I considered buying the Star Wars prequels on Blu-Ray
Posted: September 22 11, 11:24 am
by cpebbles
Accidentally. They've got a huge picture of Yoda that dominates the boxcover, and it takes more than the cursory glance I was giving it to make out that it's the prequels. I didn't even realize it until I saw the box with episodes IV-VI sitting in a much less conspicuous spot (While the much harder sale prequels are a featured new release). Luckily I've decided that George Lucas is never getting another cent out of me until he re-releases the original trilogy without all the [expletive] he's been adding to them for the last 15 years.
Re: I considered buying the Star Wars prequels on Blu-Ray
Posted: September 22 11, 5:01 pm
by Maclowery
Just don't ever buy anything Star Wars related again. I won't.
Re: I considered buying the Star Wars prequels on Blu-Ray
Posted: September 23 11, 7:08 am
by Leroy
So I'm not the only one thinking the prequels were awful? I guess maybe the originals may have been too, but I was young. And in love with that crazy haired princess.
Re: I considered buying the Star Wars prequels on Blu-Ray
Posted: September 23 11, 9:07 am
by Transmogrified Tiger
Leroy wrote:So I'm not the only one thinking the prequels were awful? I guess maybe the originals may have been too, but I was young. And in love with that crazy haired princess.
The prequels weren't quite as good, but because they weren't a part of people's childhood they get labeled as crap moneygrabs. Kinda like how the National Treasure movies are pretty much on par with Indiana Jones, but woe be the person who doesn't give Indy his due respect.
Re: I considered buying the Star Wars prequels on Blu-Ray
Posted: September 23 11, 9:46 am
by thrill
I'm pretty sure if I hadn't seen the Star Wars series as a child, I'd hate all of them.
Re: I considered buying the Star Wars prequels on Blu-Ray
Posted: September 23 11, 2:15 pm
by cpebbles
Transmogrified Tiger wrote:
Leroy wrote:So I'm not the only one thinking the prequels were awful? I guess maybe the originals may have been too, but I was young. And in love with that crazy haired princess.
The prequels weren't quite as good, but because they weren't a part of people's childhood they get labeled as crap moneygrabs. Kinda like how the National Treasure movies are pretty much on par with Indiana Jones, but woe be the person who doesn't give Indy his due respect.
You are now my least favorite person ever.
The Empire Strikes Back and Raiders of the Lost Ark are on a completely different level from the rest of the series, among the best movies of all time. Star Wars was good. Return of the Jedi and the last Indiana Jones movie were okay. Temple of Doom, the Star Wars prequels, and National Treasure movies are complete garbage.
Re: I considered buying the Star Wars prequels on Blu-Ray
Posted: September 23 11, 2:22 pm
by wart57
I like all of the movies mentioned so far.
I don't care.
I like them.
Re: I considered buying the Star Wars prequels on Blu-Ray
Posted: September 23 11, 2:31 pm
by ghostrunner
Transmogrified Tiger wrote: Kinda like how the National Treasure movies are pretty much on par with Indiana Jones, but woe be the person who doesn't give Indy his due respect.
Dear god, sir.
As for Star Wars, I was just watching ESB with my son a few weeks ago and it really is a great movie unlike the others. Sometimes I've wondered if I haven't remembered it too fondly, but it's as good as I remember. It's also the only one where Lucas didn't either write or direct (he did one of those on all the others), which I'm certain is no coincidence. Lawrence Kasdan wrote both ESB and Raiders.
Re: I considered buying the Star Wars prequels on Blu-Ray
Posted: September 23 11, 6:10 pm
by AdmiralKird
I have no beef with some of the stuff added to the original trilogy, like the beak on the Sarlacc sand pit monster, making Rancor/Wampa fight scenes look more realistic, fixing the female looking Emperor in the Empire Strikes Back, or adding some of the pullback camera shots to view more of the cities, but some of the changes to the fundamental storyline and awkward changes (Greedo Shoots first, adding an un-aged force ghost of Hayden Christensen at the end when we just saw Anakin unmasked and he looked nothing like he did as a young adult), really irk me. As Plinkett would say, its a case of someone gaining too much power to be questioned creatively.
[/youtube]
Also the prequels are poorly written stories that do not mesh well with the originals, even without altering the originals. Anakin wasn't a good friend of Obi-Wan, he was a whiny know-it-all on almost every occasion, the Jedi were ridiculously incompetent, especially Yoda, etc
Re: I considered buying the Star Wars prequels on Blu-Ray
Posted: September 23 11, 6:36 pm
by cpebbles
Adding CGI [expletive] to the original series irks me, no matter how minor it is. It's distracting because the CGI still doesn't mesh with actors and physical effects. When Lucas dies, whoever gets left in charge is going to figure out that there is money to be made by releasing remastered versions of the original trilogy with all of Luca's [expletive] stripped out. Let's just say I'm saving up for that day.