Page 1 of 2
When to give up on a car
Posted: September 8 17, 12:49 pm
by Arthur Dent
We've got a 2007 GTI that has been a giant money pit disaster the last two years. My metric has been that if a repair costs less that the blue book value of the working car, you should probably repair. But the problem is even if individual repairs meet that criteria, summing them up over that period, it's about equal prior to the latest incident. Now the clutch has failed taking the flywheel with it to the tune of $2600 (dealership). Blue book is ~$6000. I think I'm done, but I'm curious how others think about these things and try to guess what future repairs will cost.
Re: When to give up on a car
Posted: September 8 17, 12:57 pm
by GeddyWrox
How many miles?
Re: When to give up on a car
Posted: September 8 17, 1:09 pm
by CardsofSTL
I hate dealing with auto repairs; so if I had to have mine in the shop for more than routine maintenance more than once in a year; I'd get something else. But I am probably not typical in that regard. I think generally speaking; I would look at the car and decide if this repair is going to give me an X amount of time without having to have more repairs; or is this only one of what will probably be several more repairs that I will need over the next 1 or 2 years. If its the latter I am definitely looking for a different ride.
Re: When to give up on a car
Posted: September 8 17, 1:14 pm
by Arthur Dent
GeddyWrox wrote:How many miles?
I forget, but it's not that many. Well under 100k.
Re: When to give up on a car
Posted: September 8 17, 1:17 pm
by GeddyWrox
I'd be tempted to keep it then, as long as there aren't any signs of other major issues.
My 2012 Escape has 121xxx miles now, and I hope to drive it for several more years. But the transmission has been gradually acting up more and more over the last few years. If the tranny goes, I might have to punt.
Re: When to give up on a car
Posted: September 8 17, 1:53 pm
by Leroy
My criteria is if it is a chick magnet, any amount of repairs is worth it.
Re: When to give up on a car
Posted: September 8 17, 1:57 pm
by GeddyWrox
Truth.
Re: When to give up on a car
Posted: September 8 17, 2:25 pm
by AWvsCBsteeeerike3
Arthur Dent wrote:We've got a 2007 GTI that has been a giant money pit disaster the last two years. My metric has been that if a repair costs less that the blue book value of the working car, you should probably repair. But the problem is even if individual repairs meet that criteria, summing them up over that period, it's about equal prior to the latest incident. Now the clutch has failed taking the flywheel with it to the tune of $2600 (dealership). Blue book is ~$6000. I think I'm done, but I'm curious how others think about these things and try to guess what future repairs will cost.
Aren't you basically stuck the $2600 anyway (although it is probably cheaper to get it done somewhere other than the dealership if you want to go that route)? If you don't repair it, and the value is $6k, no one is going to pay the $6k. You'd be better off getting it fixed and then selling it, imo.
People that buy fixer uppers, I'd think, are doing it to make a profit and if you're only discounting the repair price from the value, then there's no margin for them. Maybe if the price of parts is $1k you can get $4k for it or so....I don't know.
Just my 2 cents, but I'd bite the bullet and fix it, then re-evaluate.
Re: When to give up on a car
Posted: September 8 17, 3:54 pm
by JoeMcKim
Whenever the repair costs come close to how much you'll be paying on your car bill for that year. If you have to pay for example $2500 on your loan in that year and have to pay over under $800-1000 on repairs then its justified to keep yourself from starting a new auto loan again, if you're paying more then that then its time to probably just get a new car.
Re: When to give up on a car
Posted: September 11 17, 8:11 am
by cardinalkarp
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:Arthur Dent wrote:We've got a 2007 GTI that has been a giant money pit disaster the last two years. My metric has been that if a repair costs less that the blue book value of the working car, you should probably repair. But the problem is even if individual repairs meet that criteria, summing them up over that period, it's about equal prior to the latest incident. Now the clutch has failed taking the flywheel with it to the tune of $2600 (dealership). Blue book is ~$6000. I think I'm done, but I'm curious how others think about these things and try to guess what future repairs will cost.
Aren't you basically stuck the $2600 anyway (although it is probably cheaper to get it done somewhere other than the dealership if you want to go that route)? If you don't repair it, and the value is $6k, no one is going to pay the $6k. You'd be better off getting it fixed and then selling it, imo.
People that buy fixer uppers, I'd think, are doing it to make a profit and if you're only discounting the repair price from the value, then there's no margin for them. Maybe if the price of parts is $1k you can get $4k for it or so....I don't know.
Just my 2 cents, but I'd bite the bullet and fix it, then re-evaluate.
This pretty much sums it up, even if you trade it in for a new car any dealership taking it will take that amount directly off the KBB value....and that's already after they try to screw you on the trade in value to begin with.
Did you happen to buy this thing brand new or used?....because if it's well under 100k it's surprising it's burned through a clutch that quickly.