Page 1 of 2

Brisket

Posted: December 1 10, 5:15 pm
by Fat Strat
Let me start this rant by saying that I've never cooked or priced brisket before. At a large Thanksgiving gathering last week the host served brisket with a dry rub to go along with the turkey. It was amazing! By far the best brisket I've ever had anywhere. I got the recipe and planned to make it for an upcoming Christmas party the wife and I are hosting for my board.

I wanted to do a test run this weekend with a small brisket to make sure I had everything correct before making it for the important people. Went to Schnuck's, picked up all the ingredients for the rub, then went to the meat section. $45 for a 8lb brisket, the smallest they had! $45!!!! I've been to quality BBQ restaurants that served fully cooked brisket for $6-8/lb + sides.

Is that a typical price for brisket? Am I missing something important here? I really want to serve that for the party, but not at $100 for just the meat.

Re: Brisket

Posted: December 1 10, 5:19 pm
by thrill
I don't know anything you're asking but would like to add that I had a brisket sandwich on Marble Rye at Goldman's deli yesterday that was amazing.

Re: Brisket

Posted: December 1 10, 5:26 pm
by lukethedrifter
Also of no help, Smoki O's has the best BBQ brisket in town. Better than Pappys just get the sauce on the side.

Re: Brisket

Posted: December 1 10, 5:30 pm
by TGantz
Fat Strat wrote:Let me start this rant by saying that I've never cooked or priced brisket before. At a large Thanksgiving gathering last week the host served brisket with a dry rub to go along with the turkey. It was amazing! By far the best brisket I've ever had anywhere. I got the recipe and planned to make it for an upcoming Christmas party the wife and I are hosting for my board.

I wanted to do a test run this weekend with a small brisket to make sure I had everything correct before making it for the important people. Went to Schnuck's, picked up all the ingredients for the rub, then went to the meat section. $45 for a 8lb brisket, the smallest they had! $45!!!! I've been to quality BBQ restaurants that served fully cooked brisket for $6-8/lb + sides.

Is that a typical price for brisket? Am I missing something important here? I really want to serve that for the party, but not at $100 for just the meat.
EDIT- Nevermind. I want to keep my job.

Re: Brisket

Posted: December 1 10, 6:08 pm
by lukethedrifter
TGantz wrote:
Fat Strat wrote:Let me start this rant by saying that I've never cooked or priced brisket before. At a large Thanksgiving gathering last week the host served brisket with a dry rub to go along with the turkey. It was amazing! By far the best brisket I've ever had anywhere. I got the recipe and planned to make it for an upcoming Christmas party the wife and I are hosting for my board.

I wanted to do a test run this weekend with a small brisket to make sure I had everything correct before making it for the important people. Went to Schnuck's, picked up all the ingredients for the rub, then went to the meat section. $45 for a 8lb brisket, the smallest they had! $45!!!! I've been to quality BBQ restaurants that served fully cooked brisket for $6-8/lb + sides.

Is that a typical price for brisket? Am I missing something important here? I really want to serve that for the party, but not at $100 for just the meat.
EDIT- Nevermind. I want to keep my job.
Yeah, I don't telling him to switch price stickers with a bottom round at your store is a great thing to post on here.


Just kidding to TGantz' bosses. And he didn't tell him he'd leave a brisket by the dumpster either.

Re: Brisket

Posted: December 2 10, 7:31 am
by jeffbgoofy
Sometimes they go on sale. We get them in the big packages at Dierberg's when they have good sales. Split them and do them one of two ways. Blues Hog dry rub for the smoker or a chili sauce mix for the oven. Either way it turns out great. I was always a big fan of brisket on the bbq circuit

Re: Brisket

Posted: December 2 10, 8:19 am
by Popeye_Card
Unfortunately, that's about the going-rate for brisket at the supermarket. It isn't exactly a prime cut of beef, but because of it's popularity for bbq, they gouge the price. Kinda like ribs, which were just thrown out in the garbage before peeps discovered how to bbq.

You can probably get a better cut for cheaper from a decent butcher or smaller grocery store. That would be my suggestion if you need enough for a party.

Re: Brisket

Posted: December 2 10, 8:54 am
by lukethedrifter
Seems kind of funny to say that a super delicious and costly cut of meat is not high quality.

If he's looking for brisket I'm not sure what better and cheaper hunk of cow flesh he's going to get.

Re: Brisket

Posted: December 2 10, 8:59 am
by redbirdjazzz
lukethedrifter wrote:Seems kind of funny to say that a super delicious and costly cut of meat is not high quality.

If he's looking for brisket I'm not sure what better and cheaper hunk of cow flesh he's going to get.
It's a lean, tough cut that requires low temperature and long cook times, which does make it ideal for barbecue. It's similar to flank steak, which is only expensive because somebody decided to invent London Broil in order to make a tough, cheap cut of meat desirable.

Re: Brisket

Posted: December 2 10, 9:28 am
by cards2468
occasionally my dad will smoke brisket, and it's always [expletive] awesome

oh, and Pappy's has fantastic brisket

so my recommendation is to just do carry out and bring everybody Pappy's