Page 1 of 1

Round 1: "Africa" vs "The Thong Song" *CLOSED*

Posted: January 29 17, 6:00 pm
by Swirls
http://challonge.com/grb_cover_tourney has all the tourney info.

Round 1:

BW23's "Africa" by Mike Masse


Swirls' "The Thong Song" by The Ghost Of Patrick Swayze

Re: Round 1: "Africa" vs "The Thong Song"

Posted: January 29 17, 8:39 pm
by AWvsCBsteeeerike3
When I think of cover songs, both of these songs epitomize exactly what I think of.

Re: Round 1: "Africa" vs "The Thong Song"

Posted: January 30 17, 4:54 am
by AdmiralKird
I came to vote for Africa. Left voting for The Thong Song, not that the Africa cover was bad, but I felt like TTS Cover was highly transformative in both a comical and well-sung way, and the Africa one didn't feature the high pitch on "rAINs" which is almost the defining moment of the song for me besides the baseline.

Re: Round 1: "Africa" vs "The Thong Song"

Posted: January 30 17, 7:02 am
by Swirls
"Let me see that tho-o-ong. Baby! That thong thong thong thong thong..."

Re: Round 1: "Africa" vs "The Thong Song"

Posted: January 30 17, 10:09 am
by heyzeus
Maybe it's a prejudice, but I really really dislike ironic covers of black music by white hipsters. It just seems yucky in a culturally appropriative, smarmy kind of way. Even though they're often clever and enjoyable.

Re: Round 1: "Africa" vs "The Thong Song"

Posted: January 30 17, 1:01 pm
by BW23
Africa is what made Masse a YouTube hit. I dig his covers mainly for the songs themselves, but he's got a classic rock kind of voice which, frankly, is good for just about the only thing he is actually doing with it. And Africa was something we sung in 7th grade music class concert. Our teacher was a Toto fan, and the song always makes me think of him.

The interesting thing on Masse is that he's an attorney that used to just sing in a pizza joint for fun. I don't think he practices law now but makes money doing covers, so he must be doing okay financially.

Re: Round 1: "Africa" vs "The Thong Song"

Posted: January 30 17, 1:25 pm
by lukethedrifter
Low did a more interesting cover of Africa.

Re: Round 1: "Africa" vs "The Thong Song"

Posted: January 30 17, 4:33 pm
by GeddyWrox
Anyone wearing a RUSH t-shirt gets my vote.

Re: Round 1: "Africa" vs "The Thong Song"

Posted: January 31 17, 8:44 pm
by Swirls
ROUND CLOSED!

Congrats BW23! "Africa" advances to the 2nd round!