Page 1 of 10
2009-2010 Bowl Discussion
Posted: December 6 09, 7:06 pm
by albertmvpujols
Boise vs. TCU is a joke. TCU should've been put up against Cincy or Florida and this isn't a slight on Boise at all as they are very good, but why the hell are both mid-majors playing each other. I would've loved to see TCU/Florida and Boise/Cincy or Boise/Iowa.
Re: 2009-2010 Bowl Discussion
Posted: December 6 09, 7:25 pm
by clevername
BCS making sure there's less ammo for a playoff if "lower tier" teams aren't given a chance to beat "upper tier" teams. The whole thing is a crock.
Re: 2009-2010 Bowl Discussion
Posted: December 6 09, 7:34 pm
by Hungary Jack
Agree with both y'all. Cincy and TCU finished 3-4 but I would much rather see TCU play Florida and Cincy play Oregon. I'm not sold on Cincy but they have earned the right to play a major conference team. Boise St. vs. Ohio St. would be another good matchup.
Re: 2009-2010 Bowl Discussion
Posted: December 6 09, 7:45 pm
by Maclowery
People in Iowa City are pissy about it, too. We have one of the best travelling fanbases in the country. Do they honestly expect to sell 80,000 tickets to those two schools? It's already debateable sports-wise whether the two easier-conference teams should play against eachother. Then add the financial mistake? Dumb.
Oh well, I think Iowa / GA Tech will be a really fun game.
Re: 2009-2010 Bowl Discussion
Posted: December 6 09, 7:50 pm
by cardsfansince82
I think guaranteeing there will be more than one undefeated team is dumb. Match them all up against big conference schools and settle the debate.
Re: 2009-2010 Bowl Discussion
Posted: December 6 09, 11:01 pm
by Faceman
Can anybody explain to me why Cincinnati isn't playing G Tech in the Orange Bowl? That is supposed to be Big East vs ACC right? The bowl did not lose their team to the BCS NCG so I don't understand.
BCS NCG: UT vs Bama (top 2, Big 12 vs SEC)
Rose: Oregon vs OSU (Pac 10 vs Big 10)
ACC: G Tech vs Cincy (ACC vs Big East)
Sugar: UF (SEC #2) vs BCS at large (TCU, Boise, Iowa)
Fiesta: At large vs at large, since no other Big 12 team is in.
I agree - Iowa vs Boise / TCU in Fiesta, Florida vs the other in the Sugar.
Edited to add: Not that any of it, beyond the big game, matters.
Re: 2009-2010 Bowl Discussion
Posted: December 6 09, 11:09 pm
by albertmvpujols
From wiki: The Big East's BCS representative is not tied directly to a specific BCS Bowl. It is selected to a bowl in the same manner as an at-large team. The BCS may choose select a second team to play in another BCS bowl game.
The Big East still has an auto bid, just not to any certain BCS bowl.
Re: 2009-2010 Bowl Discussion
Posted: December 7 09, 8:58 am
by phins
albertmvpujols wrote:Boise vs. TCU is a joke. TCU should've been put up against Cincy or Florida and this isn't a slight on Boise at all as they are very good, but why the hell are both mid-majors playing each other. I would've loved to see TCU/Florida and Boise/Cincy or Boise/Iowa.
In basketball, they call it the "George Mason effect" as the committee wants to put all non-BCS teams (for you Radio) against each other that they can. That way, it reduces their chances to have many advance. By pitting them against each other, it's a lose-lose for them.
Honestly, I think it just had to do with ratings...the bowl games are looking out for #1, and those teams just aren't going to get the compelling ratings and attendance figures...at least historically.
Re: 2009-2010 Bowl Discussion
Posted: December 7 09, 9:03 am
by JL21
phinstd wrote:Honestly, I think it just had to do with ratings...the bowl games are looking out for #1, and those teams just aren't going to get the compelling ratings and attendance figures...at least historically.
Perhaps, but I'd be a hell of a lot more inclined to watch an upstart TCU or Cincinnati or Boise St. in a bowl game than I would Iowa (or Georgia Tech, for that matter). I've had an opportunity to watch Iowa and GT every freakin' week. How many chances are there to catch TCU and/or Boise St.?
Re: 2009-2010 Bowl Discussion
Posted: December 7 09, 9:50 am
by phins
JL21 wrote:phinstd wrote:Honestly, I think it just had to do with ratings...the bowl games are looking out for #1, and those teams just aren't going to get the compelling ratings and attendance figures...at least historically.
Perhaps, but I'd be a hell of a lot more inclined to watch an upstart TCU or Cincinnati or Boise St. in a bowl game than I would Iowa (or Georgia Tech, for that matter). I've had an opportunity to watch Iowa and GT every freakin' week. How many chances are there to catch TCU and/or Boise St.?
Boise's on like every Friday night it seems...it's a shame, but the people picking these bowls do it solely on who they think can draw attendance and ratings.
Miami got picked for the Champs Sports over a team that beat them at their place, played in the conference championship, and had a better conference record (Clemson). Now Clemson is bumped all the way down to the Music City Bowl...ouch.
That Boise St./TCU game I may not even turn on...it's a sad commentary, but I just don't care now that they're playing each other. I'd have been more inclined to watch TCU versus Florida, or Boise versus Florida. That would have been fun to watch them matchup.