Zomby Woof wrote:
so in that breath; what does a ATL v CIN series look like to you?
i expect a thoughtout-longwinded response, thanks.

haha. I'll do my best to comply.
One thing that's tough to call right now is who will have home-field advantage. They're just a game apart. If CIN ends up with the better record, we have to consider that ATL is bad bad bad on the road (29-37) while CIN has been just about = in their Home/Away splits, and is good both home and away.
So much of the playoffs comes down to hot/cold, but I think that phenomenon skews a tad toward hitters, and pitchers can be relied on to display less variance to their regular season performance in the playoffs (though obv they are not entirely safe from a worse- or better-than-normal outing.)
Lost in a lot of the Waino/Josh/Doc/Ubaldo talk this year: Tim Hudson has been lights-out. There's not a single pitcher on Cincy's team I like against Hudson, which I think gives ATL a distinct advantage. I equally like Tommy Hanson against whoever CIN lines up 2nd, and Jurrjens over CIN's 3rd starter. CIN could basically line up any three starters, and I'd take Hudson/Hanson/Jurrjens over them.
With Leake slowing down and hitting the DL with shoulder fatigue (Dusty pitching him 138 innings right out of the draft is insane and this is something we should have seen coming), Arroyo getting by with poor K and BB rates but a very lucky BABIP, and Volquez coming back and looking...meh...I think CIN's rotation would be tired and ineffective in a hypothetical series v ATL.
ATL has a superior bullpen to CIN as well. That counts for a lot in the playoffs, when you're playing close games in high leverage situations.
CIN is 6th in baseball in defensive efficiency, ATL 10th. I don't think either is more likely than the other to cost their team a win with a fielding blunder.
All-tolled, ATL is 3rd in the NL in runs allowed, CIN is only 9th. If post-season pitching is more predictive and reliable than post-season hitting, you gotta like ATL's odds on that front.
I'm not sure the "he's been there before" intangible applies, since neither really has a roster deep in playoff experience.
CIN, though, has definitely the best hitting lineup in the NL, and probably the best in MLB. If they get hot, it could be trouble for ATL. That's really the only way I can see CIN beating ATL in a five-game series: they get super-hot and the ATL pitching runs cold.