Page 1 of 5

I am obese

Posted: November 17 10, 3:11 pm
by wart57
For my insurance at work we need to take some medical tests, called healthy measures, to get "discounts" on our insurance rates. There are 4 categories of discounts, if you pass each one, you get a $5 "discount" per week.
Blood Preassure - Mine was 116/72 - Normal range - "Discount"!
Cholesterol - 185 - Optimal range betweem 120 and 199 - "Discount"!
Glucose - 91 - 70-99 is the normal range - "Discount"!

BMI - 30.55 - Ideal is 19-25, overweight is 26-29, obese is 30-34, Morbidly obese is 35-40, and Super Obesety (I love that classification) is over 40.
Now, I know I am not a skinny man, I was at one time, but I am not obese. I am 5 ft 11, and weigh in at 216 - I have actually lost 10 pounds in the last month by cutting back my soda consumption by about 95% and taking the stairs every day. I have a 36 inch waist and I am a have a large frame for my height (I'm not fat I am just big boned), yet I am classified as obese, so there goes $260 down the drain - how the [expletive] am I obese? Next year, if I continue to do what I am doing, I should be unter 200lbs, which is where I want to be anyway. I think someone needs to re-dow the weight charts.

Re: I am obese

Posted: November 17 10, 3:14 pm
by cpebbles
You smell funny too.

Seriously, BMI is REALLY imperfect. For me to get down to my "optimal" weight, I'd to have a limb amputated, and I doubt a single arm would do it.

Re: I am obese

Posted: November 17 10, 3:16 pm
by wart57
cpebbles wrote:You smell funny too.

Seriously, BMI is REALLY imperfect. For me to get down to my "optimal" weight, I'd to have a limb amputated, and I doubt a single arm would do it.
What, did my Old Spice wear off? Why didn't anyone tell me before now?

Re: I am obese

Posted: November 17 10, 3:17 pm
by cards2468
BMI isn't the most accurate way to depict a person's health. My dad, for instance, is classified as obese by his insurance company, yet he lifts every day and runs 2+ miles every day (has been keeping up this regime for as long as I can remember). He's just a bit more bulky than your average person even though his body fat % is relatively low. He's cutting back on weight lifting and won't touch beer anymore because he can't stand that he's classified as obese.

Re: I am obese

Posted: November 17 10, 4:46 pm
by lukethedrifter
I think it's a serious misuse of BMI to base an individuals insurance rates on it. For the insurance company it's not but for the individual it's rather unfair.

Re: I am obese

Posted: November 17 10, 4:52 pm
by G. Keenan
While BMI is an inaccurate measure of a person's health or obesity, I think we can all agree that wart is nonetheless obese.

Re: I am obese

Posted: November 17 10, 4:53 pm
by planet planet
G. Keenan wrote:While BMI is an inaccurate measure of a person's health or obesity, I think we can all agree that wart is nonetheless obese.
It takes a big man to admit it too.

Re: I am obese

Posted: November 17 10, 4:54 pm
by Jocephus
lukethedrifter wrote:I think it's a serious misuse of BMI to base an individuals insurance rates on it. For the insurance company it's not but for the individual it's rather unfair.
are you suggesting that insurance companies do not use fair and honest practices?

Re: I am obese

Posted: November 17 10, 4:57 pm
by lukethedrifter
planet pujolsian wrote:
G. Keenan wrote:While BMI is an inaccurate measure of a person's health or obesity, I think we can all agree that wart is nonetheless obese.
It takes a big man to admit it too.

clever

Re: I am obese

Posted: November 17 10, 6:16 pm
by jim
cpebbles wrote:You smell funny too.

Seriously, BMI is REALLY imperfect. For me to get down to my "optimal" weight, I'd to have a limb amputated, and I doubt a single arm would do it.

So what would a guys ceiling be with numbers like that? Fat? Chunky?