Page 1 of 4

JaMarcus Russell

Posted: May 6 10, 3:04 pm
by Lesson
This may not be the right forum to post this in, but here it goes. You're the Number 1 Pick in the NFL Draft and you're cut just three years after you were drafted. You're team gave you $31 Million in guaranteed money. Not only are you supposed to be the face of the franchise, you are supposed to have a good work ethic. Well, he doesn't. When you weigh 300 Pounds and play QB with $31 Million in guaranteed money, with a contract worth up to $68 Million, you deserve to pay back the money.

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Posted: May 6 10, 3:13 pm
by Michael
I wouldn't give back a dime.

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Posted: May 6 10, 3:15 pm
by StL Dan
I disagree, to an extent.

Oakland didn't have to pick Russell their #1 pick. But, does it surprise anyone that they did? If I were Russell, I wouldn't say "thanks, but no thanks. You're better off picking someone else".

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Posted: May 6 10, 3:15 pm
by Lesson
Michael wrote:I wouldn't give back a dime.

:D True, he probably won't but when a team invests that much into you and you don't even last your full contract as well as not leading your team to a winning season, you should pay back every cent. Once the salary cap is back in place, it may financially cripple(if that offends anyone, I apologize in advance) for a few years.

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Posted: May 6 10, 3:20 pm
by cardsfansince82
cardslesson101 wrote: it may financially cripple(if that offends anyone, I apologize in advance)
wat

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Posted: May 6 10, 3:21 pm
by StL Dan
cardslesson101 wrote:
Michael wrote:I wouldn't give back a dime.

:D True, he probably won't but when a team invests that much into you and you don't even last your full contract as well as not leading your team to a winning season, you should pay back every cent. Once the salary cap is back in place, it may financially cripple(if that offends anyone, I apologize in advance) for a few years.
Russell worked his rear end off to put himself into the position to be rewarded with #1 draft pick. So, he got bonused. BONUSED. He already earned that bonus by virtue of being the #1 pick.

If there is something he didn't "earn", it was the opportunity to sign an extension, much less earn the opportunity to play out his current contract.

So, they dumped him. Both sides are square.

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Posted: May 6 10, 3:26 pm
by Lesson
StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
Michael wrote:I wouldn't give back a dime.

:D True, he probably won't but when a team invests that much into you and you don't even last your full contract as well as not leading your team to a winning season, you should pay back every cent. Once the salary cap is back in place, it may financially cripple(if that offends anyone, I apologize in advance) for a few years.
Russell worked his rear end off to put himself into the position to be rewarded with #1 draft pick. So, he got bonused. BONUSED. He already earned that bonus by virtue of being the #1 pick.

If there is something he didn't "earn", it was the opportunity to sign an extension, much less earn the opportunity to play out his current contract.

So, they dumped him. Both sides are square.
You may be right about him playing his tail off to be in that position but he played at a very good football school with talent already in place. There are the Ricky Williams, Ryan Leaf's of the world when they could absolutely destroy your franchise when they don't perform or act at all like a #1 Overall pick should. If I was in the Raiders position in 2007, I would have absolutely taken Russell to be the 1st Overall pick. But when you weigh 300 pounds and don't perform at an all pro level for the amount of money he was payed for, you don't deserve that contract. In fact, I'd rather see the rest of Russell's contract go to charity or a portion of the money Russell earned go to charity. Look at Charles Rogers, the Lions were able to sue and get the bonus money back.

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Posted: May 6 10, 3:30 pm
by Leroy
I'm glad he's gone. Al's corpse must really be starting to smell now.

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Posted: May 6 10, 3:30 pm
by StL Dan
cardslesson101 wrote:
StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
Michael wrote:I wouldn't give back a dime.

:D True, he probably won't but when a team invests that much into you and you don't even last your full contract as well as not leading your team to a winning season, you should pay back every cent. Once the salary cap is back in place, it may financially cripple(if that offends anyone, I apologize in advance) for a few years.
Russell worked his rear end off to put himself into the position to be rewarded with #1 draft pick. So, he got bonused. BONUSED. He already earned that bonus by virtue of being the #1 pick.

If there is something he didn't "earn", it was the opportunity to sign an extension, much less earn the opportunity to play out his current contract.

So, they dumped him. Both sides are square.
You may be right about him playing his tail off to be in that position but he played at a very good football school with talent already in place. There are the Ricky Williams, Ryan Leaf's of the world when they could absolutely destroy your franchise when they don't perform or act at all like a #1 Overall pick should. If I was in the Raiders position in 2007, I would have absolutely taken Russell to be the 1st Overall pick. But when you weigh 300 pounds and don't perform at an all pro level for the amount of money he was payed for, you don't deserve that contract. In fact, I'd rather see the rest of Russell's contract go to charity or a portion of the money Russell earned go to charity. Look at Charles Rogers, the Lions were able to sue and get the bonus money back.
I think you are confused about why players get "bonus" money and "contract" money. They are paid for two different reasons.

Bonus money is automatic for any player chosen in the first round. It's not paid for services performed or to be performed. It's paid simply because of their high draft position.

Contract dollars are paid for performance on the field. To that extent, Jamarcus got what he "deserved" for being a #1 overall pick and, conversely, was fired by Oakland and will no longer be compensated for services performed. Contract terminated.

RE: Charles Rogers. Weren't there extentuating circumstances in that situation that allowed the Lions to get back some of his bonus unrelated to performance on the field?

edit: RE: Rogers - a court has ordered him to repay 6.1M of his 9.1M bonus because he abused narcotics and therefore defaulted on his contract. Did Russell default on his contract? Or did he just suck? Right now, we only have proof of the latter.

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Posted: May 6 10, 3:31 pm
by sighyoung
A day of relief and thanksgiving, if you own a Hometown Buffet franchise in the Oakland area.