Page 1 of 2

Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: December 1 25, 5:10 pm
by mikechamp
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on November 30.

A lot of questions this week, plus 2 bonus questions: one about agents' strategies and another about a creative CBA addition. Enjoy the read!!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/11/ ... at-91.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Tucker and Imai for the Yanks?

Mark Polishuk
I’d be surprised to see New York spend to quite that level in bringing in two top-level guys. Bellinger and Imai seem like a more reasonable duo, if the Yankees make two big purchases.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is Lowder eligible for rookie of the year? He is under the innings limit but has over a year of service time on the 60 day IL.

Mark Polishuk
Lowder is no longer considered a rookie.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Was very surprised that a Miz extension would even be mentioned, what do you think an extension like that would look like? Seems a little risky for the Brewers no?

Mark Polishuk
Locking up a young potential ace is a very logical tactic for a lower-payroll team. If the Brewers feel as strongly about the Miz’s future as they did Chourio, they could explore another long-term deal that extends the team’s control over the hurler.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Pirates actually gonna spend money or all bluster?

Mark Polishuk
I’ll believe it when I see it, but there has been enough smoke about the Pirates spending that I feel they’ll do something out of character. Not sign Schwarber anything, but they’ll sign a position player to a fairly pricey (for them) multi-year contract. Skenes has established himself as such a star that it seems like the Bucs really want to win something while he’s still in the organization.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do the Pirates make sense as a team for Soler considering they need to increase payroll?

Mark Polishuk
In theory, but I’d think (hope?) the Pirates would be aiming higher than an aging hitter coming off a subpar year.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If the catcher market is thin, could you see the Brewers moving Contreras and his approx $11mill salary? What kind or return could he possibly bring?

Mark Polishuk
Same logic as the Phillies and Realmuto earlier… if you let a starting catcher go, what’s your plan to replace him? Trading Contreras is even less likely for the Brewers since he’s affordable for them even for that salary, since it’s still a bargain price for such a productive catcher.

You’ll start to hear more trade buzz about Contreras next winter when he’s a year away from free agency. It will be interesting to see if Milwaukee is sold enough on Quero to trade Contreras, or if they’ll hang onto him to try and win in 2027, then let him walk in free agency.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Should Bloom bring in Scherzer on a one year deal?

Mark Polishuk
Scherzer wants to pitch for a contender, not a rebuilding team.

Unless his market is completely barren, I don’t see Scherzer going to St. Louis.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Could you see the Marlins/Pirates making a trade purely to up the payroll, if they aren’t able to actually sign anyone they want and don’t want the grievance? Like take on Castellanos’ salary and get a prospect for it, then just DFA Castellanos? Neither org is well thought of so isn’t it possible that they can’t sign anybody and end up in a really bad spot payroll-wise and have to make a move?

Mark Polishuk
If the Marlins/Pirates offer enough money, they can definitely get people to sign. The price was right for Severino to join the A’s last year, as much as he might regret that decision in hindsight.

And, who’s to say a free agent wouldn’t have interest in either team. The Marlins were a decent team last year that seems to be on the way up, and they play in Florida. The Pirates have Skenes and a bunch of good pitchers, so a prominent free agent might be intrigued by the challenge of bringing winning baseball back to Pittsburgh.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Could the Reds potentially sign Marcell Ozuna as a cheaper alternative to Kyle Schwarber? And or Ryan O'Hearn could work for this question too.

Mark Polishuk
The previous commenter’s suggestion of O’Hearn is pretty plausible, actually. I imagine ROH will get a lot of looks from teams in the medium payroll range who can’t afford the likes of a Schwarber or an Alonso.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What’s the most plausible bat the Reds sign or trade for?

Mark Polishuk
Trade a quality pitching prospect for a quality young hitter who becomes a long-term answer for the lineup. Or, trade a quality pitching prospect for an established hitter who becomes a short-term answer.

The built-in other observation is that the Pirates have identified whether there's something amiss with the way they're developing hitters, or if they're just picking the wrong players.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Skenes to the Yankees for… The Martian, Austin Wells, Schlitter, Spencer Jones, George Lombard Jr.

Mark Polishuk
If the Yankees actually offered all that for Skenes, I think Pittsburgh says yes.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the Reds going to have a competition for the 3b job, or have they already given it to Hayes? Where does Sal Stewart fit if Hayes is the 3b and Steer at 1b? Stewart just the DH?

Mark Polishuk
Hayes is an incredible defensive 3B, so he isn’t going anywhere. As recently noted in an Athletic piece, Stewart/Steer have enough positional flexibility that it allows the Reds to be open to several possibilities as they weigh new additions
https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/11/ ... -cruz.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Tatsuya Imai and Cubs a good fit?

Mark Polishuk
Sure. Raises the ceiling of Chicago’s rotation, and provides long-term rotation help since Imanaga/Taillon/Boyd are all free agents after 2026.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Could Cards balance a trade with M's featuring Donovan & Sloan as principals?

Mark Polishuk
If Polanco departs, trading for Donovan would be a very nice pivot for Seattle. Dealing Sloan for two years of Donovan is a risk, yet the M’s farm system is deep enough that Dipoto might be willing to take the plunge.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
When will the 2026 mlb draft order be determined? Where will the Cards pick??

Mark Polishuk
The lottery takes place on December 9.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Does the same agent representing multiple players impact the timing of signings? Like does an agent prioritize the “big fish” first and slow play negotiations for the secondary free agents they represent that play the same position?

Mark Polishuk
It makes for a fascinating question, but I doubt any agent would really go on the record about how they operate in any given offseason. No agent wants to even slightly give the impression that one client is more value than another.

Since each player is different, an agent has flexibility in how they deal with each situation, even in the bigger-picture context of an offseason where an agency has multiple clients.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What do you think about a franchise player designation in the next CBA that either discounts that players lux tax hit by a certain percentage for high spending teams, or the lux tax going to pay a certain percentage of a franchise player's salary for revenue sharing recipients?

Mark Polishuk
Creative answers like this seem way more feasible to me than the idea of the players ever agreeing to a salary cap. The NBA version of your idea is somewhat akin to the “Larry Bird rule,” which allows a team to go over the cap in order to retain its own free agent.
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: December 1 25, 6:02 pm
by WAR God
Sign Scherzer. If the team surprises and competes, keep him. If the team sucks and he’s dealing, trade him. If everyone involved sucks, who cares?

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: December 2 25, 8:19 am
by Famous Mortimer
WAR God wrote: ↑
December 1 25, 6:02 pm
Sign Scherzer. If the team surprises and competes, keep him. If the team sucks and he’s dealing, trade him. If everyone involved sucks, who cares?
What did you think of Polishuk's reasoning why it won't happen?

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: December 2 25, 9:30 am
by cardinalkarp
Signing Scherzer 15 years too late would be a total Cardinal move.

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: December 2 25, 11:38 am
by WAR God
Famous Mortimer wrote: ↑
December 2 25, 8:19 am
WAR God wrote: ↑
December 1 25, 6:02 pm
Sign Scherzer. If the team surprises and competes, keep him. If the team sucks and he’s dealing, trade him. If everyone involved sucks, who cares?
What did you think of Polishuk's reasoning why it won't happen?
I don’t anticipate a real market. He hasn’t had an ERA+ above 100 since 2023. He’s 41.

I want this for purely selfish reasons, and the 10% chance he turns it around.

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: December 2 25, 12:02 pm
by sighyoung
cardinalkarp wrote: ↑
December 2 25, 9:30 am
Signing Scherzer 15 years too late would be a total Cardinal move.
Brings back memories of the Cardinals bringing in the likes of Claude Osteen and Larry Dierker at the ends of their careers.

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: December 2 25, 1:09 pm
by mikechamp
I think Scherzer only signs for the Cards if they are the last resort. He seems to be peeved that they didn't draft him. And then there's also the factor that he doesn't have many seasons left to compete for a ring.

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: December 2 25, 2:11 pm
by MrCrowesGarden
It’s not that they didn’t draft him. It’s that they didn’t sign him before 2015. The lesson there of course is even if you think you’re stacked at a position, you sign superstars who want to play for you.

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: December 2 25, 3:25 pm
by Famous Mortimer
Did Mark Buehrle (spelled right first time without needing to check, go me) ever express a preference for playing for the Cardinals? Because they never signed him either. I don't think it's going to happen for Scherzer as it makes absolutely no sense for either side.

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: December 5 25, 1:50 pm
by Mdcardfan60
WAR God wrote: ↑
December 2 25, 11:38 am
Famous Mortimer wrote: ↑
December 2 25, 8:19 am
WAR God wrote: ↑
December 1 25, 6:02 pm
Sign Scherzer. If the team surprises and competes, keep him. If the team sucks and he’s dealing, trade him. If everyone involved sucks, who cares?
What did you think of Polishuk's reasoning why it won't happen?
I don’t anticipate a real market. He hasn’t had an ERA+ above 100 since 2023. He’s 41.

I want this for purely selfish reasons, and the 10% chance he turns it around.
I want this too. The Cardinals have had at least one hall of famer on the roster (player or manager) every year since 1911, presuming Yadi eventually gets in. If Arenado leaves this offseason, signing Scherzer or Verlander would keep the streak alive.