Stock Market Talk

Chat about non-baseball topics. No political discussions!
Post Reply
AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Stock Market Talk

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

pioneer98 wrote:
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:This has become my defacto place to put my thoughts, so forgive me if this annoys anyone.

But, has anyone been paying attention to bbry (blackberry, formerly RIM)? They've made a huge push to get back into the smartphone game and have doubled from about $7.50 to $15 in the past 6 months. They dropped from $16.?? to $14.?? the past couple days with their earnings report set for this week.

The results will indicate how successful Blackberry sales of their new phone have been in Europe, while not taking into account American sales, so there's something to it, at least more to it than a typical ho-hum earnings report...if there is such a thing.

Anyway, it seems like a good place to straddle the report and plan on a big move either up or down. Currently, I think it also might be a good idea to buy a bunch of call options or stock and plan on a build up of the price back to near $16 in anticipation of the report...and then sell off right before the numbers are reported.
No, I like reading your thoughts...but BBRY is a bit too risky for my tastes.

One of the ones I bought recently was DECK, and it is is up 25% since I bought it. I have to pat myself on the back for that one, because it offset part of the bath I've taken so far on DDD...

Watch DECK for the next month. Their earnings call is April 22. There is a HUGE short squeeze potentially going with them (I read short interest is 43% of outstanding shares). It is currently trading for $56/share. I suspect this could get bid up to close to $69/share in anticipation of the report ($69 is their 52 week high). Then, if the report is negative, it could drop back down into the 50s...if the report is positive, well, the price of good news would already be priced into the stock. Most analysts are thinking it is going to be a positive report, so the shorts are already getting squeezed right now. The stock is up like 10% just in the past 2 days.
I've read stories of people writing naked puts, the stock dropping, then getting absolutely [expletive] in a short squeeze (don't know if that is the right term there, but same principle). BAsically, the broker forcing them to buy puts to cover their position and the puts being ridiculously high, in a time of insane volatility as the brokerage firms all called the margins of the naked put writers. Insane. Selling stocks short and writing any type of option except a covered call really scares me though it seems there is a lot of profit there.

Re: DECK, that sounds like a brilliant plan. Obviously the downside would be the stock going up an insane amount after you sell. But, if you lock in a gain like that, it's tough to feel bad. I'm certainly not a fan of holding anything through an earnings report as there's too much risk involved, imo. Like you said, if it's a good report, "Ho-hum. Was expected. Stock goes up a little, but likely not very much" If it's a bad report, "Oh no, the sky is falling!!!! Sell! Sell! Sell!" and the stock plummets...at least for a little bit.

I look at blackberry, who had a great earnigns repot. Analysts expecte a loss of 22 cents per share and they gained 20 cents per share. Had a good launch of their new phone, have mostly positive reviews, have good margins from what I saw and the stock goes up....hardly at all.

Crazy.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Stock Market Talk

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

Here are some good energy stocks that I've been watching. LNG WPRT TGP TRGP

The only one I actually have money in is WPRT and will likely get out of it today. But, yeah. Just mostly energy stocks getting in on the energy boom, I hope.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Stock Market Talk

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

I'm going to expand on the BBRY earnigns because quite frankly this is amazing to me.

Here's a picture of what BBRY is doing and what it's calls are doing. You'll notice the calls near the money go up about an order of magnitude % wise (HPQ up .8% and call option up 9% and in the lower pic, LNG up3% call option up 33% or whatever).
Image

Image

It's all due to the implied volatility drop that accompanies the earnings report actually being reported. Still, crazy.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Stock Market Talk

Post by Arthur Dent »

Shouldn't options prices fall rather than rise in the case of reduced underlying volatility? The in the money call options increase in price when the underlying goes up because their intrinsic value has increased. Nothing to do with the passing of the earning reports decreasing uncertainty. The gains and losses are larger than on the underlying because you are essentially trading on the derivative.

If you think buy and hold of index funds is too risky, why are you looking at options trading?

EDIT: Maybe that comment refers only to BBRY where the call option would have increased 28% because of the rise in the underlying but actually fell 7% because of the drop in expected volatility. In the other cases you list, the change in option price is almost entirely due the change in the price of the underlying.

EDIT 2: I don't understand your math on the losses from the BBRY straddle either. It looks to me like the April 5 14.5 put fell from ~1.20 to ~0.45 (~63%) and the corresponding call fell from ~1.1 to ~0.7 (36%), so terrible losses on both sides.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Stock Market Talk

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

Arthur Dent wrote:Shouldn't options prices fall rather than rise in the case of reduced underlying volatility? The in the money call options increase in price when the underlying goes up because their intrinsic value has increased. Nothing to do with the passing of the earning reports decreasing uncertainty. The gains and losses are larger than on the underlying because you are essentially trading of the derivative.
Not quite sure what you're saying here.... decreasing uncertainty is going to decrease volatility. They go hand in hand. And, yes, premiums fall when volatility decreases. Yesterday the implied volatility was something like 100 and today closer to 60. That change came about because of the earnings report passing. The decrease in volatility completely negated the bump in underlying stock price. You had two variables each of which determine the premium acting against each other. In other words here are your four main variables influencing the premiums: Time to expiration barely changed, the strike price didn't change, but the underlying stock priceincreased while the volatility decreased. Two forces acting against each other and the premiums fell, despite their intrinsic value increasing. That's what I found crazy.
If you think buy and hold of index funds is too risky, why are you looking at options trading?
I've spoken about why I don't like index funds ad nauseum. In short, I am confident in my ability to do better. A lot of that revolves around recognizing and exploiting opportunities.

Here's an example, because I know you'll agree and see this the same way I do.

Last tuesday or wednesday, Oracle or some other tech stock had a bad day, so HPQ (which is on an absolute terror) loses 4%. It goes from like $23.50 to $22.40. Stupid, imo. But, it happened. So, I think HPQ is 4% undervalued...or $1 a share. What I have been doing in the past would be to simply buy as many shares as possible. I don't really feel comfortable disclosing how much I'm trading with but, let's say it's 400 shares. Buy 400 shares at $22.50 ($9000) or thereabouts and plan on selling at $23.50 ($9400). That's a good plan. More than a 3% gain which is my absolute minimum gain of even thinking about entering a trade. So, I could do that. And plan on making $386 after fees.

There's another route to take though because HPQ is widely traded and the options are fluid with small Bid and Ask separation. So, in order to make $400, and knowing the delta is only 0.7, and expecting a $1 gain in stock price, $400/0.7 = 571 rounded up means 600 shares are needed....or 6 contracts (100 contracts/share). The premiums were $1 at the time. So, that would involve buying 6 contracts at $1/share at 100 shares/contract or $600. A couple days later, as expected the stock jumps back to above $23.5 and the premiums rise to $1.70. $1.70/share x 100shares/contract x 6 contracts is a return of $1020. 1020-600-29 in fees = $391.

If the stock moves the way you want it to, you have to lay out only a fraction of the capital to get the same gains. This goes hand in hand with a higher % profit. Yeah, if HPQ dropped to $15, I'd have been [expletive], no different if I owned the stock. If it had dropped to $21, I'd have been in bad shape, but wouldn't have lost everything. Probaby could have still recoverd a couple hundred dollars.

OTOH, I couldn't 'lose it all' as people like to assume. Assuming $9000 was the value of my trading acct, and for some reason I lost all the money I put in play, that's still a manageable hit, less than 10%...the minimum amount most people will say a stop loss needs to be put.

In short, I don't think it's more risky. I think it's smarter to do it this way in certain situations. And, people that wager their entire accounts on options trading are stupid, drunk or simply addicted to gambling and will one day lose everything.
Last edited by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 on March 28 13, 3:40 pm, edited 3 times in total.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Stock Market Talk

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

Arthur Dent wrote:
EDIT: Maybe that comment refers only to BBRY where the call option would have increased 28% because of the rise in the underlying but actually fell 7% because of the drop in expected volatility. In the other cases you list, the change in option price is almost entirely due the change in the price of the underlying.

EDIT 2: I don't understand your math on the losses from the BBRY straddle either. It looks to me like the April 5 14.5 put fell from ~1.20 to ~0.45 (~63%) and the corresponding call fell from ~1.1 to ~0.7 (36%), so terrible losses on both sides.
Edit 1. Yes. I think.
Edit 2. I just did a quick guesstimate on the april 20th 14 c and p. I had 1.53 C and 1.28P jotted down on a notebook piece of paper on some date when I made this up in my head. I just took the high for the day (today) 1.99 x ~0.75 = ~1.5 (which isn't even the right way to do it) and saw the puts (today) at somewhere around 0.6? or so and said half.

So, yeah, the point remains, even if you hit the absolute high on the call options, you still were soundly defeated in this trade. Straddling seems like a horrible idea. I had no clue the volatility would make that big of a difference. Luckily I don't have to do that actual math of how much I would have lost. I'd probably actually have just held on to everything and would now be hoping for a big swing or some miracle. And, hope is not a strategy.

greenback44
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11665
Joined: June 26 06, 8:54 pm
Location: In a Small Town with Jack and Diane

Re: Stock Market Talk

Post by greenback44 »

There are perfectly good reasons to buy (or sell) volatility, especially for a company like BBRY, and straddling is one way to do that.

The more I read about DDD, the more I want to short it to zero.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Stock Market Talk

Post by Arthur Dent »

AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:The decrease in volatility completely negated the bump in underlying stock price. You had two variables each of which determine the premium acting against each other. In other words here are your four main variables influencing the premiums: Time to expiration barely changed, the strike price didn't change, but the underlying stock priceincreased while the volatility decreased. Two forces acting against each other and the premiums fell, despite their intrinsic value increasing. That's what I found crazy.
That doesn't seem particularly surprising to me. Buying the options for a straddle before the report cost a premium of at least $2/share meaning, roughly, that the share price had to move at least $2 to make any money (before fees). The main thing likely to trigger significant price swings in the short term was that earnings report. When it failed to produce that movement, it became obvious that the trade was a loss, so the options prices are going to crash reflecting that fact. To cash out without a big loss, you'd have to find some sucker to sell the options to who wanted to bet on a big movement coming soon even though the big news had come and and gone.
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:If the stock moves the way you want it to, you have to lay out only a fraction of the capital to get the same gains. This goes hand in hand with a higher % profit.
Yes, but I don't particularly get your logic in the HPQ example. What's the point of getting a higher percent return if you scale back your investment, so the that the total profit is exactly equivalent? Seems like you're just using the standard stock buy version of the trade as a benchmark for risk. If there's an advantage to the options approach, it's that by reducing the amount of capital required, you have the opportunity to earn a larger return by taking a larger risk. That's more or less the same basic strategy as picking highly volatile stocks to trade in. If you recognize the danger of putting your whole account in an options trade, you should see the danger in the volatile stocks too. It's the same thing amplified.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Stock Market Talk

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

Arthur Dent wrote:
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:The decrease in volatility completely negated the bump in underlying stock price. You had two variables each of which determine the premium acting against each other. In other words here are your four main variables influencing the premiums: Time to expiration barely changed, the strike price didn't change, but the underlying stock priceincreased while the volatility decreased. Two forces acting against each other and the premiums fell, despite their intrinsic value increasing. That's what I found crazy.
That doesn't seem particularly surprising to me. Buying the options for a straddle before the report cost a premium of at least $2/share meaning, roughly, that the share price had to move at least $2 to make any money (before fees). The main thing likely to trigger significant price swings in the short term was that earnings report. When it failed to produce that movement, it became obvious that the trade was a loss, so the options prices are going to crash reflecting that fact. To cash out without a big loss, you'd have to find some sucker to sell the options to who wanted to bet on a big movement coming soon even though the big news had come and and gone.
Exactly. And, it's kind of tough to find suckers when the market is pretty much set for you. I am still shocked that BBRY outperforming analysts eps by what 45 cents, being in the black instead of the red and having successful launches and good reviews with the next phone set to debut on time resulted in BBRY only moving 1% (down at that) today. I thought that a report like that would have generated some movement. It didn't. SO, yeah, learned about volatility trumping intermediate stock movement (which as you note is not surprising). Also, don't assume that volatility necessarily means a big move is coming. REally, I just can't believe the stock didn't jump on that report. I feel so...defeated.
AD wrote:
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:If the stock moves the way you want it to, you have to lay out only a fraction of the capital to get the same gains. This goes hand in hand with a higher % profit.
Yes, but I don't particularly get your logic in the HPQ example. What's the point of getting a higher percent return if you scale back your investment, so the that the total profit is exactly equivalent? Seems like you're just using the standard stock buy version of the trade as a benchmark for risk. If there's an advantage to the options approach, it's that by reducing the amount of capital required, you have the opportunity to earn a larger return by taking a larger risk. That's more or less the same basic strategy as picking highly volatile stocks to trade in. If you recognize the danger of putting your whole account in an options trade, you should see the danger in the volatile stocks too. It's the same thing amplified.
This is a great point that I don't have an answer for right now.

A couple things off the top though. If you own a volatile stock, it's going to go up or down more so than a non-volatile stock. Granted. But, during a trade it's not going to go to zero, nor is it going to lose 50%. On day 3 of holding a stock if it opens down 5% on an imbalance, that sucks. But, hopefully you can still get out with a small win or loss. If a stock opens down like that when you're holding options that is a huge hit. You're basiclaly faced with a choice to sell for a 50% loss if not more or hope it shoots back up. That's a big difference and no stop loss is going to prevent it. The amplification factor when all your money is on the line makes them not even close to the same strategy, imo. It would be stupid to put yourself in a position to have to make that decision (sell for 50% or hope the stock comes back). Again, jmo.

My plans have changed over the year. It's basically gotten to the point where I have a goal, believe it or not, that is a % each month. So, that helps give me some guidelines. As you'd expect though, it's not that easy. I see things that I've seen for the past couple months and just take for granted I'm going to trade it. XTXI and KKD earnings reports, namely. It's more risk than I need to take on to hit the target, but it just seems like easy money. Then HPQ comes along and the exact question you asked came to my head. Being that I didn't 'need' to trade it to hit a target, X contracts seemed like a justifiable, safe number. But, yeah, afterwards, it's like [expletive], should have done more...that's what got me here, not [expletive] footing around. Plus, it's not a given that every month there will be a trade that will yield the results I'm looking for, so...eat while the foods hot or whatever.

I don't know. I don't have an answer would be a better answer than what I gave above.

User avatar
pioneer98
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22007
Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
Location: High A Minors

Re: Stock Market Talk

Post by pioneer98 »

greenback44 wrote:The more I read about DDD, the more I want to short it to zero.
Go for it! What do you think about SSYS, which is basically the sister of DDD? Another 3D printing stock, XONE, jumped nearly 10% today on good earnings, and pulled SSYS and DDD along with it a bit.

I'm extremely long on these 3D printing stocks...they could drop a ton in the short term, but I'm determined to hold them for a looooong time. Their technology just has too much going for it. I realize that not all of them might survive. There easily could be some of them that go to zero. But one of these companies is likely to figure it out and become huge. It could take 10 years though for all I know.

EDIT: This analyst thinks DDD is worth $47/share:
http://seekingalpha.com/article/1305551 ... urce=yahoo

Post Reply