Page 1 of 3

Rave: MP3 players

Posted: August 10 08, 9:20 am
by jim
So I finally decided leap into the 21st century and bought a Sansa MP3 player for $49. 2GB + a screen. I love this thing. I've loaded a bunch of French language lectures onto it which is why I really bought it, but I might put some music on there as well someday.

I don't get the IPod thing though. My kids and wife have that, and I really don't see the value in those. For $49 I could have gotten a 1GB Ipod shuffle with no screen, or this Sansa 2GB with a screen and an FM radio built in to boot.

Re: Rave: MP3 players

Posted: August 10 08, 9:26 am
by ThatGuy
The Shuffle is nice and compact, but it would drive me crazy not to be able to play a song I wanted to hear right when I wanted to hear it. Other iPods are pretty expensive, but I've had mine for about a year now and I've got no complaints.

Is the Sansa comparable to the Shuffle in size?

Re: Rave: MP3 players

Posted: August 10 08, 10:23 am
by jim
ThatGuy wrote:The Shuffle is nice and compact, but it would drive me crazy not to be able to play a song I wanted to hear right when I wanted to hear it. Other iPods are pretty expensive, but I've had mine for about a year now and I've got no complaints.

Is the Sansa comparable to the Shuffle in size?
Pretty close. The sensa is more square in shape so you can have a screen, but it's really small. I just couldn't see why anyone would pay the same price for less memory and no screen. I don't know that the FM radio I'll use much, but it's there also.

Re: Rave: MP3 players

Posted: August 10 08, 10:37 am
by StatmanCrothers
yes, but what if you want every good song that was every released on a 45-rpm record, and you want them all to fit in the palm of your hand?

Re: Rave: MP3 players

Posted: August 10 08, 11:59 am
by Transmogrified Tiger
It's because iPods hate happiness. They're awful.

Re: Rave: MP3 players

Posted: August 10 08, 12:16 pm
by ThatGuy
Transmogrified Tiger wrote:It's because iPods hate happiness. They're awful.
Fail.

Re: Rave: MP3 players

Posted: August 10 08, 1:24 pm
by ghostrunner
They're certainly not awful. I'm on my second one in 6 years. It's durable if you get a good case, and it's easy to use.

I can't argue if someone thinks they're overpriced. But Apple's stuff doesn't feel cheaply made and outside of one iBook, every product I've ever had ran smoothly for a long time.

Re: Rave: MP3 players

Posted: August 10 08, 2:33 pm
by Jocephus
microsoft zune is where its at

Re: Rave: MP3 players

Posted: August 11 08, 12:43 am
by InvincibleCakeEater
Jocephus wrote:microsoft zune is where its at
Honestly, I haven't used it much, but I have actually been quite impressed each time I have.

Re: Rave: MP3 players

Posted: August 11 08, 6:58 am
by jeffbgoofy
I love my 4 GB Sansa, me and my wife both have one and my son has a 2 gb clip, been good to us...