Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments
Posted: September 3 25, 4:13 pm
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on August 31.
More questions in this one, and I included 4 bonus questions: one about expanded rosters, one about the volume of releases, and 2 about realignment. Enjoy the read!!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/08/ ... at-72.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Ketel Marte the top target to bat cleanup for the Pittsburgh Pirates in 2026?
Mark Polishuk
I find it unlikely that Marte will be dealt anywhere, let alone to a Pittsburgh team that will find his contract too pricey.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Feels like the Giants have a run in them. Only 5 back. Your thoughts?
Mark Polishuk
Interestingly, the Giants only play four more teams for the rest of the season… two series each against the Dodgers, D’Backs, Rockies, and Cardinals.
Those extra games against Colorado in particular are a good chance to make up ground, but realistically, the Giants are probably too far out.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Stewart being called a bit too late to provide the offensive spark the Reds desperately needed over a week ago. Held down for some dumb financial/playing time reason?
Mark Polishuk
The PPI factor was surely on the Reds’ minds to some extent, but don’t forget that Stewart didn’t even make his Triple-A debut until after the All-Star break. It’s understandable how a team would want to give a good prospect some real run at Triple-A before giving him the extra challenge of the big leagues.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What can you see the Pirates doing this offseason? They need bats and have a surplus of good young pitching. I would like to see them add two bats to their lineup.
Mark Polishuk
As much as “you can never have too much pitching” applies, dealing a young arm for a young up-and-coming bat makes a ton of sense for the Pirates. I agree that they need multiple hitters to help get things turned around, and if ownership isn’t going to spend in free agency, then the front office has to be more aggressive on the trade front.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think Marmol will be the Cardinal manager next year?
Mark Polishuk
2026 is the last guaranteed season of Marmol’s contract, so the Cards would be eating just one year of money in the event of a managerial change. Allowing Bloom to pick his own manager would make sense with Bloom fully taking over the front office, and Bloom might welcome this flexibility since he basically inherited Alex Cora in Boston.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Does this Brewers team have what it takes to win it all?
Mark Polishuk
Absolutely. The Brewers are a scary opponent for anyone in October.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Can we now consider Henry Davis a complete 1/1 bust? I see no hope for improvement at the plate.
Mark Polishuk
For the “what should the Pirates do this winter” question earlier, the answer maybe should’ve been an overhaul of their hitting development strategies.
Davis has a 57 wRC+ over 610 career PA, or a little more than the equivalent of one full MLB season. While it’s early to write him off entirely, there haven’t been many or any flashes that Davis is close to breaking out, so that’s a very troubling lack of progress for a player that (as a 1-1 pick) had to be a key building block in a rebuild.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think the Cardinals should move on from Arenado?
Mark Polishuk
They should’ve moved on last winter, and I suspect the front office is still shaking their head of the chain of events that led Arenado to reject that deal to Houston.
Going forward, it’s hard to see much of a trade market for Arenado at all given his salary and how his offense has completely fallen off the table this season.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
At what point does the evaluation of a particular player trait change? Asking re Bruce Turang, whose 40 power grade is looking ridiculous at the moment.
Mark Polishuk
I dunno who this Bruce Turang guy is, but Brice Turang has been on an absolute scorcher for the last month. Don’t be surprised if/when Turang wins NL Player of the Month for August.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah and can we adjust his fielding grade?
Mark Polishuk
DRS still has him at +9, but even that’s down from +22 last year. I’m not sure I’ve watched the Brewers enough to make an eye test evaluation, but put it his way, if you’re a Milwaukee supporter… you’re pretty happily taking this better-hitting version of Turang, right?
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is picking up Carlos Santana a difference maker for the Cubs? Could he help them get to the series?
Mark Polishuk
It’s more of a talent floor raise over Turner.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will Sal Stewart be available for the postseason if the Reds get their act together and make it?
Mark Polishuk
Yep. The August 31 rule only applies to players coming into the organization. Teams can and have called up prospects well after September 1 who have gone to play big roles in the playoffs.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I understand why they reduced the roster size in September, but 28 seems small. Any discussion of maybe expanding to maybe 30 at least?
Mark Polishuk
I’m sure the MLBPA wouldn’t mind having more jobs available for a month. But, I think having having 30 roster spots still gets into the “competitive advantage or disadvantage during pennant races” territory the league and union looked to eliminate when cutting September rosters down from 40.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
It seems like a lot more players are getting released than in years past. Is this because teams are trying to save some prorated salary?
Mark Polishuk
Don’t forget that the rules were changed a few years ago concerning August trades. So since teams can no longer move most players after the deadline, you’re seeing more releases or waiver situations as teams try to clear roster space (and save money).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What do you think is more likely: 8 divisions of 4 teams, or 4 divisions of 8?
Mark Polishuk
It depends on how the geography works out with two expansion cities, plus any lingering possibility that the Rays or A’s might be playing elsewhere than Tampa/St. Pete or in Vegas.
I’d probably prefer four divisions of eight just to add more cache to being a division champion. Yet the league may prefer more divisions and fewer wild card teams, even if some of the wild card clubs’ records will inevitably top some division winners more often than not.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I know you guys did a poll this week on regional realignment if the league expands. What are your personal feelings on the subject?
Mark Polishuk
There is so much tradition within the AL/NL that I want to see that preserved, rather than the weirdness of a “West League” and “East League.” You can rework the geography within the current league alignments and incorporate expansion teams into the mix, but I want to see the AL and NL groupings generally remain intact.
Then again, as a Jays fan, my main priority in any alignment would be to see the Blue Jays get out of any division with the Yankees, Red Sox, and Rays. So if this means the Jays in the NL, bring it on!
-----------------------------------------------------------------
More questions in this one, and I included 4 bonus questions: one about expanded rosters, one about the volume of releases, and 2 about realignment. Enjoy the read!!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/08/ ... at-72.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Ketel Marte the top target to bat cleanup for the Pittsburgh Pirates in 2026?
Mark Polishuk
I find it unlikely that Marte will be dealt anywhere, let alone to a Pittsburgh team that will find his contract too pricey.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Feels like the Giants have a run in them. Only 5 back. Your thoughts?
Mark Polishuk
Interestingly, the Giants only play four more teams for the rest of the season… two series each against the Dodgers, D’Backs, Rockies, and Cardinals.
Those extra games against Colorado in particular are a good chance to make up ground, but realistically, the Giants are probably too far out.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Stewart being called a bit too late to provide the offensive spark the Reds desperately needed over a week ago. Held down for some dumb financial/playing time reason?
Mark Polishuk
The PPI factor was surely on the Reds’ minds to some extent, but don’t forget that Stewart didn’t even make his Triple-A debut until after the All-Star break. It’s understandable how a team would want to give a good prospect some real run at Triple-A before giving him the extra challenge of the big leagues.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What can you see the Pirates doing this offseason? They need bats and have a surplus of good young pitching. I would like to see them add two bats to their lineup.
Mark Polishuk
As much as “you can never have too much pitching” applies, dealing a young arm for a young up-and-coming bat makes a ton of sense for the Pirates. I agree that they need multiple hitters to help get things turned around, and if ownership isn’t going to spend in free agency, then the front office has to be more aggressive on the trade front.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think Marmol will be the Cardinal manager next year?
Mark Polishuk
2026 is the last guaranteed season of Marmol’s contract, so the Cards would be eating just one year of money in the event of a managerial change. Allowing Bloom to pick his own manager would make sense with Bloom fully taking over the front office, and Bloom might welcome this flexibility since he basically inherited Alex Cora in Boston.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Does this Brewers team have what it takes to win it all?
Mark Polishuk
Absolutely. The Brewers are a scary opponent for anyone in October.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Can we now consider Henry Davis a complete 1/1 bust? I see no hope for improvement at the plate.
Mark Polishuk
For the “what should the Pirates do this winter” question earlier, the answer maybe should’ve been an overhaul of their hitting development strategies.
Davis has a 57 wRC+ over 610 career PA, or a little more than the equivalent of one full MLB season. While it’s early to write him off entirely, there haven’t been many or any flashes that Davis is close to breaking out, so that’s a very troubling lack of progress for a player that (as a 1-1 pick) had to be a key building block in a rebuild.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think the Cardinals should move on from Arenado?
Mark Polishuk
They should’ve moved on last winter, and I suspect the front office is still shaking their head of the chain of events that led Arenado to reject that deal to Houston.
Going forward, it’s hard to see much of a trade market for Arenado at all given his salary and how his offense has completely fallen off the table this season.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
At what point does the evaluation of a particular player trait change? Asking re Bruce Turang, whose 40 power grade is looking ridiculous at the moment.
Mark Polishuk
I dunno who this Bruce Turang guy is, but Brice Turang has been on an absolute scorcher for the last month. Don’t be surprised if/when Turang wins NL Player of the Month for August.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah and can we adjust his fielding grade?
Mark Polishuk
DRS still has him at +9, but even that’s down from +22 last year. I’m not sure I’ve watched the Brewers enough to make an eye test evaluation, but put it his way, if you’re a Milwaukee supporter… you’re pretty happily taking this better-hitting version of Turang, right?
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is picking up Carlos Santana a difference maker for the Cubs? Could he help them get to the series?
Mark Polishuk
It’s more of a talent floor raise over Turner.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will Sal Stewart be available for the postseason if the Reds get their act together and make it?
Mark Polishuk
Yep. The August 31 rule only applies to players coming into the organization. Teams can and have called up prospects well after September 1 who have gone to play big roles in the playoffs.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I understand why they reduced the roster size in September, but 28 seems small. Any discussion of maybe expanding to maybe 30 at least?
Mark Polishuk
I’m sure the MLBPA wouldn’t mind having more jobs available for a month. But, I think having having 30 roster spots still gets into the “competitive advantage or disadvantage during pennant races” territory the league and union looked to eliminate when cutting September rosters down from 40.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
It seems like a lot more players are getting released than in years past. Is this because teams are trying to save some prorated salary?
Mark Polishuk
Don’t forget that the rules were changed a few years ago concerning August trades. So since teams can no longer move most players after the deadline, you’re seeing more releases or waiver situations as teams try to clear roster space (and save money).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What do you think is more likely: 8 divisions of 4 teams, or 4 divisions of 8?
Mark Polishuk
It depends on how the geography works out with two expansion cities, plus any lingering possibility that the Rays or A’s might be playing elsewhere than Tampa/St. Pete or in Vegas.
I’d probably prefer four divisions of eight just to add more cache to being a division champion. Yet the league may prefer more divisions and fewer wild card teams, even if some of the wild card clubs’ records will inevitably top some division winners more often than not.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I know you guys did a poll this week on regional realignment if the league expands. What are your personal feelings on the subject?
Mark Polishuk
There is so much tradition within the AL/NL that I want to see that preserved, rather than the weirdness of a “West League” and “East League.” You can rework the geography within the current league alignments and incorporate expansion teams into the mix, but I want to see the AL and NL groupings generally remain intact.
Then again, as a Jays fan, my main priority in any alignment would be to see the Blue Jays get out of any division with the Yankees, Red Sox, and Rays. So if this means the Jays in the NL, bring it on!
-----------------------------------------------------------------