Page 1 of 25

Which NCAA Conference is the best at football?

Posted: October 25 10, 12:45 pm
by JL21
New thread.

Re: Which NCAA Conference is the best?

Posted: October 25 10, 12:46 pm
by The Third Man
Football? SEC. Basketball? Big East/ACC. Combination? Big 12 or Big 10, maybe. Other sports? Who cares.

Re: Which NCAA Conference is the best?

Posted: October 25 10, 12:47 pm
by JL21
Thread title changed.

Re: Which NCAA Conference is the best at football?

Posted: October 25 10, 12:50 pm
by Hungary Jack
Big East.

Re: Which NCAA Conference is the best at football?

Posted: October 25 10, 12:51 pm
by AWvsCBsteeeerike3
SEC. More pointedly, I'd argue a 1 loss alabama team deserves to be in the BCS game moreso than an undefeated Michigan State team. I don't know about an undefeated Mizzou team, however. Though, if Mizzou and Bama faced off and it was a pick 'em game, I imagine that line would move real quick to make Bama favored by more than a field goal. I know it's not a scientific statement, but when you're dealing with arbitrarily picking two teams to play, it's as good a way to measure as any. Not that Mizzou couldn't beat Bama.

Re: Which NCAA Conference is the best at football?

Posted: October 25 10, 12:54 pm
by Socnorb11
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:SEC. More pointedly, I'd argue a 1 loss alabama team deserves to be in the BCS game moreso than an undefeated Michigan State team. I don't know about an undefeated Mizzou team, however. Though, if Mizzou and Bama faced off and it was a pick 'em game, I imagine that line would move real quick to make Bama favored by more than a field goal. I know it's not a scientific statement, but when you're dealing with arbitrarily picking two teams to play, it's as good a way to measure as any. Not that Mizzou couldn't beat Bama.

Why do you think that Alabama deserves to get in over the Big Ten champion, but not the Big XII champion?

Re: Which NCAA Conference is the best at football?

Posted: October 25 10, 1:19 pm
by albertmvpujols
The weakness of the SEC East balances out the strength of the SEC West.

(And someone please tell me what the signature win of anyone outside of Auburn in the West is to make them so strong?)

Re: Which NCAA Conference is the best at football?

Posted: October 25 10, 1:22 pm
by AWvsCBsteeeerike3
Socnorb11 wrote:
Why do you think that Alabama deserves to get in over the Big Ten champion, but not the Big XII champion?
Because being 12-1 in the SEC West is more deserving than being 12-0 in the Big X. Especially when they won't even play the best team in the conference.

Mizzou beating OU twice as well as Nebraska on the road is pretty impressive and it's tough to say the same (12-1 in the SEC > 13-0 in the Big XII).

The conf champion game is huge since it's guarateed to be against a top team, likely a team you've already played and have to beat again. Regardless, Alabama is going to be favored in all their games the rest of the season. So, if you truly believe that they're not the best team, then you'll have a good chance to maek some money as LSU and Auburn will likely both be about +180 on the moneyline.

Re: Which NCAA Conference is the best at football?

Posted: October 25 10, 1:35 pm
by AWvsCBsteeeerike3
albertmvpujols wrote:The weakness of the SEC East balances out the strength of the SEC West.

(And someone please tell me what the signature win of anyone outside of Auburn in the West is to make them so strong?)

Well, like you said, Auburn has beaten a good Arkansas team and LSU team in back to back weeks. The SEC West has to be the toughest division in football w 4 teams in the top 20 out of 6 teams. If you can't see why having to run that gauntlet is in itself deserving then there's no point in having a conversation as we're not going to change each others minds.

I guess my point is, Bama beat Penn State, beat an undefeated Arkansas team in Fayetteville then beat Florida the next week. All their opponents since Arkansas have been coming off a bye week. They've got LSU at Baton Rouge and Auburn still to go. In the end, wins over a likely undefeated Auburn and Arkansas and a 1 loss LSU plus likely revenging their only loss to USC in the sec championship game is more impressive than wins against Wisconsin and at Michigan and Iowa.

Re: Which NCAA Conference is the best at football?

Posted: October 25 10, 1:46 pm
by Hungary Jack
Whomever wins the SEC will certainly have earned it, and a trip to the national title game. If Mizzou wins out, it would be really hard not to send them on to the championship game either.

I still think Bama is the best team in the SEC, and just happened to get beat by a good SoCo team that had a great day.

MSU is a fine team, but they were moments away from losing to Notre Dame and Northwestern. I have a hard time putting them in the same echelon as Bama, Mizzou, and Auburn.

The Oregon offense is scary, but I think it would meet its match against Bama, LSU, and perhaps Mizzou. The PAC-10 is not exactly full of defensive stalwarts.