Page 1 of 2

Protection Plans/Extended Warranty

Posted: October 20 18, 8:00 pm
by stlouie_lipp
I'm buying a whole new entertainment system set-up through Best Buy. Spending more than I should and getting more than I need, but whatever, it will be nice. Do you guys buy the protection plans for such purchases, or are they scams? I'm on the fence on this.

Help me GRB, you're my only hope.

Re: Protection Plans/Extended Warranty

Posted: October 20 18, 9:40 pm
by CardsofSTL
A lot of retailers tend to make their money on warranty sales versus product sales; because competition keeps everything priced pretty evenly for the most part. Not sure if that would be the case with Best Buy...but to me it depends on how long the warranty lasts. If it's lifetime or what seems like a good amount of time I would do it; if it is one or two years then I figure it isn't worth it. Regardless...if you need it you will be glad you bought it.

Re: Protection Plans/Extended Warranty

Posted: October 20 18, 11:09 pm
by IMADreamer
Absolutely never. Always a scam.

Re: Protection Plans/Extended Warranty

Posted: October 20 18, 11:33 pm
by cardsfantx
Nope

Re: Protection Plans/Extended Warranty

Posted: October 21 18, 12:48 am
by AdmiralKird
Almost always no, but I put one on our last modem because the previous one got blown out in a lightning strike. The additional $5 or whatever for a $70 device that has itself a tiny warranty and probably poor internal surge protection was worth the price in this instance.

Re: Protection Plans/Extended Warranty

Posted: October 21 18, 1:04 pm
by Freed Roger
Another nope.

Re: Protection Plans/Extended Warranty

Posted: October 21 18, 1:04 pm
by Freed Roger
Another nope.

Re: Protection Plans/Extended Warranty

Posted: October 21 18, 3:11 pm
by cardsfansince82
I generally say no, but every once in a while I will do one if the cost is really low compared to what is covered or there's some kind of added benefit. I bought a new mower at the beginning of the year and it was only $50 more for the protection plan, but that extended the warranty to four years from one and included a free yearly tune up at any certified dealer for all four years. I figured just the tune ups alone made that worth it. I probably couldn't find anyone to work on it even once for less than that. I haven't actually used it yet (waiting till mowing season is over) but I read all the fine print and asked a bunch of questions. I might have to pay a reduced price for replacement blades, but the labor and everything else is covered.

For electronics I'm almost always no. I usually just assume that if something is wrong it's wrong right away or within the factory warranty period. It can be painful to pay an extra 10+% or whatever on stuff that's priced high to begin with for something you almost never end up needing. But if you are spending big money already and are comfortable with the extra cost and what it covers, it might be worth having the peace of mind.

Re: Protection Plans/Extended Warranty

Posted: October 21 18, 3:48 pm
by Socnorb11
There's a reason they try to sell the extended plans. It's a moneymaker for them, which means it's a loser for the consumer.

Don't do it.

Re: Protection Plans/Extended Warranty

Posted: October 21 18, 4:19 pm
by stlouie_lipp
Yeah, this confirms my thoughts on them. Some people like the piece of mind, but I think like 82, if it's defective you'll know it right away.