Page 1 of 6
Louisiana boycotts science; scientists boycott Louisiana
Posted: February 16 09, 12:02 pm
by TimeForGuinness
http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2009 ... ce_sci.php
One of my favorite meetings is the annual Society for Integrative and Comparative Biology meetings. One of my favorite cities to visit is New Orleans, Louisiana. The two pleasures will not be coinciding at any time in the near future because of the ineptitude and inanity of Louisiana's legislature and governor, Bobby Jindal.
Re: Louisiana boycotts science; scientists boycott Louisiana
Posted: February 16 09, 12:54 pm
by Maclowery
I think that by next generation, people that still believe in literal creationism will be much less influential. There are still plenty of uneducated (scientifically) zealots out there, but their vague attempts at justifying the possibility of literal creationism are going to continue to be ridiculed by the academic world.
Explaining mystical elements in our religious texts scientifically is a really slippery slope, obviously. At some point, for the faithful, an element of mysticism has to come up; that's the foundation of religion. Atheists are going to argue that creationism is just as far-fetched and dated as Methuselah living eight times longer than the normal life span. Science vs. religion is, by definition, an un-ending debate. The faithful will always have to take a stand at some point, declaring certain core elements of their faith to be fact, despite scientific, erm, questioning.
I've always thought that in another century or two, that major religions will have basically 'retreated' their literal truths back to the core of whatever faith is in question. For Christians, Christ must, by definition, ascend above humanity. I think a lot of infuential spiritual leaders are concerned that giving ground to science - saying, for instance, that the bible isn't literal in many places, will start that slippery slope that will really challenge the faithful.
/history major diatribe out!
Re: Louisiana boycotts science; scientists boycott Louisiana
Posted: February 16 09, 12:58 pm
by crash2269
i am just trying to understand the position of some on the board...
if one believes in literal creationism that person in turn is less intellectual or has a lower education?
also, i don't think it's fair to say all republicans have an anti science basis. i don't understand why some think that religion and science have to be at odds with each other. there is nothing in religion that says science is evil or cannot help explain things we see in the natural world.
Re: Louisiana boycotts science; scientists boycott Louisiana
Posted: February 16 09, 1:00 pm
by JCShutout
Maclowery wrote:I think that by next generation, people that still believe in literal creationism will be much less influential. There are still plenty of uneducated (scientifically) zealots out there, but their vague attempts at justifying the possibility of literal creationism are going to continue to be ridiculed by the academic world.
Explaining mystical elements in our religious texts scientifically is a really slippery slope, obviously. At some point, for the faithful, an element of mysticism has to come up; that's the foundation of religion. Atheists are going to argue that creationism is just as far-fetched and dated as Methuselah living eight times longer than the normal life span. Science vs. religion is, by definition, an un-ending debate. The faithful will always have to take a stand at some point, declaring certain core elements of their faith to be fact, despite scientific, erm, questioning.
I've always thought that in another century or two, that major religions will have basically 'retreated' their literal truths back to the core of whatever faith is in question. For Christians, Christ must, by definition, ascend above humanity. I think a lot of infuential spiritual leaders are concerned that giving ground to science - saying, for instance, that the bible isn't literal in many places, will start that slippery slope that will really challenge the faithful.
/history major diatribe out!
There have already been many movements within mainline Catholicism and Mainline Protestantism which don't look at the Bible literally. This argument has existed millenia back. There were different schools of interpretation in Judaism, some which took the text literally, and some which ascribed many parts to be allegory.
I'm not sure why you have to lose the human Christ
Re: Louisiana boycotts science; scientists boycott Louisiana
Posted: February 16 09, 1:13 pm
by Radio_Bugtussle
pop_haines wrote:This anti-science bias from the GOP...I don't know whether to laugh or cry.
"Cheap nostalgia for the Salem Witch Trials." -- Jello Biafra
How you can rationally work the GOP into this is beyond me.
Re: Louisiana boycotts science; scientists boycott Louisiana
Posted: February 16 09, 1:13 pm
by Arthur Dent
Maclowery wrote:I think that by next generation, people that still believe in literal creationism will be much less influential.
I don't know about that. According to Gallup polls, the percentage of people who believe in literal creationism has remained essentially unchanged since 1982.
Re: Louisiana boycotts science; scientists boycott Louisiana
Posted: February 16 09, 1:27 pm
by ghostrunner
TimeForGuinness wrote:http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2009 ... ce_sci.php
One of my favorite meetings is the annual Society for Integrative and Comparative Biology meetings. One of my favorite cities to visit is New Orleans, Louisiana. The two pleasures will not be coinciding at any time in the near future because of the ineptitude and inanity of Louisiana's legislature and governor, Bobby Jindal.
This isn't quite clear - the Society is the one choosing not to go to New Orleans.
I don't understand boycotting a whole state over a misguided government policy. New Orleans isn't conservative, and it's still trying to recover. Is this like the scientist version of Atlas Shrugged, or the US banning commerce with Cuba?
Re: Louisiana boycotts science; scientists boycott Louisiana
Posted: February 16 09, 1:32 pm
by Maclowery
JCShutout wrote:Maclowery wrote:I think that by next generation, people that still believe in literal creationism will be much less influential. There are still plenty of uneducated (scientifically) zealots out there, but their vague attempts at justifying the possibility of literal creationism are going to continue to be ridiculed by the academic world.
Explaining mystical elements in our religious texts scientifically is a really slippery slope, obviously. At some point, for the faithful, an element of mysticism has to come up; that's the foundation of religion. Atheists are going to argue that creationism is just as far-fetched and dated as Methuselah living eight times longer than the normal life span. Science vs. religion is, by definition, an un-ending debate. The faithful will always have to take a stand at some point, declaring certain core elements of their faith to be fact, despite scientific, erm, questioning.
I've always thought that in another century or two, that major religions will have basically 'retreated' their literal truths back to the core of whatever faith is in question. For Christians, Christ must, by definition, ascend above humanity. I think a lot of infuential spiritual leaders are concerned that giving ground to science - saying, for instance, that the bible isn't literal in many places, will start that slippery slope that will really challenge the faithful.
/history major diatribe out!
There have already been many movements within mainline Catholicism and Mainline Protestantism which don't look at the Bible literally. This argument has existed millenia back. There were different schools of interpretation in Judaism, some which took the text literally, and some which ascribed many parts to be allegory.
I'm not sure why you have to lose the human Christ
I'm sorry, I was unclear, perhaps. I'm not calling for the toppling-down of major religions. Far be it. I think that religion and faith will continue to slowly play a smaller part in the 'average' life of our society, though. Its role has certainly diminished, on the whole, for several hundred years. I think that this is just a confusing time, when a three-way logjam between politics, science, and religion are all butting heads and trying to figure out how each must interact with another to reach some sort of equilibrium.
Specifically to Christianity, I don't think that faithful Christians will ever be able to scientifically justify Christ himself - and they shouldn't. Perhaps we'll see more and more ground given to science regarding many mystical elements of the New Testament, but that core, most simple notion that Christ is the son of God and is our Savior (and not just a really great guy who lived a few millenia ago), will always, by strict definition, defy science, as it is the simplest foundation of Christianity.
Re: Louisiana boycotts science; scientists boycott Louisiana
Posted: February 16 09, 1:46 pm
by JCShutout
Maclowery wrote:I'm sorry, I was unclear, perhaps. I'm not calling for the toppling-down of major religions. Far be it.
darn... kidding I think...
Maclowery wrote:I think that religion and faith will continue to slowly play a smaller part in the 'average' life of our society, though. Its role has certainly diminished, on the whole, for several hundred years. I think that this is just a confusing time, when a three-way logjam between politics, science, and religion are all butting heads and trying to figure out how each must interact with another to reach some sort of equilibrium.
I think that logjam has been present numerous times in history. I think religion isn't in the forefront of power like it was before, but I don't necessarily think people are more or less religious/spiritual than previous centuries, you just won't get culturally denounced (or worse) for not being religious. To try and make an analogy (which could be terrible), I don't think homosexuality is more prevalent today than in the past, rather, since its not as taboo as before, and the risk isn't as high (although hate crimes are still committed), along with modern psychology, more people are able to be open about who they are.
Maclowery wrote:Specifically to Christianity, I don't think that faithful Christians will ever be able to scientifically justify Christ himself - and they shouldn't. Perhaps we'll see more and more ground given to science regarding many mystical elements of the New Testament, but that core, most simple notion that Christ is the son of God and is our Savior (and not just a really great guy who lived a few millenia ago), will always, by strict definition, defy science, as it is the simplest foundation of Christianity.
Is there some need people are expressing to prove this scientifically? Mythology expresses a cultural truth. It should be challanged by the signs of the times (including science), but shoulden't necessarily fight with it. At some point science may be able to tell us more about the why, which would be wonderful. There will always be spirituality in some sense as there will always be wonder at the human condition, whether due to a limited mind or an open one.
Religious people worried about this stuff need to stop giving yesterday's answers to questions no one is asking anymore.
Re: Louisiana boycotts science; scientists boycott Louisiana
Posted: February 16 09, 2:51 pm
by sighyoung
So, does all this have to do with the Louisiana Science Education Act?
http://www.nola.com/news/index.ssf/2008 ... e_for.html