Page 1 of 3

Blues Young Player Poll

Posted: October 2 11, 4:36 am
by longhornbaseball
Similar to this poll done at the end of the '09 season: If you could only have two players for the rest of their careers, which would you choose?

Re: Blues Young Player Poll

Posted: October 2 11, 6:48 am
by Swingingbunt
I struggled choosing between Oshie and Pietrangelo. I can see the merits to either one along with Stewart.

Re: Blues Young Player Poll

Posted: October 2 11, 7:08 am
by BigDCardlvr
The lone Shattenkirk vote is supposed to be for Stewart.

Re: Blues Young Player Poll

Posted: October 2 11, 7:19 am
by Popeye_Card
I think Petro is the easy call. I think he's clearly going to be an All-Star quality talent for a long time, with a probable career path of Scott Niedermayer--or better.

Then I struggled a bit between Stewart and Berglund. Stewart is going to post a lot of goals in his career, and I think he's already pretty much established his ceiling. Berglund still has some room to grow and would be a more complete player, but there's also a lower floor than Stewart. I went with Stewart because of the odds.

I think the wild card in this discussion would be if Taresenko were included. He probably has the highest ceiling of the forwards, but at this point the lowest floor too.

Re: Blues Young Player Poll

Posted: October 2 11, 9:44 am
by MrCrowesGarden
I went Petro and Stewart as well. Top-flight D-man and likely elite goal scorer... I'm almost always going to pick those two.

Re: Blues Young Player Poll

Posted: October 2 11, 10:28 am
by JCShutout
Also Stewie and Petro. Not only is Stewart highly likely to be a consistent 30+ goal scorer, but he's also a bruiser.

Re: Blues Young Player Poll

Posted: October 2 11, 10:28 am
by st.lewis11
Petro & Stewart, although I feel Berglund has perhaps the highest ceiling. I hope he begins to put it together.

Re: Blues Young Player Poll

Posted: October 2 11, 10:33 am
by Popeye_Card
st.lewis11 wrote:Petro & Stewart, although I feel Berglund has perhaps the highest ceiling. I hope he begins to put it together.
I have a feeling (OK, more of a hope) that Berglund figured it out late in the season and in the WC's, and is ready to go Beast Mode on the league this year. Seems like he's finally figured out that he's huge and nearly impossible to knock off his skates, and is starting to use that great wrist shot of his to his advantage.

Edit to add this important detail:
[SHOW]
Image

Re: Blues Young Player Poll

Posted: October 2 11, 1:16 pm
by thrill
Stew & Petro. No surprise everyone else feels the same.

Let's make it more interesting. Rank them.

Re: Blues Young Player Poll

Posted: October 2 11, 1:19 pm
by thrill
1 Petro
2 Stewart
3 Bergz
4 Oshie
5 Shat
6 Dags
7 Perron

If we included Halak, he'd be between Stewart and Berglund for me.