Page 1 of 4
Dropping out of grad school (update p3: I'm stuck)
Posted: April 11 17, 7:27 pm
by Schlich
I should do it, right?
Just not sure a life in academia is right for me anymore. Between the terrible job market, the long hours, the bullcrap hoops, the inability to pursue my hobbies without feeling guilty about it, the relative worthlessness i feel like my contribution to society is... just doesnt seem worth it anymore. I will miss the intellectual challenge and the autonomy. I'll still get a masters if I drop out. Probably will try to get a job programming somewhere local and go from there.
Gonna try to talk to my adviser sometime this week. Just a big step, and it sucks feeling like a quitter (and like i'd be letting my adviser down).
Re: Dropping out of grad school
Posted: April 11 17, 8:05 pm
by Michael
Sounds like you've already made your decision.
What did you study as an undergrad? What are you studying now?
Regardless of the direction you take I sincerely wish you the best.
Re: Dropping out of grad school
Posted: April 11 17, 8:31 pm
by Schlich
Michael wrote:Sounds like you've already made your decision.
What did you study as an undergrad? What are you studying now?
Regardless of the direction you take I sincerely wish you the best.
I was Biomedical Engineering in undergrad, compsci minor, now in a Biomedical Engineering program and study neural interfaces in particular. It feels like i'm doing the coolest research in the world, which just makes the slow tediousness of grad school and independent research in general all the more frustrating. I might have abstract regrets someday that I didn't follow it through till I couldn't do it anymore, but I feel like the chances are much more likely that if i finished I'd just be sitting 3 years from now with the degree and no clear path in academia, wondering why i put myself through the misery. And I genuinely think i'd enjoy a career in programming, it's always been my favorite part of what i do, and yet I'm still not really that good at it.
Thanks for the well-wishes.
Re: Dropping out of grad school
Posted: April 11 17, 8:33 pm
by Schlich
I'm also worried that i'm being extremely rash about this. I've had "ha-ha i wanna drop out" commiseration with my cohort as we all have, but the last week or so it's been real and it's just made more sense the more i think about it. My mood seems to change every week though. Really probably just need to wait on what my adviser has to say.
Re: Dropping out of grad school
Posted: April 11 17, 8:49 pm
by Michael
You're in a smart guy field so moving in to IT won't be a stretch. That's good for interviews.
What languages are you using?
Here's one issue I see with your plan:
Schlich wrote:the relative worthlessness i feel like my contribution to society is
Programming will not help with this at all. If anything else it will be worse.
Re: Dropping out of grad school
Posted: April 11 17, 9:02 pm
by AWvsCBsteeeerike3
It's always good to question what you're doing and where you're going. So, it's perfectly natural to be in this position, most likely.
Sounds like you're doing the right thing in talking to your adviser about this. And, really, I don't even have the foggiest what you're talking about when you explain what you're doing.
But, my .02 would be to figure out what it is you like to do (be it studying neural interfaces and finding applications for that or be it programming or be it living in a van down by the river) and then working towards making that possible. Obviously, certain things/paths are going to take more schooling than others and some are going to take less. Whatever it is you want to do, basing that decision on money alone or with money as a large factor is probably not the best way to go about it.
Regardless, I'll echo Michael's sentiment and wish you the best.
Re: Dropping out of grad school
Posted: April 11 17, 9:10 pm
by Joe Shlabotnik
Can you play LF Schlich?
Follow your heart and do what you love to do. If what you're doing in grad school isn't cutting it, look for another open door. Hell, run for congress or something. God knows it needs people like you.
Re: Dropping out of grad school
Posted: April 11 17, 9:16 pm
by sighyoung
First, don't define yourself based on anyone else's standards or timetables or metrics. This is all about where you thrive and what you're interested in. If academia drives you up the wall or bores you to tears, well, it does. I'm glad you're getting a degree out of it.
Who knows, a conversation with your mentor may change things, but at the same time, academia isn't for everyone. Grad school tries to break people down and mold them into the image of a "scholar," and that gets old and tiresome very fast. Academic politics can be a complete headache. Leaving is probably a sign that you're sane.
Look, I had a friend in a doctoral program in Musicology who stayed in it for seventeen years. SEVENTEEN YEARS. He finally realized that he was never going to write his thesis because he hated it, and accepted that all the other stuff he was doing in the meantime was, indeed, what he wanted to be doing. And he is happy, decently remunerated, and doing just fine, thank you.
Additionally, while my life as a professor is nice, it's easy for me to say that because I'm on the other side, and I've probably repressed so much that I wake up screaming. It doesn't mean that the bridges that were there when I crossed over are still in place. It's frankly more difficult and competitive in academia than when I graduated and got a job.
It's natural, if you stay in school for years, to think that the next degree on the horizon is the appropriate next step, and anything short of it is failure. But that's just not true, and life's too short to waste time trying to fit into an abstract concept of success.
Just weigh your options carefully, is all I would say. Lots of people in your position have had second, third, even fiftieth thoughts. Some stayed, some left. Most made the right choice for them.
But please don't think of your time in grad school as a sunken cost that necessitates more of your time and effort. Stay only because you really like it, or have something to do that can really please you enough to put up with the other crap that goes along with academia.
Re: Dropping out of grad school
Posted: April 11 17, 9:23 pm
by Schlich
I think the left fielding gig is more likely than a congressional run at this point in time, but i'll tuck that into my back pocket for now. Thanks for the kind words
One of the sucky things about quitting is that I do love the work i do, as far as the subject matter is concerned. But love for the subject matter isn't enough to be a good fit for academia, i think. I'm curious about what sigh might have to say.
(Michael, most of the stuff we're working on is in MATLAB, which is just a simple high level language with lots of libraries for scientific data. Unfortunately it encourages a lot of bad programming habits. Most of our other stuff is in C++ though my contributions were all minor edits. I could hold my own in pretty much any of the big languages to start out, but i'm definitely a fixer-upper. My computer science education was a lot more math and algorithm-heavy and less learning best coding practices a la object-oriented design. I'm curious about your last comment if you care to elaborate.)
edit: and there he is, on cue
Re: Dropping out of grad school
Posted: April 11 17, 9:49 pm
by Arthur Dent
Schlich wrote:I'll still get a masters if I drop out.
I did this and have no regrets about it.
In my case, I was miserable enough that I was willing to drop out with nothing, but my adviser was happy to keep me on for the 6 additional months or so I needed to complete my masters. I was so terrified and self-absorbed about informing my adviser of my choice, that I didn't get a great read, but in retrospect, I don't think she was particularly surprised, and was completely supportive, setting me up with a number of interviews with her corporate contacts, etc.
In terms of jobs, there can, in some cases, actually be an upside to having not having a PhD as employers' have some negative ideas of what PhDs are like and will often also often reject you as overqualified with one. Theoretically, a PhD is better, but in my experience, a lot of other factors are more important, especially labor market conditions when you graduate.
Anyway, it also sounds to me like you've really already made up your mind. If you're like me, and probably most people, you avoid making these kind of major changes past the point where deep down you know you should. At the point where you're willing to truly accept the choice, it's about having confidence in your own ability to know what's best for yourself.