Page 1 of 1
Rant: New basketball/hockey arenas
Posted: November 15 10, 10:43 am
by jim
We talk a bunch about the new baseball stadiums, compare them to Fenway and Wrigley ... but what about the great basketball and hockey arenas that have bit the dust? I hate The United Center. You literally feel like you are in a shopping mall, and I mean exactly like it. Stores, restaurants, escalators and elevators. If you blindfolded someone and just dropped them in the corridor and asked them if they were A) at Woodfield Mall or B) at an NBA basketball game - if they didn't notice everyone wearing the same shirts they would pick A.
Also, will there ever be a day where we have basketball specific and hockey specific arenas? These multi purpose places have a pretty big disadvantage - just look at any seating chart of a basketball arena where they play hockey and will see what I mean. The rink is longer than the court, and the seats go on for quite a ways past the baseline before they make a turn. Result is you are just farther away from the action with weird angles. i don't know if there are compromises for hockey seating - maybe not - but for basketball it really pushes the affordable seating far away from the court.
I used to love the old Checkerdome, haven't been to the new place whatever they call it. Except that 3rd deck behind the net - that was about like climbing that big tower to change the light at the top that someone posted on here recently. That was crazy steep.
Anyway, that's my rant. I miss places like the Checkerdome, the Chicago Stadium, the Gardens ... it's a shame we have to tear down these great old places to have something shiny and new. I hate shiny and new in sports places.
Re: Rant: New basketball/hockey arenas
Posted: November 15 10, 10:56 am
by Swirls
Joe Louis Arena in Detroit is only used for Red Wings games; the Pistons play in a different building.
Looks like just another reason why Chicago sucks...
Re: Rant: New basketball/hockey arenas
Posted: November 16 10, 7:47 am
by Sutter'sBeard
jim wrote:We talk a bunch about the new baseball stadiums, compare them to Fenway and Wrigley ... but what about the great basketball and hockey arenas that have bit the dust? I hate The United Center. You literally feel like you are in a shopping mall, and I mean exactly like it. Stores, restaurants, escalators and elevators. If you blindfolded someone and just dropped them in the corridor and asked them if they were A) at Woodfield Mall or B) at an NBA basketball game - if they didn't notice everyone wearing the same shirts they would pick A.
Also, will there ever be a day where we have basketball specific and hockey specific arenas? These multi purpose places have a pretty big disadvantage - just look at any seating chart of a basketball arena where they play hockey and will see what I mean. The rink is longer than the court, and the seats go on for quite a ways past the baseline before they make a turn. Result is you are just farther away from the action with weird angles. i don't know if there are compromises for hockey seating - maybe not - but for basketball it really pushes the affordable seating far away from the court.
I used to love the old Checkerdome, haven't been to the new place whatever they call it. Except that 3rd deck behind the net - that was about like climbing that big tower to change the light at the top that someone posted on here recently. That was crazy steep.
Anyway, that's my rant. I miss places like the Checkerdome, the Chicago Stadium, the Gardens ... it's a shame we have to tear down these great old places to have something shiny and new. I hate shiny and new in sports places.
I miss the atmosphere and noise in Chicago Stadium compared to the UC but I don't miss the partial views at hockey games. I sh*t you not, I sat directly behind a pillar one time and, another time had one take out about 1/3 of my view. I also love nostalgia but, I think, from an overall experience, I'll take the UC over Chicago Stadium.
Re: Rant: New basketball/hockey arenas
Posted: November 16 10, 8:30 am
by thrill
jim wrote:Also, will there ever be a day where we have basketball specific and hockey specific arenas?
The onus is on the hockey teams to be able to build their own barn in most cities that have both and they just can't justify it. We have separate facilities in Phoenix, I know they do in Detroit and Minneapolis, that's all i'm aware of off the top of my head.
Re: Rant: New basketball/hockey arenas
Posted: November 16 10, 9:01 am
by Radbird
Pepsi Center in Denver is used by both the Nuggets and the Avalanche (also the National Lacrosse League's Colorado Mammoth). Sitting in the upper deck "end zone" is great for hockey and weak for basketball.
Re: Rant: New basketball/hockey arenas
Posted: November 16 10, 9:15 am
by thrill
Radbird wrote:Pepsi Center in Denver is used by both the Nuggets and the Avalanche (also the National Lacrosse League's Colorado Mammoth). Sitting in the upper deck "end zone" is great for hockey and weak for basketball.
Hey Rad, have you seen any people walking around in Rapids gear lately? Is the casual sports fan even aware that they're going to MLS Cup Final? That team does a terrible job marketing the brand. They're a fun team to watch.
Re: Rant: New basketball/hockey arenas
Posted: November 16 10, 9:22 am
by jim
I just checked out the seating diagram for the Phoenix place and that is exactly what I am talking about. At the baseline they angle the seats in immediately. In Chicago, there are sections that are facing the court at a 90 degree angle (to the baseline) but you are well past the baseline - probably close to 50 feet past it.
I also wish Chicago's place was in an area where there was stuff to do before/after the game. Basically the thing to do after the game in Chicago is get the hell out as fast as you possibly can. I would be seriuosly tempted to get season tix, or at least go in on season tix with someone in Chicago if it was in a better area. It's JUST the game in Chicago. When it's over, your night is done. Of course things were the same in the old place - in fact it was worse. Way worse actually. The neighboorhood has actually improved tremendously since then. But the promise of restaurants and places to hang out never materialized.
Miami is in a sweet spot - right near the water and tons of places to eat/drink after the game. Have I ever said that I really like alot of things about Miami? edit ... and I'm guessing Phoenix as well. I would imagine there are places to go before/after the game there as well.
Re: Rant: New basketball/hockey arenas
Posted: November 16 10, 9:24 am
by Radbird
thrill wrote:Radbird wrote:Pepsi Center in Denver is used by both the Nuggets and the Avalanche (also the National Lacrosse League's Colorado Mammoth). Sitting in the upper deck "end zone" is great for hockey and weak for basketball.
Hey Rad, have you seen any people walking around in Rapids gear lately? Is the casual sports fan even aware that they're going to MLS Cup Final? That team does a terrible job marketing the brand. They're a fun team to watch.
Not that I've seen. They barely get mentioned on the local news sportscast, and if they do it's after prep sports. I know about it because my daughter and her friends are soccer fans.
Re: Rant: New basketball/hockey arenas
Posted: November 16 10, 9:36 am
by thrill
jim wrote:and I'm guessing Phoenix as well. I would imagine there are places to go before/after the game there as well.
There are a few places downtown near the Suns arena, but it's largely a wasteland that you want to leave asap. There's a development surrounding the hockey arena with tons of restaurants and shops where you can hang out at after Coyotes and Cardinals games but the downside to it is the fact that it's way the hell out in the suburban wasteland that is the West valley.
If they could have combined the two and put the Westgate City Center downtown and made a dual purpose, new stadium, despite the admitted problems with seating and playing surfaces in the combo arenas, it would have been a huge boost to downtown tourism and nightlife. Also the city of Glendale wouldn't have the loaded gun to their head of a hockey team that can't draw on the brink of relocating somewhere in Canada anchoring their terrible location with a huge white elephant of an arena and a shopping center/apartments/restaurant development that depends on the arena and the football stadium to draw people and tenants.
This city spread like a virus in the 90's and early 2000's and they had a fantastic opportunity to do a lot of things right in terms of civil engineering. Unfortunately, they just didn't.