Shaw to 2B.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What would the Reds have to give up for Yandy Diaz? Chase Petty?
Mark Polishuk
2026 is Diaz’s final guaranteed year, plus there’s a club option for 2027. So two seasons of Diaz for Petty probably isn’t something Cincinnati is open to doing, though these could be elements of a multi-player swap
-----------------------------------------------------------------
How can the scouts all be so wrong about players like Jordan Walker, or Jo Adell since he HAS to be mentioned in every chat?
Mark Polishuk
Scouting players and identifying future stars is incredibly hard. Still plenty of time for Walker to get clicking at the MLB level, just as it took Adell several years to finally have a breakout.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
When was the last time a team did a pre-career (or very early career) extension with a pitcher?
Mark Polishuk
These don’t happen too often. Ashby’s extension with Milwaukee is the most recent, after some brief checking on the MLB Contract Tracker.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the cubs involved for Okamoto?
Mark Polishuk
They were mentioned as one of the teams in the hunt. The depth of their interest isn’t known, however.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Brewers have no depth at shortstop, and a marginal hitter at best manning the position. What are you hearing about the Kiner-Filefa market, and is there a chance he could fall to the Brewers?
Mark Polishuk
IKF should fall within the Brewers’ price range for bench depth.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Why do players wait so long to sign? If it was me, I’d sign as soon as possible to get acclimated with my new squad.
Mark Polishuk
If the offers aren’t interesting, players aren’t just going to grab the least-uninteresting lowball offer just for the sake of signing.
-----------------------------------------------------------------