Inspired by a convo with the one and only @vinsanity, what is the worst song ever by a great band? What is the greatest net discrepancy between how good the band is and how bad the song is?
And also, why is it REM's "Shiny Happy People?"
Re: Worst songs by great bands
Posted: December 7 21, 3:55 pm
by Superorganism
Fitter Happier, Electioneering, Feral, We Suck Young Blood, Fake Plastic Trees are crap.
Re: Worst songs by great bands
Posted: December 7 21, 3:58 pm
by GeddyWrox
Every great band has terrible songs. This is an interesting concept. I'm fascinated.
Even with my own favorite band, Rush... Lots of stinkers to choose from.
I'll go with Tears from 2112. But there are a ton of really bad songs from the 80s and 90s and 00s to choose from too.
Re: Worst songs by great bands
Posted: December 7 21, 4:11 pm
by Popeye_Card
Since there are a lot of throwaway tracks on albums by every band, I'll stick with the more popular ones - songs you might hear on the radio, but immediately switch stations.
For the Beatles, I think we are all in agreement that it is The Long and Winding Road, correct?
Since there are a lot of throwaway tracks on albums by every band, I'll stick with the more popular ones - songs you might hear on the radio, but immediately switch stations.
For the Beatles, I think we are all in agreement that it is The Long and Winding Road, correct?
I wouldn't say TLaWR is one of my favorites by The Fab 4 but I actually do like it a fair amount. I could take or leave a lot of their earliest stuff. Stuff like I Wanna Hold Your Hand, etc.
Since there are a lot of throwaway tracks on albums by every band, I'll stick with the more popular ones - songs you might hear on the radio, but immediately switch stations.
For the Beatles, I think we are all in agreement that it is The Long and Winding Road, correct?
I wouldn't say TLaWR is one of my favorites by The Fab 4 but I actually do like it a fair amount. I could take or leave a lot of their earliest stuff. Stuff like I Wanna Hold Your Hand, etc.
I generally treat everything pre-Rubber Soul as coming from a completely different band that I barely listen to, but while it is poppy I don’t consider any of it “bad” (at least the popular songs). TLaWR (particularly the original Phil Spector version) is sappy and generally awful. Paul at his worst. Watching the Get Back documentary, making the others in the group work on that song may have actually been what broke the band.
Since there are a lot of throwaway tracks on albums by every band, I'll stick with the more popular ones - songs you might hear on the radio, but immediately switch stations.
For the Beatles, I think we are all in agreement that it is The Long and Winding Road, correct?
Run For Your Life off the British Rubber Soil. My jaw dropped listening to it. It's misogyny needs a disclaimer in the 2020s. Just awful.
Since there are a lot of throwaway tracks on albums by every band, I'll stick with the more popular ones - songs you might hear on the radio, but immediately switch stations.
For the Beatles, I think we are all in agreement that it is The Long and Winding Road, correct?
Run For Your Life off the British Rubber Soil. My jaw dropped listening to it. It's misogyny needs a disclaimer in the 2020s. Just awful.
I think John hated it. Partially because he grabbed a line or two from, who, Elvis? I can't quite remember. But, yeah, the other lyrics too. But I have to say, it's still a pretty cool song.
The Long and Winding Road...yes, the Spector treatment didn't age well. I can't listen to it but I don't know if I'd pick it as their worst.
If you guys are avoiding pre Rubber Soul, you're missing a lot.
Oh, That Means a Lot is a Paul song that might have been their worst ever if it had been released. Only redeeming part is the ending.
Re: Worst songs by great bands
Posted: December 8 21, 8:14 am
by AWvsCBsteeeerike3
Maybe not by a great band, but honky tonk badonkadonk killed country music...for me at least. And should largely be considered the worst song to ever be recorded.