so is the premise that the reason he ultimately went mad was because batman's dad called him a nutjob? is that something that's ever been alluded to in the comics?
really well done origin story that didn't feel like a comic book movie for once.
so is the premise that the reason he ultimately went mad was because batman's dad called him a nutjob? is that something that's ever been alluded to in the comics?
I think the idea is that he's a deeply damaged person, going back to being chained to a radiator and beaten by his mom's boyfriend as a child. The tipping point in that mens room scene with Wayne is the reveal that Penny is a wacko and Arthur was adopted, which sends him to Arkham to steal the records from Paperboi, which tells him the truth about Penny, which then leads him not to go kill Wayne but to go kill Penny.
Another big moment IMO is when he lets the little person clown go after killing 'You love Barry, you give him sub sandwich' guy. He knows the difference between those who have harmed him (Penny, the bros on the subway, DeNiro) and those who have not (Wayne, the little person clown.) The whole thing w/ DeNiro is basically a call for what bullying via viral video can do to a person.
I was the one that mentioned "Falling Down", and really the credit for that goes to a friend of mine. I finally saw Joker last night. Similar story arc to Falling Down, honestly, and they might be more similar than might be obvious at first glance. My thoughts:
The movie was visually great. The riot scenes were so damn realistic it was unsettling. Almost "uncanny valley".
One similarity to Falling Down is that in both films, you aren't sure how much of what we are seeing is is real, or just the character's imagination. Joker made it clear some of what we were seeing was fantasy, but the lines are blurred. Falling Down is more subtle about it, but also implies at least some of it is just in the character's mind.
Here is a take I heard on Joker that I find very intriguing. At several points in the movie, Joker encounters someone that he's hoping will help him in some way, or at least be kind to him. But they never are of course. His boss, the guy at the gate of Wayne's estate, the guy with his mom's medical records in the mental hospital, Thomas Wayne, the talk show host, etc. In every single case, they offer no help, and in some cases they treat him like [expletive]. The take I heard is that the point of the movie is that none of these people he interacts with can ever take a step back and see the bigger picture, and see that they helped create the conditions that created this monster. I'm not excusing mass murder or shifting blame or anything. These characters I'm talking about are not responsible for Joker murdering people, but they are all partially responsible for the soil of Gotham being so poisoned that a mass murdering psycho emerged from it. None of these characters Joker encounters ever want to admit that maybe the soil got poisoned on their watch, or that they had a small role in letting conditions in Gotham get so bad.
Now here is the kicker: when this movie was released, we had the same kind of conversations happen in the real world!!! There were tons of reviews and opinion pieces written saying that this movie was awful, that it was the "incel movie", that it was glorifying violence and hate, and so on....in other words none of the people writing these opinion pieces wanted to dare confront the question this movie is begging, which is: What's so wrong with our society that a movie like Joker even gets made, and that it turns out to be very popular? Nope, can't engage with that question. All of these critics agreed that it's 100% the fault of the filmmakers for making this awful film, and we shouldn't even entertain the idea that this film is critiquing our society in some way. These critics all reacted to the movie Joker the same way the characters in the film reacted to the character Joker.
pioneer98 wrote:I was the one that mentioned "Falling Down", and really the credit for that goes to a friend of mine. I finally saw Joker last night. Similar story arc to Falling Down, honestly, and they might be more similar than might be obvious at first glance. My thoughts:
The movie was visually great. The riot scenes were so damn realistic it was unsettling. Almost "uncanny valley".
One similarity to Falling Down is that in both films, you aren't sure how much of what we are seeing is is real, or just the character's imagination. Joker made it clear some of what we were seeing was fantasy, but the lines are blurred. Falling Down is more subtle about it, but also implies at least some of it is just in the character's mind.
Here is a take I heard on Joker that I find very intriguing. At several points in the movie, Joker encounters someone that he's hoping will help him in some way, or at least be kind to him. But they never are of course. His boss, the guy at the gate of Wayne's estate, the guy with his mom's medical records in the mental hospital, Thomas Wayne, the talk show host, etc. In every single case, they offer no help, and in some cases they treat him like [expletive]. The take I heard is that the point of the movie is that none of these people he interacts with can ever take a step back and see the bigger picture, and see that they helped create the conditions that created this monster. I'm not excusing mass murder or shifting blame or anything. These characters I'm talking about are not responsible for Joker murdering people, but they are all partially responsible for the soil of Gotham being so poisoned that a mass murdering psycho emerged from it. None of these characters Joker encounters ever want to admit that maybe the soil got poisoned on their watch, or that they had a small role in letting conditions in Gotham get so bad.
Now here is the kicker: when this movie was released, we had the same kind of conversations happen in the real world!!! There were tons of reviews and opinion pieces written saying that this movie was awful, that it was the "incel movie", that it was glorifying violence and hate, and so on....in other words none of the people writing these opinion pieces wanted to dare confront the question this movie is begging, which is: What's so wrong with our society that a movie like Joker even gets made, and that it turns out to be very popular? Nope, can't engage with that question. All of these critics agreed that it's 100% the fault of the filmmakers for making this awful film, and we shouldn't even entertain the idea that this film is critiquing our society in some way. These critics all reacted to the movie Joker the same way the characters in the film reacted to the character Joker.
Before sayiing anything else, I'd like to say the scene where Joker shoots Murray is, to my untrained eye, absolutely brilliant. First off, there's so much suspense in the background. Arthur had jus killed Randal. Then ran from the cops. So, who knows how much trouble he's in, but it's obviously enough for him to be arrested on site. Murray seems interested, if not likable, in the dressing room with their interaction. And, I found myself kind of rooting for Arthur to make a good appearance with the hope that it could lead to something positive for him...of course, there's no hope, his character is a foregone conclusion. But, despite everything, there's still that glimmer of hope and when he comes out on stage full of confidence, it's kind of refreshing. Then, there's the innocence of experiencing something he's undoubtedly thought about for some time, and the realization it's just like he imagined. Then there's the despair and admission. Then, the anger. Then, the crazy. It all just flowed so well, and when he shot Murray, I loved how the camera angle went from Arthur to Murray to Arthur to Murray to where you really get the up close looks of guys in a debate. Then, bam, you're reminded you're the audience, not inside Arthur or Murray's head, and get to experience the shot as if you're a member of the audience of Murray's show. Just really well done, imo.
Okay, that said, I don't get the complaints from reviewers that this was some political hit-piece or call to arms for MAGA incels or whatever. In no way is Arthur's side of the conflict glamorized. And, the cronies that rush to his POV in the movie are rarely even mentioned.
Moving on, like a few people have mentioned, what I enjoyed a lot about the movie is that there is so much material incorporated in a believable manner. At some point, I think in the 80s, mental institutions were scaled back with the majority of those either institutionalized or non institutionalized but recipients of treatment ending up in prison as their treatments were discontinued. And, not just those that are 'victims' of viral videos gone bad, but those that are outside the societal norms are looked down on by society at large. It's obvious Arthur is troubled. He was abused as a child and raised by a delusional woman who did not do enough to protect him. And, it's all too believable he was treated as an outcast by basically everyone. And, his path leads him down, what I can only imagine, is the path that many people have taken. It's not until the end, and possibly not until he was sitting on stage, did he decide to turn that despair and anger outward instead of on himself. Obivously in all his rehearsals he shoots himself, not anyone else. While this may/may not have been intentionally portrayed this way, I left thinking that this arc could be applied to a great many people who have, sadly, taken their own lives or taken lives of others. Arthur's moments of breaking were gut-wrenching, almost difficult to watch. The scene where he gets up to unlock the door for the guy from the HAHA clown company right after killing Randal was phenomenal. His parting thought of thanking of him for being the only guy that was nice to him was really well done.
That's not to say Arthur was right to do what he did or he acted in a noble manner, obviously. Just that, there are very real aspects to the backstory that apply in today's day and age. Which is unfortunate.
All that said, the interspersed comedic breaks, likely due to the dark nature of the film, really hit the mark. And, the story overall was well told in a logical manner. The acting was great, the soundtrack was great, the cinematography was great. Overall, well done on a really depressing topic.
Seems like a lot of people like to always compare who plays the Joker best. West, Nicholson, Ledger, etc. And, it's really not fair to lump Phoenix in with a group that just played the Joker with no insight to the man. If you have a follow up where Phoenix is battling Batman in a story that largely follows Batman and Joker is relegated to supporting cast, we can talk then. But, I have a tough time imagining anyone portraying the character in this movie better than Phoenix did. Dude absolutely nailed it, imo.
Before sayiing anything else, I'd like to say the scene where Joker shoots Murray is, to my untrained eye, absolutely brilliant. First off, there's so much suspense in the background. Arthur had jus killed Randal. Then ran from the cops. So, who knows how much trouble he's in, but it's obviously enough for him to be arrested on site. Murray seems interested, if not likable, in the dressing room with their interaction. And, I found myself kind of rooting for Arthur to make a good appearance with the hope that it could lead to something positive for him...of course, there's no hope, his character is a foregone conclusion. But, despite everything, there's still that glimmer of hope and when he comes out on stage full of confidence, it's kind of refreshing. Then, there's the innocence of experiencing something he's undoubtedly thought about for some time, and the realization it's just like he imagined. Then there's the despair and admission. Then, the anger. Then, the crazy. It all just flowed so well, and when he shot Murray, I loved how the camera angle went from Arthur to Murray to Arthur to Murray to where you really get the up close looks of guys in a debate. Then, bam, you're reminded you're the audience, not inside Arthur or Murray's head, and get to experience the shot as if you're a member of the audience of Murray's show. Just really well done, imo.
Okay, that said, I don't get the complaints from reviewers that this was some political hit-piece or call to arms for MAGA incels or whatever. In no way is Arthur's side of the conflict glamorized. And, the cronies that rush to his POV in the movie are rarely even mentioned.
Moving on, like a few people have mentioned, what I enjoyed a lot about the movie is that there is so much material incorporated in a believable manner. At some point, I think in the 80s, mental institutions were scaled back with the majority of those either institutionalized or non institutionalized but recipients of treatment ending up in prison as their treatments were discontinued. And, not just those that are 'victims' of viral videos gone bad, but those that are outside the societal norms are looked down on by society at large. It's obvious Arthur is troubled. He was abused as a child and raised by a delusional woman who did not do enough to protect him. And, it's all too believable he was treated as an outcast by basically everyone. And, his path leads him down, what I can only imagine, is the path that many people have taken. It's not until the end, and possibly not until he was sitting on stage, did he decide to turn that despair and anger outward instead of on himself. Obivously in all his rehearsals he shoots himself, not anyone else. While this may/may not have been intentionally portrayed this way, I left thinking that this arc could be applied to a great many people who have, sadly, taken their own lives or taken lives of others. Arthur's moments of breaking were gut-wrenching, almost difficult to watch. The scene where he gets up to unlock the door for the guy from the HAHA clown company right after killing Randal was phenomenal. His parting thought of thanking of him for being the only guy that was nice to him was really well done.
That's not to say Arthur was right to do what he did or he acted in a noble manner, obviously. Just that, there are very real aspects to the backstory that apply in today's day and age. Which is unfortunate.
All that said, the interspersed comedic breaks, likely due to the dark nature of the film, really hit the mark. And, the story overall was well told in a logical manner. The acting was great, the soundtrack was great, the cinematography was great. Overall, well done on a really depressing topic.
Seems like a lot of people like to always compare who plays the Joker best. West, Nicholson, Ledger, etc. And, it's really not fair to lump Phoenix in with a group that just played the Joker with no insight to the man. If you have a follow up where Phoenix is battling Batman in a story that largely follows Batman and Joker is relegated to supporting cast, we can talk then. But, I have a tough time imagining anyone portraying the character in this movie better than Phoenix did. Dude absolutely nailed it, imo.
CNN and MSNBC desperately wanted this to be a MAGA propaganda piece but anyone who actually went into it with an open mind saw that it was just a really well done and enjoyable comic book villain origin.
It was so well done, in fact, that i almost forgot it was comic book movie.
I guess maybe because it humanized the character. I found myself actually sympathetic towards the bad guy.
It was just nice see an original take on the origin of an agent of chaos.
I may actually try to go see it again on the big screen if its still out next weekend.