Page 1 of 2

Contreras Ejection and Aftermath

Posted: August 26 25, 10:42 am
by CardsofSTL

St. Louis Cardinals first baseman Willson Contreras was ejected after a strikeout in the seventh inning of Monday’s series opener against the Pittsburgh Pirates. He claims he was ejected after he told the home-plate umpire to “call those pitches both sides.”

Just moments after his seventh-inning strikeout and responding remarks, Contreras was ejected by home plate umpire Derek Thomas.

A major disruption followed. Contreras approached Thomas after the strikeout, visibly frustrated and restrained by manager Oli Marmol and bench coach Daniel Descalso. Contreras exchanged some heated remarks, tossed a bat near the direction of an umpire that ultimately hit Cardinals coach Brant Brown, and then threw a bucket of Hi-Chew fruit chews from the Cardinals dugout onto the field.

Marmol was also ejected after a discussion following the events that transpired.
Contreras shared the following remarks on his point of view around the ejection with media members after Monday’s contest:
“I’m still wondering, to be honest,” Contreras said on why he was tossed. “I don’t think he had a reason to throw me out. I didn’t argue any pitch in any at-bat. I didn’t argue any pitch in my last at-bat. The only thing I said was, ‘call those pitches both sides, because you’re missing for us.’ That was it. Then I turned around. The next thing I hear, he threw me out. He had no reason for it.”

“I knew I struck out on a good pitch. I didn’t argue any of the pitches in any of the at-bats today, because I know he was a good umpire. The only bad thing I said was, ‘call those pitches both sides.’ And that was it. And he kind of surprised me because I know the game, [we were leading] by one [run]. I don’t want to get thrown out in a close game like that.”

Contreras added that he apologized to Cardinals hitting coach Brant Brown for tossing a bat that hit him.

“I apologized to him. I wasn’t looking back, I just threw my bat back, but that was not on purpose,” said Contreras.
Sources indicate that MLB will take harsh action against Contreras most specifically for throwing his bat in the direction of the umpires and that a decision on punishment may be released as early as Tuesday.

FWIW the Umpire Scorecard from last night's game:


Re: Contreras Ejection and Aftermath

Posted: August 26 25, 10:50 am
by CardsofSTL

Re: Contreras Ejection and Aftermath

Posted: August 26 25, 12:00 pm
by heyzeus
He's getting a pretty long suspension, you betcha

Re: Contreras Ejection and Aftermath

Posted: August 26 25, 12:38 pm
by a_smith
It just keeps getting harder and harder to watch this team. I liked watching his ABs. Now I get to see Burlson at 1b.

Re: Contreras Ejection and Aftermath

Posted: August 26 25, 12:43 pm
by CardsofSTL
Robles was suspended 10 games in the minors a few years ago for throwing a bat...I anticipate something along those lines.

Re: Contreras Ejection and Aftermath

Posted: August 26 25, 12:43 pm
by cardsfantx
man, there goes our chance to crawl back into contention

Re: Contreras Ejection and Aftermath

Posted: August 26 25, 1:32 pm
by booger71
The Cardinals batboy is lucky he didn't get ejected

Re: Contreras Ejection and Aftermath

Posted: August 26 25, 2:42 pm
by sighyoung
cardsfantx wrote: ↑
August 26 25, 12:43 pm
man, there goes our chance to crawl back into contention
If, by contention, you mean 'a heated argument,' I'd say we're right in the thick of things.

Re: Contreras Ejection and Aftermath

Posted: August 26 25, 4:41 pm
by mikechamp
heyzeus wrote: ↑
August 26 25, 12:00 pm
He's getting a pretty long suspension, you betcha
6 games and a fine:

https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/08/ ... nsion.html

Re: Contreras Ejection and Aftermath

Posted: August 26 25, 5:39 pm
by booger71
MLB will probably knock it down to 3 games