Page 1 of 3
Fukushima disaster much worse then we are told
Posted: June 21 11, 12:53 pm
by IMADreamer
http://english.aljazeera.net/indepth/fe ... 02638.html
We have 20 nuclear cores exposed, the fuel pools have several cores each, that is 20 times the potential to be released than Chernobyl," said Gundersen. "The data I'm seeing shows that we are finding hot spots further away than we had from Chernobyl, and the amount of radiation in many of them was the amount that caused areas to be declared no-man's-land for Chernobyl. We are seeing square kilometres being found 60 to 70 kilometres away from the reactor.
They recalculated the amount of radiation released, but the news is really not talking about this," he said. "The new calculations show that within the first week of the accident, they released 2.3 times as much radiation as they thought they released in the first 80 days
the US, physician Janette Sherman MD and epidemiologist Joseph Mangano published an essay shedding light on a 35 per cent spike in infant mortality in northwest cities that occurred after the Fukushima meltdown, and may well be the result of fallout from the stricken nuclear plant.
I just highlighted some highlights of the article but it was an interesting read. I like most Americans have completely forgotten about the Japanese disaster, sorry but I did. I stumbled across this today. I wasn't sure if I should make an all new thread or bump the old one so I hope this is ok. I know we have some experts here on the site and I'd be curious to hear what they think about this article. Is it over blown or true? I'm just curious to what every one thinks. I'm not much of a fan of nuclear power but I'm also not educated enough to put up a real argument against it. My experience comes from playing Sim City 20 years where you had to rebuild a city around a nuclear accident.
Re: Fukushima disaster much worse then we are told
Posted: June 21 11, 1:00 pm
by cpebbles
The U.S. government has clearly disagreed with the official statements of the Japanese. I think their recommendation was that U.S. citizens not have a prolonged stay within 300 km of the site, while the Japanese government was saying 100 km was outside the danger zone.
Re: Fukushima disaster much worse then we are told
Posted: June 22 11, 5:09 am
by AdmiralKird
Do not listen to the pirate American radio stations, I can assure you, Midway was a great victory for our empire. At least two Yorktown class carriers were sunk and the American Navy has been severely crippled in its capacity to make war in the Pacific.
Re: Fukushima disaster much worse then we are told
Posted: June 27 11, 10:21 am
by Swirls
We have 20 nuclear cores exposed, the fuel pools have several cores each, that is 20 times the potential to be released than Chernobyl," said Gundersen.
I stopped reading after this.
Apparently this guy doesn't realize that there's only one "core" per reactor - and it's in the reactor vessel. No reactor vessels were breached during the accident. Sure there were hydrogen explosions that blew off the roofs of the reactor buildings (secondary containment), but the drywells (primary containment) and the reactor vessels themselves (located inside the drywell) remained intact.
The spent fuel pools contain spent fuel assemblies. That's it. A thousand or so fuel pellets make up a fuel rod; several fuel rods make up a fuel bundle; four fuel bundles make up a fuel assembly. The spent fuel is incredibly radioactive when it comes out of the reactor core. Hence why it is constantly under water at a nuclear power plant with the water being cooled and recirculated.
One of the biggest differences in terms of the amount of radiation released from Chernobyl versus Fukujima is that we knew where the fuel was at Fukujima and what needed to be done, but the Japanese weren't proactive in doing it. Chernobyl happened because they were [expletive] idiots who disabled all of their safety systems in order to perform a similarly [expletive] idiotic test on their turbine - their boiler explosion (completely different type of explosion than what happened at Fukujima) resulted in the entire core being blown apart, with fuel rods and control rods being shot out and sent around the crash site. They've still not accounted for all of the fuel - and this is 25 years later. Their best guess is that the missing fuel melted and formed a huge glass sculpture looking thing that's referred to as the "Elephant's Foot."
Re: Fukushima disaster much worse then we are told
Posted: June 27 11, 10:30 am
by IMADreamer
Thanks for the professional opinion on the subject. That's why I posted it because I knew there were people here who had a better handle on this then the media.
Re: Fukushima disaster much worse then we are told
Posted: June 27 11, 11:06 am
by Arthur Dent
Swirls wrote:No reactor vessels were breached during the accident. Sure there were hydrogen explosions that blew off the roofs of the reactor buildings (secondary containment), but the drywells (primary containment) and the reactor vessels themselves (located inside the drywell) remained intact.
Do we know that? Last I heard there was evidence of damage to the pressure vessels in at least two reactors.
Edit: And regardless, they did release a lot of radiation. Justified or not, this is likely going to lead to semi-permanent depopulation of certain areas.
Re: Fukushima disaster much worse then we are told
Posted: August 3 11, 9:19 am
by sighyoung
Re: Fukushima disaster much worse then we are told
Posted: August 3 11, 10:45 am
by TimeForGuinness
Swirls wrote:We have 20 nuclear cores exposed, the fuel pools have several cores each, that is 20 times the potential to be released than Chernobyl," said Gundersen.
I stopped reading after this.
Apparently this guy doesn't realize that there's only one "core" per reactor - and it's in the reactor vessel. No reactor vessels were breached during the accident. Sure there were hydrogen explosions that blew off the roofs of the reactor buildings (secondary containment), but the drywells (primary containment) and the reactor vessels themselves (located inside the drywell) remained intact.
The spent fuel pools contain spent fuel assemblies. That's it. A thousand or so fuel pellets make up a fuel rod; several fuel rods make up a fuel bundle; four fuel bundles make up a fuel assembly. The spent fuel is incredibly radioactive when it comes out of the reactor core. Hence why it is constantly under water at a nuclear power plant with the water being cooled and recirculated.
One of the biggest differences in terms of the amount of radiation released from Chernobyl versus Fukujima is that we knew where the fuel was at Fukujima and what needed to be done, but the Japanese weren't proactive in doing it. Chernobyl happened because they were [expletive] idiots who disabled all of their safety systems in order to perform a similarly [expletive] idiotic test on their turbine - their boiler explosion (completely different type of explosion than what happened at Fukujima) resulted in the entire core being blown apart, with fuel rods and control rods being shot out and sent around the crash site. They've still not accounted for all of the fuel - and this is 25 years later. Their best guess is that the missing fuel melted and formed a huge glass sculpture looking thing that's referred to as the "Elephant's Foot."
Thanks for the info...I was waiting for you (GRBs resident nuclear expert) to chime in on the subject.
(If you've explained everything earlier, I must have missed it.)
Re: Fukushima disaster much worse then we are told
Posted: March 2 15, 9:40 am
by pioneer98
This article (behind a paywall) talks a lot about the ongoing aftermath. The author lived in areas near the forbidden zone. It's a gigantic mess. He said something like 150,000 people's homes are inside the forbidden zone. Their homes are worthless now, even though they owe a ton on their mortgages, and insurance and government hasn't helped all of them. Some people are allowed to go into the forbidden zone during certain times still to look after their property. But they can't stay long because of radiation exposure. The theory is the danger is in how much radiation you are exposed to, not the rate of exposure. The author carried a dosimeter with him at all times and it tells him how much exposure he's gotten. Even outside the forbidden zone there is some amount of exposure higher than normal. Heck, he got readings of radiation in California and Virginia. Some cities near the forbidden zone with higher measurements of radiation have cleared off trees and topsoil and bagged it up and taken it elsewhere. They just don't know what else to do with it. There is still radiation going into rivers and the ocean. That crazy idea they had to build a giant underground freezing system to freeze all the groundwater was not feasible.
Re: Fukushima disaster much worse then we are told
Posted: March 2 15, 11:10 am
by Socnorb11
What are the exposure rates in the forbidden zone?
Radiation wouldn't absorb into topsoil and trees, would it? And rivers and ocean?