Door to Door Activists
Posted: June 19 09, 6:14 pm
I just had a very nice young man named Mark stop by my front door asking me to sign his petition for 100% "clean energy" for Massachusetts within 10 years. Disappointed that Mark with his wispy alternative chin beard mono-rolled cyclists pant leg and multiple facial alloy decorations interrupted my daddy just wants a drink to relax after work time, I decided to tests Mark's understanding of the issue at hand (this is as near verbatim as I can recall a conversation from 10 minutes ago]:
Well Mark, that sounds like a great idea.
Thanks, so will you sign?
Absolutely, just a few quick questions first.
Okay.
What's the expected capital expenditure on such a lofty endeavor? Considering that Mass. is already running a substantial deficit, are you expecting any public spending?
I am not sure how much...something like this...it's important to reduce emissions.
I agree Mark! Critical stuff here. So we can safely assume that it's not going to be a budget line in any governmental omnibus spending bill, we're expecting it to come from the private sector.
Well that's one...
Can you think of a reason why an energy company would switch to a more costly and less reliable form of energy production when the current system is so overwhelmingly profitable for them?
...but carbon emissions are on th....
I agree, the environmental impact is what's important here, right Mark?
Right.
Great, so what's the plan, where are we getting our clean energy from 10 years from now?
With plans like the Cape Cod wind farm, things like that.
Absolutely! Quick question though Mark, what's the impact on the natural habitat out there with 150 turbines implanted 7 miles off-shore?
Coal is dirty energy, and our goal is to...
Yes it is Mark, and I am sure that the flora and fauna will adapt quickly. Birds will learn to avoid the area, and the fish will just live somewhere else. Mass. fisherman will follow them farther out into the sea...oh no Mark, that will require more gas in their boats won't it?
Well, that's poss...
Let's explore that thought some more, the socio-economic impact of such a quick adaptation of clean energy. For everyone currently employed at a coal and fossil fuel power plant, they'll be employed at the new sites right? The Cape Cod wind turbines....well, they won't need any employees after construction outside of periodic maintenance. What other types of power are we looking at here?
Well, wind and solar are the big ones.
My concern is the consistency of power there Mark. Are we going to look into geothermal, biomass, nuclear energy as well? Where are we putting these sites? Mass doesn't get enough sustained light for solar, and geothermal is great for local sites, but nothing can be scaled up enough given our population density.
Is there anyone else here I can speak with?
Just me Mark. So. I don't want to jump around too much on you, but I don't see how we can get 100% of our energy without importing from other states but then we're back to the public spending issues.
I am just going to go.
So you don't want me to sign?
Oh, um, will you?
No. No I will not Mark.
[Mark dejectedly backs away, nearly falling down my stairs]
Well Mark, that sounds like a great idea.
Thanks, so will you sign?
Absolutely, just a few quick questions first.
Okay.
What's the expected capital expenditure on such a lofty endeavor? Considering that Mass. is already running a substantial deficit, are you expecting any public spending?
I am not sure how much...something like this...it's important to reduce emissions.
I agree Mark! Critical stuff here. So we can safely assume that it's not going to be a budget line in any governmental omnibus spending bill, we're expecting it to come from the private sector.
Well that's one...
Can you think of a reason why an energy company would switch to a more costly and less reliable form of energy production when the current system is so overwhelmingly profitable for them?
...but carbon emissions are on th....
I agree, the environmental impact is what's important here, right Mark?
Right.
Great, so what's the plan, where are we getting our clean energy from 10 years from now?
With plans like the Cape Cod wind farm, things like that.
Absolutely! Quick question though Mark, what's the impact on the natural habitat out there with 150 turbines implanted 7 miles off-shore?
Coal is dirty energy, and our goal is to...
Yes it is Mark, and I am sure that the flora and fauna will adapt quickly. Birds will learn to avoid the area, and the fish will just live somewhere else. Mass. fisherman will follow them farther out into the sea...oh no Mark, that will require more gas in their boats won't it?
Well, that's poss...
Let's explore that thought some more, the socio-economic impact of such a quick adaptation of clean energy. For everyone currently employed at a coal and fossil fuel power plant, they'll be employed at the new sites right? The Cape Cod wind turbines....well, they won't need any employees after construction outside of periodic maintenance. What other types of power are we looking at here?
Well, wind and solar are the big ones.
My concern is the consistency of power there Mark. Are we going to look into geothermal, biomass, nuclear energy as well? Where are we putting these sites? Mass doesn't get enough sustained light for solar, and geothermal is great for local sites, but nothing can be scaled up enough given our population density.
Is there anyone else here I can speak with?
Just me Mark. So. I don't want to jump around too much on you, but I don't see how we can get 100% of our energy without importing from other states but then we're back to the public spending issues.
I am just going to go.
So you don't want me to sign?
Oh, um, will you?
No. No I will not Mark.
[Mark dejectedly backs away, nearly falling down my stairs]