Page 1 of 1

Writers vs Agencies in Hollywood

Posted: April 19 19, 10:22 am
by ghostrunner
This is an interesting story that's been brewing the past month or so, and the big news the past week is that most writers have "fired" their agencies.

https://prospect.org/article/how-privat ... bM.twitter
Previously, these organizations were partnerships under the control of the agents themselves; today, “the top three agencies now operate under the pressure of private-equity-level profit expectations,” the report explains.

That translates into an affinity for something known as “packaging” fees, direct payments from studios to talent agencies as a kind of commission for employing their clients. “Packaging” is a bit of a misnomer, as even one client of an agency can trigger this studio fee. The WGA estimates that about 90 percent of the 2016-2017 television season’s scripted programs were packaged. WME earned $138 million from packaging fees in 2013 alone, according to financial statements.

Clients do not share in these packaging fees, though the fees substitute for the agent’s usual 10 percent commission. However, packaging fees are considered part of the budget of a television or film production, and can stretch into the millions of dollars. That means that the agent is bartering with the studio over a fee that comes out of the same pot of money as the writer’s pay.

Because agencies bring with them actors, directors, and other premium talent, they can bargain for higher packaging fees. Maybe all those clients aren’t packaged in one project, but the studio would want to keep an agency happy for future considerations. “Agency success is severed from client income,” the WGA report states, which undermines the entire purpose of writers hiring agents to operate in their interests.

The Association of Talent Agents has claimed that writers make more money because of packaging fees, but the WGA doesn’t buy it. The union has cited surveys that median weekly earnings of television writers and producers fell 23 percent between 2014 and 2016, at a time of “Peak TV” production (nearly 500 shows were produced in the United States last year) when writers’ services are needed more than ever. In recent negotiations, agents offered cutting writers into the deal, barely, by granting them an almost insulting 1 percent of packaging-fee profits. The WGA rebuffed that.

Agencies have cultivated other revenue streams apart from client fees as well. WME and CAA in particular have focused on purchasing content, which their private equity owners have encouraged.

For example, WME and Silver Lake have purchased the mixed martial arts company UFC, the Miss Universe pageant, the Professional Bull Riders association, and IMG, which produces and distributes sports and nonfiction entertainment. WME also now has its own film and TV production arm, built through acquisitions of other production companies, which has sold shows and films to Paramount, Apple, and Amazon. The company’s revenue has increased sixfold over the past four years. Under TPG’s leadership, CAA has also moved into producing programming for Apple and Facebook. The agency has also created a $500 million investment fund for content called Evolution Media.

Again, these are talent agencies that are supposed to be operating in the best interest of their clients. Having moved into production, they now often serve as their clients’ employers, which the WGA calls an “indefensible conflict of interest.” Typically producers want to lower labor costs, while agents sign clients with the intention of maximizing their income.

The agencies have made out well from private equity investment and expansion. TPG’s stake in CAA has tripled in valuation in a matter of years, and top executives at the agency have earned more than $250 million from the TPG deal. Silver Lake has nearly doubled its investment in WME, with valuation of the company exploding to $5.7 billion at the end of 2017, up from $833 million just five years earlier.

Some minor agencies have signed the WGA’s code of conduct, which basically restricts the agencies to representing their clients. With the major agencies rejecting this, however, many writers will probably try to have their managers and lawyers negotiate contracts for them. The large agencies have threatened to sue if writers go forward with this, saying that the managers and lawyers would be performing agent duties without a license.