Page 1 of 3

Just got my bill

Posted: June 7 12, 9:16 am
by pioneer98
I almost hate to bring up everyone's favorite subjects (health care and bills) but I needed to vent this.

I had an appendectomy a few months ago, and the bill just came in. I am incredibly fortunate to have relatively good insurance, so I was able to pay my portion of it with my HSA account. The bill is very difficult to follow with all the adjustments, but from what I can tell it would have cost around $20,000 if I did not have insurance. Mine was fairly routine, too. They got it before it burst and I was only in the hospital a total of about 28 hours.

So on to the rant part. Here are some facts I learned about this topic from doctors as I went through this.
  • 1 in 15 people will have to have an appendectomy at some point in their lives. Let's call that 7% of the population.
  • Appendicitis can happen to anyone at any time, even professional athletes like Matt Holliday and Rafael Furcal. The cause of it is unknown.
  • The population of America is 311 million people.
  • That means in America, roughly 21 million people have had or will need an appendectomy.
  • If all of them cost $20,000, the cost of this to our country will be $420,000,000,000.
  • Depending on who you ask, something like 18% of the population in America does not have health insurance.
  • That means that there are probably close to 4 million people in the country who have had or will need to have an appendectomy that do not have insurance. Odds are high that those people also don't have $20,000, either. So who pays? Pretty much all of us, I think.
And this is just appendicitis. I'm sure there are many others. We have this big push right now in this country to go to more "preventive" health care. In fact, that's why I have a high deductible plan right now. That plan has "prevented" me from going to the doctor once or twice when I might not have needed to, but someone let me know when we find a way to prevent appendicitis.

Re: Just got my bill

Posted: June 7 12, 9:18 am
by lukethedrifter
I can't break it down for you like you did but I had my L knee scoped and cleaned up 2 summers ago. I have insurance. Still cost me in the neighborhood of $4500 out of pocket.

Re: Just got my bill

Posted: June 7 12, 9:24 am
by AWvsCBsteeeerike3
lukethedrifter wrote:I can't break it down for you like you did but I had my L knee scoped and cleaned up 2 summers ago. I have insurance. Still cost me in the neighborhood of $4500 out of pocket.
That sounds about right. My ACL replacement was just north of $6K out of pocket and that's with a $500 deductible and an 80/20 insurance/me split on payments. I can't remember if that included or didn't include the $20 copay every time I went to rehab (2-3x weekly for 4 months).

Re: Just got my bill

Posted: June 7 12, 11:49 am
by G. Keenan
As others have said, we already have socialized medicine in the US, just in the least efficient and most expensive way possible.

Re: Just got my bill

Posted: June 7 12, 11:58 am
by vinsanity
pioneer98 wrote:And this is just appendicitis. I'm sure there are many others. We have this big push right now in this country to go to more "preventive" health care. In fact, that's why I have a high deductible plan right now. That plan has "prevented" me from going to the doctor once or twice when I might not have needed to, but someone let me know when we find a way to prevent appendicitis.
Well don't go too much, those co-pays add up on top of the inflated premiums you pay so you don't have to pay for x-rays, but free-market right?

Oh and if you get sick, don't make too many claims. They'll drop you, but hey, free market right?

Re: Just got my bill

Posted: June 7 12, 1:20 pm
by pioneer98
My brother had to have knee surgery a few years ago when he was in that limbo state where he was too old to be on my parent's insurance but did not have it yet himself. He quietly applied for insurance and they accepted him, then he immediately had the surgery and the insurance did pay for a lot of it. Otherwise it would have set him back $19,000. He got extremely lucky.

Re: Just got my bill

Posted: June 7 12, 1:22 pm
by pioneer98
G. Keenan wrote:As others have said, we already have socialized medicine in the US, just in the least efficient and most expensive way possible.
Yes.

Honestly, I wish I could shop around for my own insurance. But I can't decline it where I work, so I'm kind of stuck with it. But if they had lot of options for insurance available and everyone was out there shopping around for it, I really have to wonder how much it would come down in price. Our current setup discourages competition.

Re: Just got my bill

Posted: June 7 12, 1:36 pm
by lukethedrifter
To add my daughter to my employee insurance plan, I would have to pay double what I pay independently for her. To add my wife and her daughter, I would have to pay $700/month more than I pay independently. Now that is what I call gouging the public with those perks they keep sliding me.

Re: Just got my bill

Posted: June 7 12, 1:39 pm
by Hungary Jack
Obamacare will bring prices down after he is re-elected.

Re: Just got my bill

Posted: June 7 12, 1:52 pm
by vinsanity
Hungary Jack wrote:Obamacare will bring prices down after he is re-elected.
In theory it would.

Oh and it would keep companies from dropping you when you get cancer.