Page 1 of 1

Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: September 15 25, 4:28 pm
by mikechamp
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on September 14.

A really small amount of questions in this one. They can't all be lengthy. I included 2 bonus questions: one about two fictional basestealers and one about Frankie Frisch. Enjoy the read!!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/09/ ... at-75.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Time for the Reds to pack it up?

Mark Polishuk
Speaking of teams that had a door open for them, the Reds have been struggling badly over the last four weeks. Cincinnati only had to play decent ball in that stretch, and they’d be well in front of the Mets at this point.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will shutting Winn down early hurt his chances at a GG?

Mark Polishuk
Nick Allen has the better overall slate of public metrics, as both DRS and OAA love his work. Winn is only getting the love from OAA, and Mookie Betts is the inverse, getting great DRS grades but only good OAAA grades.

If anything, Winn being such a good defender despite playing hurt all year might be a point in his favor with voters.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do the Brewers and Brandon Woodruff exercise the mutual option for next season?

Mark Polishuk
Given the long history between the two sides and the circumstances, this might be the rare example of a mutual option has a tiny chance of being mutually exercised.

But, the much more likely scenario is that Woodruff is a free agent.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Besides Tucker, which of the Cubs’ other OFs/DHs figures to be gone next season? I’d like to see Ballesteros stay.

Mark Polishuk
Suzuki and Happ are both free agents after 2026, but they also both have no-trade clauses. That doesn’t necessarily rule out a trade if either player is open to a move, except it makes things much trickier in finding a deal acceptable to all sides.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Willie Mays Hayes vs Adult Benny the Jet Rodriguez. Who wins?

Mark Polishuk
Outstanding question. My pick is Hayes, because we saw more of him as an adult than we did of Benny the Jet.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Does Frankie Frisch letting a bunch of his pals into the Hall in the 70s still have an effect today?

Mark Polishuk
It led to an overhaul of how the HOF approaches the veterans committee, though those committees have been altered many times over the years. Beyond that, I’m not sure it has much impact outside of “who is the worst Hall of Famer?” arguments,
-----------------------------------------------------------------