Page 1 of 12
Overrated or Underrated
Posted: August 24 16, 9:30 am
by Swirls
So the Mike Stanton overrated/underrated discussion in Baseball Talk got me to thinking of a game that could be fun.
You list something, and the person to reply has to say whether they think it's overrated or underrated. They can give a couple sentences with their rationale. Then they list something and the next user says whether it's over or underrated. It can be anything - food, sports, pornstars (no links, please), video game series, etc
e.g. The Little Dipper
Verdict: Underrated
Rationale: The guy is always being passed up by its big brother Ursa Major. But it's the one who has the North Star, as such, it's severely underrated.
Re: Overrated or Underrated
Posted: August 24 16, 10:02 am
by wart57
Swirls wrote:So the Mike Stanton overrated/underrated discussion in Baseball Talk got me to thinking of a game that could be fun.
You list something, and the person to reply has to say whether they think it's overrated or underrated. They can give a couple sentences with their rationale. Then they list something and the next user says whether it's over or underrated. It can be anything - food, sports, pornstars (no links, please), video game series, etc
e.g. The Little Dipper
Verdict: Underrated
Rationale: The guy is always being passed up by its big brother Ursa Major. But it's the one who has the North Star, as such, it's severely underrated.
The Little dipper is overrated - it is Ursa Minor, or the little bear. Another name for a little bear is a cub. I hate cubs.
Tesla - the band not the car company.
Re: Overrated or Underrated
Posted: August 24 16, 10:19 am
by tlombard
I don't have an opinion on Tesla yet (maybe will listen to them in a few and try to gauge the perception of them so I can answer) but Wart's logic used in his rebuttal is definitely underrated.
Re: Overrated or Underrated
Posted: August 24 16, 11:21 am
by Swirls
Tesla is definitely underrated. Modern Cowboy is a song that is criminally underplayed on SiriusXM Hair Nation.
Crawdads
Re: Overrated or Underrated
Posted: August 24 16, 11:29 am
by 33anda3rd
Crawdads are overrated because they are too much work for too little reward.
Tesla: the man, not the band or the car.
Re: Overrated or Underrated
Posted: August 24 16, 11:30 am
by AWvsCBsteeeerike3
Tesla the man is underrated, obviously.
Crawdads are overrated as a food while boils are underrated as a social experience.
Re: Overrated or Underrated
Posted: August 24 16, 11:34 am
by wart57
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:Tesla the man is underrated, obviously.
Crawdads are overrated as a food while boils are underrated as a social experience.
Crawfish etouffee is underated. I mean, just look at it.
This:

Re: Overrated or Underrated
Posted: August 24 16, 12:16 pm
by Swirls
Heineken is overrated as a lager.
But, I read that KLM airlines is now offering it on tap on flights. So, having beer available on draught is underrated.
Paper clips
Re: Overrated or Underrated
Posted: August 24 16, 12:59 pm
by Jocephus
Re: Overrated or Underrated
Posted: August 24 16, 1:06 pm
by heyzeus
Paper clips are overrated. I wouldn't have this drawer full of several hundred of them otherwise. Also, they are very easily bent, then become worthless.
Next: The Olympics