Page 1 of 2

Rave! Job offers.

Posted: June 26 09, 4:03 pm
by JCShutout
I'm hesitant to post this with GRBers struggling with layoffs, but I'm so excited (and I don't think most of you would want the pay I'm accepting). I have offers to be a literacy tutor in north stl with Americorps and as a field organizer with an organization trying to abolis the death penalty in Missouri. Its a nice "problem" to have. I think I will enjoy both and do both well. I will decide by Monday morning.

These are the things I will be discerning this weekend:

Teaching pros:

-I'd essentially be a reading specialist, which is something I want to look at doing for my career.
-There is a huge need for this. The issue is very important to me.
-Working directly with people is very life-giving for me.
-Helping get kids reading levels up might do more to keep people off death row than organizing.
-Gain a lot of experience, might make it easier to get a normal teaching job in the future.
-Work with a team, so if I struggle, I have people to lean on.
-Would be able to bike or take a bus to work (eco-friendly).

Teaching cons:

-Full time, same pay as other job means less time volunteering.

Organizing pros:

-Working with different groups, developing creative ideas, speaking engagements, vigils. (fun and creative work)
-I think the issue very important (duh! I applied).
-I wonder if the nonprofit justice world is a possible career for me.
-20 hours/week, same pay = more time volunteering with other endeavors. Also, work hours are flexible for the most part.
-They wanted me to take the full-time exec director role, and asked me in both interviews if I would consider working full time in the future-I think they want to groom me to take on a larger role in a couple of years.
-Part of my job would be to develop relationships with inmates, victim's families and police officers, be there for the former two, and try and develop a mutual respect with the other. That has the chance of being as life-giving as teaching.
-Part of the job is writing, and I'm good at that. (I've had a few letters to the editor published, and written articles for different organizations' newsletters)

Organizing cons:

-Band-aid solution to larger systemic problems.
-Less chance of success.
-Would have to drive all over the state (they do reimburse for travel, but its not as eco-friendly).

Re: Rave! Job offers.

Posted: June 26 09, 4:11 pm
by haltz
I don't like the death penalty either, but I'd much rather help kids learn to read than try and stop a handful of murderers from being killed each year.

Re: Rave! Job offers.

Posted: June 26 09, 4:19 pm
by JCShutout
haltz wrote:I don't like the death penalty either, but I'd much rather help kids learn to read than try and stop a handful of murderers from being killed each year.
Which is an excellent point, better chance for effectiveness, although if I took the part time job, I would spend more time tutoring kids in the neighborhood (our house offers a tutoring program)

Then again, lots of people want to help kids, not so many want to help those who have made heinous mistakes. Someone needs to work for their dignity too. They are still people.

Also to take into account, Americorps has like 3x as many applications this year than any other year, so there will be many to fill those spots if I turn that down.

(just starting the discernment process by thinking outloud)

Re: Rave! Job offers.

Posted: June 26 09, 4:19 pm
by cards2468
haltz wrote:I don't like the death penalty either, but I'd much rather help kids learn to read than try and stop a handful of murderers from being killed each year.
I gotta go with haltz, no offense, but I don't think you'll see much change to the death penalty laws for a while; the teaching job would be instant improvement for society.

Re: Rave! Job offers.

Posted: June 26 09, 4:20 pm
by thrill
Working with kids is some of the most rewarding work I've done.

Re: Rave! Job offers.

Posted: June 26 09, 10:33 pm
by slide_into_first
Take the one that pays more.

Re: Rave! Job offers.

Posted: June 26 09, 11:19 pm
by JCShutout
slide_into_first wrote:Take the one that pays more.
Heh, they're about the same. the organizing pays more in salary, but Americorps gives $4800 of loan forgiveness (and I'd qualify for food stamps) which would put them over the organizing job in terms of total pay (but its twice the hours). But I'm taking either a 57% or 66% pay cut to take one of the jobs. Money really isn't a motivation.

Re: Rave! Job offers.

Posted: June 27 09, 9:25 am
by phins
Philosophical differences aside, the teaching gig is something that I think you find very rewarding, and is an endeavor that you know will achieve lasting results (even if one person learns to read through your efforts). Knowledge is power my friend, and giving someone a chance at a bright future, rather than living out their days in a cell would be a no brainer.

You sound like an intelligent dude, and I imagine you don't need any of us to make the right decision for you. You'll do that all for yourself...

PS- Congrats on the job offers, the way I understand it, you weren't fulfilled in your other job.

Re: Rave! Job offers.

Posted: June 27 09, 9:50 am
by Freed Roger
Congrats jc.

Re: Rave! Job offers.

Posted: June 29 09, 12:10 pm
by JCShutout
I took the organizing job. There were a lot of positives and few negatives about both. The thing which spoke to my heart the most was, and I talked to other people, not just reading this thread, most people saw working with kids as rewarding and "worth" time and resources, but thought that prisoners were not "worth" that.

It sounds corney, but someone has to care about them because no one else will. There are countless people waiting for an Americorps offer. Children will not be without attention (hell I'm a jungle gym for the kids in the neighborhood). In my personal philosophy on life, living faithfully is more important than living "effectively" (although I do think living faithfully is effective on a personal grass-roots level). Its not my personal job to save the world (effectiveness). The world will be saved by beauty. Its my job to live as faithfully as possible, and reflect that beauty. Yes I could have done that with both jobs, so I took the one which spoke to me most right now based on need and human dignity.