Page 1 of 2

Mike Tomlin and Clock Management

Posted: December 21 09, 10:29 am
by AWvsCBsteeeerike3
To those that didn't see the Green Bay/Pittsburgh game last night, you missed a good one.

Tomlin is taking a beating for his management at the end of the game, but I couldn't agree mroe with what he did. For those that missed it, here is what happened:

GB had marched down the field with ease on two consecutive drives in the 4th quarter, taking a 1 point lead.
Pitt kicked a fg with ~ 4 minutes to go to go up 2 points.
Pitt attempted an onsides kick and touched the ball too early...and that is the only reason they did not recover. Joe Buck and every media person in America threw a hissy fest as this being stupid.
GB scored a touchdown with ~ 2 minutes left and converted a 2 point conversion to go up 6 points
Pitt scored a touchdown and converted the extra point with no time remaining to win by 1 point.

It was a great game and I would contend if Tomlin elects to kick deep after taking a 2 point lead, GB would have marched down the field kicking a field goal as time expired.

Re: Mike Tomlin and Clock Management

Posted: December 21 09, 11:15 am
by clevername
yeah, I pretty much agree. If you feel the other team's offense is playing too well against your defense and you're not going to be able to stop them from scoring, I think it's better to take a chance on the onsides kick and probably at least leave yourself time to make a comeback yourself if they recover and score on a short field rather than a 75 yard drive that leaves you with 30 seconds.

Re: Mike Tomlin and Clock Management

Posted: December 21 09, 11:35 am
by Freed Roger
I was wondering if that was tomlins motive.

how about kicking away then not playing prevent D...play a blitzing scheme. I like this idea better. It would either lead to a big play one way or another. Gives your team a chance to make a play

Re: Mike Tomlin and Clock Management

Posted: December 21 09, 12:43 pm
by stlouie_lipp
He didn't hide in his post game presser. He basically said "I didn't think we could stop them and they couldn't stop us".

Re: Mike Tomlin and Clock Management

Posted: December 21 09, 12:46 pm
by AWvsCBsteeeerike3
Freed Roger wrote:I was wondering if that was tomlins motive.

how about kicking away then not playing prevent D...play a blitzing scheme. I like this idea better. It would either lead to a big play one way or another. Gives your team a chance to make a play
I thought about that, and that would be fine by me as well.

But.... I like what he did more. The D looked atrocious. Under your scheme, you basically are praying that your defense that is looking inept up to that point somehow reverses course and can make a stop. Something they hadn't done in the 4th quarter.

Also, you're assuming GB would go for the big play. What if under heavy blitz, they hit the hot route time and again? This runs the clock down as well without giving up the big play.

As it is, you give your team a chance to make 1 play. If that doesn't work, you give your offense which was playing far better than their defense a chance to win the game....which they did.

Re: Mike Tomlin and Clock Management

Posted: December 21 09, 2:34 pm
by clevername
well, their D/blitzes hadn't worked all night. Is there any real reason to believe they were holding something back they could throw at Green Bay at the end to stop them?

Re: Mike Tomlin and Clock Management

Posted: December 21 09, 2:57 pm
by Freed Roger
clevername wrote:well, their D/blitzes hadn't worked all night. Is there any real reason to believe they were holding something back they could throw at Green Bay at the end to stop them?
I wasn't as dumbfounded by the os kick as Buck was. It had some merit. But it took a lot of luck for it to work. Green Bay could have drained that clock more than they did.

Suppose they got it to first and goal. think they could have drained the clock

Re: Mike Tomlin and Clock Management

Posted: December 21 09, 3:10 pm
by clevername
Freed Roger wrote:
clevername wrote:well, their D/blitzes hadn't worked all night. Is there any real reason to believe they were holding something back they could throw at Green Bay at the end to stop them?
I wasn't as dumbfounded by the os kick as Buck was. It had some merit. But it took a lot of luck for it to work. Green Bay could have drained that clock more than they did.

Suppose they got it to first and goal. think they could have drained the clock
I think that's a risk worth taking, though. They're just as likely to run the clock out on a long drive.

Re: Mike Tomlin and Clock Management

Posted: December 21 09, 3:29 pm
by Popeye_Card
This isn't that much different than the Bill B. 4th down decision, except that a field goal puts you down, and an onside kick doesn't have quite the same success rate as a 4th down attempt.

Re: Mike Tomlin and Clock Management

Posted: December 21 09, 3:32 pm
by AWvsCBsteeeerike3
Freed Roger wrote:Green Bay could have drained that clock more than they did.

Suppose they got it to first and goal. think they could have drained the clock
That is precisely why I love LOVE LOVE what Tomlin did. Imo, he totally out maneuvered McCarthy those last couple minutes. Yeah, Green Bay could have, and likely should have, completely drained the clock. But, they didn't.

Reading Tomlin's comments on the post game interview, he acknowledged that was his thinking as well. He wanted this: 1. The ball back from the kick. 2. The ball back with enough time to score.

Yes, he assumed GB would score. It was the right assumption in my opinion.