Page 1 of 4

Rant: Not knowing the rules of the road

Posted: September 23 10, 5:51 pm
by jim
Two incidents in the past week, same situation and same place.

Busy intersection with a stop sign on the side road, none on the main road. First occurrence I come up westbound to the stop sign and see a guy heading east at this stop sign. I'm turning right, he's turning left. He was there before me. After about a minute, traffic clears to go. Since I'm going right and he's turning left - so both wanting to go the same way on the road. I have the right away. I don't care if he's been there an hour and I just got there, it's my right of way. I go, he turns left, and then starts scream at me and continues to yell as we approach the next traffic light together. I see him in my rear view mirror. It's not a 4 say stop [expletive].

Same situation, same road, but now I'm turning left. I'm there first and some old lady in a Toyota (btw - Buicks and Toyota's you need to watch for - worst drivers in the world) is wanting to be nice because I got there first. Hey you old syphilitic [expletive], it's your right of way. Go. You are confusing people you old dried up hag.

People routinely treat this intersection like an all-way stop and it is not. Follow the rules and there is no confusion.

Re: Rant: Not knowing the rules of the road

Posted: September 23 10, 7:59 pm
by cardsfansince82
You can't even get a straight answer from a cop on this one, it's pretty divided. Technically, I would side with you and say anyone going right or straight would have the right of way over someone turning left. However, it's also pretty common knowledge that common courtesy is to yield to the person who was there first. I usually let the person go first but I also communicate with hand signals. It's stupid to get in a wreck just by being a stickler. It hardly ever happens where two cars are truly fighting over a small window in traffic. Usually the right turner goes first because the left is still blocked or there's such a big gap that both can go no problem.

Re: Rant: Not knowing the rules of the road

Posted: September 23 10, 8:05 pm
by planet planet
In a four way stop sign situation, whoever's been there longest has the right away, right?

Re: Rant: Not knowing the rules of the road

Posted: September 23 10, 8:11 pm
by Joe Shlabotnik
Jim I've been driving 35 plus years and this is the first I've heard of that. Is that the way they teach it in Missouri?

Thread hijack - let's talk 4 way stops. In NY State where I grew up, it was you get to the intersection and if there is anyone to your left, you yield to them and follow after they go thereby setting up a counterclockwise rotation through the intersection.

Out west it was a totally different thing. In Idaho it appeared people remembered when they got to the intersection and you damn well better go in that order or else. In Oregon it seemed like anyone turning right went when they were ready and rolled right through and if you and the guy opposite were both going straight through, you went at the same time.

Weird - It never occurred to me there was such regional difference.

Re: Rant: Not knowing the rules of the road

Posted: September 23 10, 8:15 pm
by jim
There is no regional difference. Left turns yield to oncoming traffic, always. It's that simple. There should only be logic, not courtesy. You should be able to define mathematically.

Planet - I'm talking about a regular stop sign, not and all-way.

Re: Rant: Not knowing the rules of the road

Posted: September 23 10, 9:06 pm
by cardsfansince82
planet pujolsian wrote:In a four way stop sign situation, whoever's been there longest has the right away, right?
Four way stop is always who got to a complete stop first, or been there the longest. If it's a tie the person to the right goes.
jim wrote:There is no regional difference. Left turns yield to oncoming traffic, always. It's that simple. There should only be logic, not courtesy. You should be able to define mathematically.
There's plenty of regional difference, not only in actual laws from state to state but also what drivers consider generally acceptable.

In Tulsa, Oklahoma people would turn left in front of me turning right at a solid green light on a daily basis. I have a rant somewhere here about it. People in Kansas City have no concept of using the left lane only for passing. They never move over and force you to pass on the right.

Re: Rant: Not knowing the rules of the road

Posted: September 23 10, 9:12 pm
by Radbird
cardsfansince82 wrote:People in Kansas City have no concept of using the left lane only for passing. They never move over and force you to pass on the right.
What do you expect from a place where they say their road names backwards. "Forty Highway"? Really???

Re: Rant: Not knowing the rules of the road

Posted: September 23 10, 9:14 pm
by jim
cardsfansince82 wrote:
planet pujolsian wrote:In a four way stop sign situation, whoever's been there longest has the right away, right?
Four way stop is always who got to a complete stop first, or been there the longest. If it's a tie the person to the right goes.
jim wrote:There is no regional difference. Left turns yield to oncoming traffic, always. It's that simple. There should only be logic, not courtesy. You should be able to define mathematically.
There's plenty of regional difference, not only in actual laws from state to state but also what drivers consider generally acceptable.

In Tulsa, Oklahoma people would turn left in front of me turning right at a solid green light on a daily basis. I have a rant somewhere here about it. People in Kansas City have no concept of using the left lane only for passing. They never move over and force you to pass on the right.
Show me one law that says it's ok to make a left turn without yielding to oncoming traffic.

Re: Rant: Not knowing the rules of the road

Posted: September 23 10, 9:45 pm
by cardsfansince82
jim wrote: Show me one law that says it's ok to make a left turn without yielding to oncoming traffic.
MICHIGAN VEHICLE CODE (EXCERPT)
Act 300 of 1949


257.650 Right-of-way; turning left at intersection; violation as civil infraction.
Sec. 650.

(1) The driver of a vehicle within an intersection intending to turn to the left shall yield the right of way to a vehicle approaching from the opposite direction which is within the intersection or so close to the intersection as to constitute an immediate hazard; but the driver, having so yielded and having given a signal when and as required by this chapter, may make the left turn and the drivers of all other vehicles approaching the intersection from the opposite direction shall yield the right of way to the vehicle making the left turn. At an intersection at which a traffic signal is located, a driver intending to make a left turn shall permit vehicles bound straight through in the opposite direction which are waiting a go signal to pass through the intersection before making the turn.

Re: Rant: Not knowing the rules of the road

Posted: September 23 10, 9:49 pm
by StatmanCrothers
jim wrote:Show me one law that says it's ok to make a left turn without yielding to oncoming traffic.
my understanding is:

if you are both stopped at a stop sign at the same intersection, if it is a four way stop, then whoever gets there (and stops first) goes first, regardless if they are making a left turn or not.

I've always generalized this to apply to any intersection with stop signs.

i was somewhere, maybe Minnesota? where it was the damnedest thing, they had a law where some number (either 3 or 4) of cars would all go at a stop sign.

so say, it's a very busy 4 way stop at rush hour. instead of one at a time, once it was a right of way, if all four cars were already lined up and stopped, then all four (or 3 or whatever) would go. Meaning, the car with the right-of-way and the 3 cars behind it.

it worked a lot better.