Page 1 of 1

Rant: NFL draft "grades"

Posted: April 24 10, 5:10 pm
by stlouie_lipp
Nobody, and I mean nobody, can grade a team's draft until at least two years have passed. Busts and surprises don't emerge until years after the draft.

Re: Rant: NFL draft "grades"

Posted: April 24 10, 5:46 pm
by Spider John
I agree, but they gotta write something, and it makes for interesting reading. Only time will tell.

Re: Rant: NFL draft "grades"

Posted: April 24 10, 5:53 pm
by TGantz
Spider John wrote:I agree, but they gotta write something, and it makes for interesting reading. Only time will tell.
That pretty much sums it up.

Except for the "interesting reading" part. I haven't read any of the grades (except for the ESPN polls during the draft) because I want to make my own judgments on our draft. I personally liked that we drafted a few raw athletes ready to be molded. But because they aren't skill position players at major colleges, they might get rated badly by an ESPN writer.

Re: Rant: NFL draft "grades"

Posted: April 25 10, 1:22 pm
by Hungary Jack
Draft grades immediately after the draft are a bit absurd. But you can at least evaluate teams on how well they addressed specific needs based on the positions and relative skills of the players drafted.

I'll evaluate the Bears because I know them well enough. They really needed a safety who could start right away, and they were very fortunate that Major Wright lasted in a very deep safety draft into the third round. Good move.

They then chose Corey Wootton in round 4. Wootton was considered first round talent until he blew his ACL in January 2009. So this looks like a great value pick. But the Bears play a cover 2 scheme that emphasizes the front four penetrating and getting upfield. Wootton never had elite edge speed in a 4-3, but is a powerful rush end who is also stout against the run. He'd fit well as a 3-4 end, but his long-term future in the NFL is probably as a tackle. So he's a bit of a project, like Henry Melton, the converted running back they drafted last year to play tackle. So this pick, while great value, doesn't do much to the roster, IMO.

The Bears also needed help at cornerback after releasing Nate Vasher. The KSU player taken in round 5 has decent size and skills, but not a lot of experience. Fair enough. He might be able to contribute in a few years.

The Bears finally drafted to fill a need at guard in round 7. The drafted a tackle and cousin of Richmond Webb, but will move him to guard to address a pretty big need. He dominated against D II competition, but it is hard to imagine in contributing at guard in 2010, even though guard is a position where rookies can often play right away.

The other pick was QB Dan LeFevour. Whatever. They already have Caleb Hanie.

So the Bears needed to complete the draft with a potential starter at safety and help at guard. I think they did well at safety. I question taking Wootton over a better guard prospect in round 4. The CB pick reminds me a bit of Zack Bowman's pick 2 years ago--a physically talented player with limited experience. Bowman might turn out to be a decent player.

So, some good things, some OK things, some "huh" things. Grade: B.

Re: Rant: NFL draft "grades"

Posted: April 25 10, 3:37 pm
by InvincibleCakeEater
Kozma is an F.
Porcello is an A.

Re: Rant: NFL draft "grades"

Posted: April 25 10, 6:30 pm
by stlouie_lipp
As far as addressing needs...I'd give my Steelers a B-. They got help at the two weakest places, OL (drafting Pouncy) and CB (trading for McFadden) but didn't really address their soon-to-be needs at DL and ILB. With that said, I like the potnetial in the OLBs they got. With those picks they basically drafted their kick coverage for next year, which needed an upgrade.

Re: Rant: NFL draft "grades"

Posted: April 25 10, 6:58 pm
by Richie Allen
Draft grades are pretty much based on if teams did what they were expected to.