Page 1 of 2

Inferior Generic Products

Posted: May 18 12, 10:32 am
by G. Keenan
There are some products for which the generic, cheaper store brand option is simply never as good. The one that annoys me the most is contact lens solution. There is simply no good generic contact lens solution. The name brand stuff works great but costs like $9/bottle. At that price I'm always tempted to try a new generic option when I come across it and it's always a complete failure. The chemical capabilities of the solution are always inferior and to compound the disappointment the bottles themselves also suck. Most recently I tried the new Walgreen's solution, figuring that a giant drug store company like them could finally have solved this problem. I mean, if they can make pain killers and cold medicine that work just as well they should be able to make contact lens solution that works, right? Nope. Absolute piece of [expletive].

Anything you buy on a regular basis that has to be name brand because the generic never measures up?

Re: Inferior Generic Products

Posted: May 18 12, 11:01 am
by Jocephus
i can't think of them off the top of my head but there are definitely some generic products i have no issue with and some i do

2 i can think of

oreo's > hydrox (even though i dont buy cookies, but growing up my dad would get hydrox and the rest of us would be disgusted)

and cereal...im sorry, im an elitist, but i cannot eat the bagged cereal. i need a box (even though the cereal is in a bag).

Re: Inferior Generic Products

Posted: May 18 12, 11:07 am
by wart57
Jocephus wrote:i can't think of them off the top of my head but there are definitely some generic products i have no issue with and some i do

2 i can think of

oreo's > hydrox (even though i dont buy cookies, but growing up my dad would get hydrox and the rest of us would be disgusted)

and cereal...im sorry, im an elitist, but i cannot eat the bagged cereal. i need a box (even though the cereal is in a bag).
The Mal-o-meal Golden Puffs are awesome.

Re: Inferior Generic Products

Posted: May 18 12, 11:11 am
by cpebbles
Almost goes without saying that all generic food products are inferior, but for some reason store brand Shake and Bake is particularly noticeable. It really shouldn't be that hard to replicate, but apparently it is.

Re: Inferior Generic Products

Posted: May 18 12, 11:44 am
by lukethedrifter
I recall buying store brand ricotta that had a grayish tinge to it.

Re: Inferior Generic Products

Posted: May 18 12, 1:00 pm
by Transmogrified Tiger
For stuff like contact solution, all the generics come from a very small number of suppliers that just put a different label on the same stuff, so if you don't like one you won't like any.

For me, the one I have to use name brand is cotton swabs/Q-tips. Generic brands always bend in the middle when I use them and it really annoys me. Otherwise I'm pretty comfortable using generics, but I'm also cheap.

Re: Inferior Generic Products

Posted: May 18 12, 1:04 pm
by Richie Allen
wart57 wrote:
Jocephus wrote:i can't think of them off the top of my head but there are definitely some generic products i have no issue with and some i do

2 i can think of

oreo's > hydrox (even though i dont buy cookies, but growing up my dad would get hydrox and the rest of us would be disgusted)

and cereal...im sorry, im an elitist, but i cannot eat the bagged cereal. i need a box (even though the cereal is in a bag).
The Mal-o-meal Golden Puffs are awesome.
Malt-O-Meal, right? I call them Crack Puffs. I went through a huge box of them in a single day. My girlfriend bought me a bag of them the size of a pillow the next day.

Re: Inferior Generic Products

Posted: May 18 12, 1:06 pm
by Richie Allen
BTW, I've gotten to where I'm almost completely anti-generic. Especially when it's a matter of only a dollar or two. I get home and say, "wtf was I thinking? Was that .75 that important to me?"

Re: Inferior Generic Products

Posted: May 18 12, 1:13 pm
by Transmogrified Tiger
Richie Allen wrote:BTW, I've gotten to where I'm almost completely anti-generic. Especially when it's a matter of only a dollar or two. I get home and say, "wtf was I thinking? Was that .75 that important to me?"
The alternative is, for many items, you're simply funding the brand name marketing and not any noticeable difference in quality. That 75 cents times ~5 items times 30+ shopping trips a year adds up. That's moreso the case with non-food items, but there's plenty of interchangeable items in food as well.

Re: Inferior Generic Products

Posted: May 18 12, 2:09 pm
by Richie Allen
Transmogrified Tiger wrote:
Richie Allen wrote:BTW, I've gotten to where I'm almost completely anti-generic. Especially when it's a matter of only a dollar or two. I get home and say, "wtf was I thinking? Was that .75 that important to me?"
The alternative is, for many items, you're simply funding the brand name marketing and not any noticeable difference in quality. That 75 cents times ~5 items times 30+ shopping trips a year adds up. That's moreso the case with non-food items, but there's plenty of interchangeable items in food as well.
For people who are just out to save money, that's fine but I'm a guy that will read labels before I buy a bag of sugar. And have only found two brands of flour that are tolerable. If there truly is no noticeable difference in quality or taste and there's a savings, that's great. I go to Aldi and Big Lots every month for things like this but to buy generic Raisin Bran at Kroger to save a dollar and then have to endure a week's worth of cardboard cereal. Not worth it.