Page 1 of 1

suicide?

Posted: January 9 12, 10:52 am
by M1IRONMIKE
I just don't get it. A couple weeks ago I had a friend from work who threatening suicide but fortunately the police were able to stop him. Now a separate friend from work committed suicide yesterday morning.

WTF

Re: suicide?

Posted: January 9 12, 12:19 pm
by IMADreamer
Life often sucks, and sometimes people want to get out. I get it. I would never do it because I wouldn't put my family through it, but I get it.

Re: suicide?

Posted: January 9 12, 12:57 pm
by GeddyWrox
Been there when I was a teen. I didn't do it because of what it would've done to my mom. But when you are seriously depressed (not just common ordinary blahs, but clinical, on-going depression), your brain does not work the same way. It's like it is wired differently. I don't know how else to explain it. But trust me, the thoughts of ending the ungodly emotional pain are relentless, and really enticing.

I feel for you, your coworkers, and that person's family. Suicide leaves many questions and wounded hearts behind.

Re: suicide?

Posted: January 9 12, 1:40 pm
by jim
Suicide makes no sense, it is so counter to every biological survival instinct that it is not possible (imo) to put yourself in someone elses state to try to rationalize it. I also don't think it's possible to say it would never happen to you, because I don't believe anyone can say that. It maybe impossible at this time to imagine yourself in a state that would lead you to that, but I don't think we can really rule it out. I also think the "how selfish" arguments are shallow and in a way selfish themselves. A person in that state of mind can't really think of it in those terms.

I think all you can say and do is to say it's a sickness and a tragedy beyond comprehension and that I would hope we a as a society could a better job at treating it. I'm not saying suicide is the sickness, that of course is the solution for the person to the sickness. I'm saying treating the cause that got the person to that point.

Sorry to hear about this, it's horrible.

Re: suicide?

Posted: January 9 12, 1:57 pm
by Cronos
jim wrote:I think all you can say and do is to say it's a sickness and a tragedy beyond comprehension and that I would hope we a as a society could a better job at treating it. I'm not saying suicide is the sickness, that of course is the solution for the person to the sickness. I'm saying treating the cause that got the person to that point.
Right on on all counts, jim. One of the things that motivated me the most to choose the career line that I did was learning about a friend of a friend who committed suicide back in college. I didn't even know the guy, but it really struck me. It's so sad that people can be in such emotional pain that they will do anything to make it stop, even if it costs them everything.

Very sad to hear this, Mike. Hope you and your friend's family and loved ones can get through this.

Re: suicide?

Posted: January 10 12, 10:29 am
by Sutter'sBeard
I had an aunt who tried numerous times before succeeding. She always explained her depression by saying, imagine the worst you have ever felt emotionally, multiply it times ten, and then feeling like that just about every waking moment.

Re: suicide?

Posted: January 10 12, 10:35 am
by Jocephus
i thought about it a lot in my late teens and early 20's. only thing that stopped me is i knew it would crush my parents. so i got on prozac instead. now i'm off prozac and i don't think about it anymore. still am easily depressed but i don't want to kill myself.

Re: suicide?

Posted: January 10 12, 10:41 am
by Cronos
It's interesting (and sad) to see just how common suicidal ideation really is: many (and I've seen the research) think about it in tough moments. Worth nothing that there's a sizeable difference between thinking about suicide and actually going through with it, and there's a lot of research currently going into what makes the thoughts turn to behavior.

Re: suicide?

Posted: January 10 12, 2:04 pm
by a_smith
Suicide when you are depressed is awful.

It is crazy how painful suicide is for those in the family. I am glad that people are doing that research Chronos mentioned

I do think that as a society we have some pretty uptight notions about suicide that stem from Christianity that it is inherently bad or should never be considered. I can think of many instances (facing a life with Alzheimer, end stages of certain cancers, etc) when one could be rational and competent and make a well informed decision to end a life. Just being suicidal is not necessarily a sign of being depressed or incompetent, rather it could be a good thing to decide to end you life at a time and place of your choosing. The quality of life should be as important as the quantity of life.