Page 1 of 4

Poll: Are fish and shellfish a different thing?

Posted: February 14 18, 12:38 pm
by JL21
When referring to shellfish (crab, lobster, shrimp, clams, scallops, mussels, crawdads, etc.), I never ever refer to it as just "fish." And when I say "fish", I never mean it to include the other stuff. But realistically, it is a type of fish. And I know some folks who use them that way. They will say "fish" as a catch-all that includes shellfish.

So what say you, GRB? Are the two terms interchangeable? Do you use "fish" when talking about lobster or crab or shrimp?

Re: Poll: Are fish and shellfish a different thing?

Posted: February 14 18, 12:41 pm
by wart57
Shellfish are just greedy fish...

Re: Poll: Are fish and shellfish a different thing?

Posted: February 14 18, 12:42 pm
by Tim
Yes, they are different. People are often allergic to shellfish and not other fish. Very different.

Re: Poll: Are fish and shellfish a different thing?

Posted: February 14 18, 1:02 pm
by Joe Shlabotnik
what Tim said.

Re: Poll: Are fish and shellfish a different thing?

Posted: February 14 18, 1:03 pm
by heyzeus
Totally different. According to the nonsensical dietary restrictions of my forbears, one is totally cool for noshing, whereas eating the other one condemns you to an afterlife of hellfire - if we believed in hell, that is.

Re: Poll: Are fish and shellfish a different thing?

Posted: February 14 18, 1:04 pm
by Arthur Dent
JL21 wrote:When referring to shellfish (crab, lobster, shrimp, clams, scallops, mussels, crawdads, etc.), I never ever refer to it as just "fish." And when I say "fish", I never mean it to include the other stuff. But realistically, it is a type of fish.
Crazy talk. A crab isn't a type of fish. That said, I bet I've said "seafood" referring to trout or something.

Re: Poll: Are fish and shellfish a different thing?

Posted: February 14 18, 1:28 pm
by Freed Roger
JL21 wrote:When referring to shellfish (crab, lobster, shrimp, clams, scallops, mussels, crawdads, etc.), I never ever refer to it as just "fish." And when I say "fish", I never mean it to include the other stuff. But realistically, it is a type of fish. And I know some folks who use them that way. They will say "fish" as a catch-all that includes shellfish.

So what say you, GRB? Are the two terms interchangeable? Do you use "fish" when talking about lobster or crab or shrimp?
different. If you are calling lobster etal a fish, then what do you call turtles, frogs, and other creatures that spend most their time in the water?

Another point:
people allergic to shellfish know the difference.

Why don't you just call it all seafood? ....but then again, some of this comes from freshwater? head scratch. Edit, and now I see Zeus covered this.

Does this have something to do with Lent?

Re: Poll: Are fish and shellfish a different thing?

Posted: February 14 18, 1:41 pm
by G. Keenan
Of course they are different and anyone who says otherwise is a moran.

I'll add to this, people who refer to themselves as vegetarians, but eat fish and/or shellfish. You are not a vegetarian if you eat the flesh of any kind of animal. I see this all the time though and it drives me crazy.

Re: Poll: Are fish and shellfish a different thing?

Posted: February 14 18, 1:54 pm
by davhern
They are entirely separate things and the term that encompasses both would be "seafood," as someone already mentioned.

Re: Poll: Are fish and shellfish a different thing?

Posted: February 14 18, 1:55 pm
by stlouie_lipp
Aren't shellfish technically crustaceans?