Page 1 of 1

snow tires

Posted: November 9 18, 10:04 am
by Gashouse
Is having a set of snow tires worth it? Is the traction that much better? I've never done it because of the combined cost of extra set of tires; cost to change tires in spring/fall; and making space to store tires.

Need new tires for our van anyway, so at least considering getting snow tires. It is the primary vehicle we use for transporting kids, so safety (better traction) is a big consideration.

Re: snow tires

Posted: November 9 18, 10:20 am
by stlouie_lipp
I will say that new ires do make a difference in the snow. I didn't realize they still made snow tires?

Re: snow tires

Posted: November 9 18, 10:40 am
by Gashouse
yes they do. I posted the same question on FB and plenty of MN and MI folks swear by snow tires. A friend in Norway says they are mandatory, with a big fine and loss of license if you don't use snow "tyres".

So, apparently I'm shopping for some snow tires and a set of rims.

Re: snow tires

Posted: November 9 18, 10:40 am
by Swirls
Personally, I've found whether or not you need winter tires to be more a factor of what your drivetrain is. If you have AWD or 4WD, your standard all season tires are fine 99% of the time (even here in Minnesota). If you have FWD or RWD, winter tires aren't a terrible idea.

I've found it's usually more efficient if you can get an additional set of rims (buy a crappy set on Craigslist or eBay for $50 since they're for winter and are going to be destroyed by salt anyway). That way they can be permanently mounted and balanced already and you can theoretically change them yourself. After the first time mounting/balancing they'll have paid for themselves.

That's if you want winter tires. I typically just use all season tires year round, as the wife and I both have AWD vehicles.

If you go to tirerack.com, you can pull up rankings for tires, where they'll compare your selected style in a particular brand/model (such as "high performance all season" or "grand touring summer" etc) against all of the other brands/models in that genre - you'll usually see 15-20 brands in each style. Part of the rankings are how well those tires perform in ice, deep snow, and light snow. When I buy a new set of all season tires, I swear by those rankings for how they do in winter.

Plus, as a bonus, Tire Rack has a distribution center here in Roseville, so you can pick them up for free roughly a half hour after ordering online and save yourself the $100ish shipping fee. :)

Re: snow tires

Posted: November 9 18, 10:58 am
by Gashouse
I was hoping you'd chime in. Thanks for the rec on tirerack.

Honda Odyssey with FWD. We also live in the burbs where they didn't grade the streets to be relatively flat like our old neighborhood in S. Mpls was. So winter traction has become a bigger issue for us.

Re: snow tires

Posted: November 9 18, 11:47 am
by Swirls
In that case I would recommend probably getting a set of snow tires. You can probably find a set of used ones on Craigslist.

I'd check on your bolt pattern online at a place like this: https://tiresize.com/bolt-pattern-finder/

I have a set of rims that are 5-100mm that don't fit my car (they were pre-mounted on a set of tires that fit my car, though). If they'll match your van, you're welcome to have them for free if you're willing to make the drive to the south metro (Eagan/Rosemount area).

Re: snow tires

Posted: November 9 18, 12:35 pm
by Gashouse
5-120mm, unfortunately.

Re: snow tires

Posted: November 9 18, 2:14 pm
by Swirls
Damn. Mine are 5-115mm, so I hear your pain. You can probably still find a set for fairly cheap on Craigslist - if you buy them from Tire Rack as a package with your tires, they'll come pre-mounted and balanced, which is nice.

Re: snow tires

Posted: November 11 18, 5:26 am
by JoeMcKim
At least here in St. Louis we only really get 1 maybe 2 real snows a year so needing snow tires isn't really that important here. If you go up a little further north like Detroit or Minneapolis then yes.