Page 1 of 3

Salary/Benefits negotiation

Posted: January 23 18, 7:37 pm
by go birds
I feel like ive made thread a million times, but after doing a search, i couldnt find it so im just starting a new one.

I was extended an offer this afternoon and while the benefits package is nice, the salary is slightly under what i was hoping for.

Can anyone offer advice on negotiating a higher salary?

Full disclosure, when going thru the initial screening process, they forced a range out of me, much to my chagrin. They DID meet me in the middle of that, but honestly i do want to see if i can get the top of that range.

Would it be unwise of me to counter with a little above the top end of the range?

I need to add that when HR extended the offer, they didn't say it was firm, so is this a sign that it's negotiable? I thought about just outright asking her if the salary is negotiable, but didnt know how that would fly.

Also, one my perks with my current company is i am able to work remote for part of the week. It is my understanding that at the new company, people have the option to work remote, so i definitely want to work that into the package before i accept. I feel like that isn't too much to ask.

Any advice/insight?

Re: Salary/Benefits negotiation

Posted: January 24 18, 8:48 am
by vinsanity
In general, I'd look at every offer as negotiable even if they say it's firm - there are other things you can you negotiate.

When I got my last job offer it was a big raise but less than what my referring contact said I should be asking for. Zeus basically gave me this template:
I appreciate the offer and am excited about working at Acme Inc but I feel it is slightly below market for the position (or someone of my qualifications or someone with my experience - whichever you're more comfortable citing). Would it be possible for the salary to be $1,000,000?
I sent that exact email and less than 3 hours later I had it approved. If the top of your range is what you think is fair I'd use that number instead of intentionally inflating it expecting them to counter.

Finding qualified candidates is difficult and expensive and once they find someone they like they are unlikely to pull an offer because you asked for more money. I've had multiple employers tell me to never take the first offer as well. They're also in the business of making money and unlikely to offer you the top amount they are willing to. I've never heard of a company rescinding an offer because someone asked for more money. At worst they'll say that's all they can afford to pay that for the position and the current offer is the best they can do.

Re: Salary/Benefits negotiation

Posted: January 24 18, 9:14 am
by Swirls
Or take the lower salary but negotiate other terms. I've succeeded in the past at getting an extra week of paid vacation. Or when relocating (which I suspect you're not doing), getting the new employer to pay full relocation expenses as well as put me up in a hotel for a month or two while looking for a place, etc.

Re: Salary/Benefits negotiation

Posted: January 24 18, 9:18 am
by go birds
Thanks for the responses (possibly again)--it was what i was hoping to hear.

I feel like timing is of the essence here so i may just go ahead and counter, but what do you guys think is an acceptable amount of time to counter.

I received the offer yesterday afternoon and told her I'd like to have some time to mull it over, but since they were eager to get me in ASAP, i'd let them know by thursday.

I'm sitting here with my response ready to go. Should i hold out for a little bit longer or just go ahead and give them my counter?

Re: Salary/Benefits negotiation

Posted: January 24 18, 9:34 am
by Popeye_Card
How large of company is it? The larger the company, the more likely that they have a pretty rigid salary structure they need to maintain.

However if that's the case, they will probably let you know that they don't really have any room for negotiation, and it won't work against you to have asked.

Re: Salary/Benefits negotiation

Posted: January 24 18, 9:44 am
by go birds
Popeye_Card wrote:How large of company is it? The larger the company, the more likely that they have a pretty rigid salary structure they need to maintain.

However if that's the case, they will probably let you know that they don't really have any room for negotiation, and it won't work against you to have asked.
~15000 people

I guess my fear is the rescission of an offer because i'm countering, because if i'm being honest, the offer is nice as is. For certain reasons, i would like a bigger salary, but i'd be totally happy with their offer.

Really, the sticking point with me is the ability to work remote, which is a perk that could be added in lieu of more money. I've made sure to express that in my counter response.

Re: Salary/Benefits negotiation

Posted: January 24 18, 9:47 am
by Michael
vinsanity wrote:In general, I'd look at every offer as negotiable even if they say it's firm - there are other things you can you negotiate.

When I got my last job offer it was a big raise but less than what my referring contact said I should be asking for. Zeus basically gave me this template:
I appreciate the offer and am excited about working at Acme Inc but I feel it is slightly below market for the position (or someone of my qualifications or someone with my experience - whichever you're more comfortable citing). Would it be possible for the salary to be $1,000,000?
I sent that exact email and less than 3 hours later I had it approved. If the top of your range is what you think is fair I'd use that number instead of intentionally inflating it expecting them to counter.

Finding qualified candidates is difficult and expensive and once they find someone they like they are unlikely to pull an offer because you asked for more money. I've had multiple employers tell me to never take the first offer as well. They're also in the business of making money and unlikely to offer you the top amount they are willing to. I've never heard of a company rescinding an offer because someone asked for more money. At worst they'll say that's all they can afford to pay that for the position and the current offer is the best they can do.
Great post.

I regret not negotiating more earlier in my career.

Re: Salary/Benefits negotiation

Posted: January 24 18, 10:33 am
by Transmogrified Tiger

Re: Salary/Benefits negotiation

Posted: January 24 18, 10:38 am
by vinsanity
Michael wrote:I regret not negotiating more earlier in my career.
Agreed; when I started my third job they I made the same mistake as Go Birds and told them my current salary and that's what they offered. I wanted the position enough I didn't negotiate and never got bonuses or raises to make up for it. It was, ironically, the owner of that company that was the first to tell me to never take the first offer in any negotiation.
go birds wrote:I guess my fear is the rescission of an offer because i'm countering...I'm sitting here with my response ready to go. Should i hold out for a little bit longer or just go ahead and give them my counter?
I really wouldn't worry about the first part or the timing. For one, it's difficult to find a candidate and it's expensive to hire/fire someone. If they rescind the offer, they're removing you as a candidate. They won't go with their second choice just because you felt you deserved more. They'll just say the offer is the best they can do or that they can certainly expand your remote working ability.

There's no good reason to wait on your response. They have a position they'd like to fill quickly; I'd say being prompt with a response works more in your favor.

Re: Salary/Benefits negotiation

Posted: January 24 18, 7:56 pm
by CardsofSTL
Generally speaking in my experience; employers don't give you their best offer initially so I think proposing a counter is more than reasonable and shouldn't affect the fact that they want to hire you. If you gave them a range; I would say no reason not to ask for something closer to the top of the range you provided.