Nope. Just like you have to be critical of all music. Television, too.Fat_Bulldog wrote:Who gives a [expletive]?
Is it okay just to watch movies for the enjoyment/entertainment aspect?
movies
- BW23
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12896
- Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm
Re: movies
- The Third Man
- It rubs the lotion on its skin.
- Posts: 8935
- Joined: July 17 06, 1:00 pm
Re: movies
I don't disagree with your general thoughts re: Gladiator (though I think that movie is decent enough, and Joaquin Phoenix absolutely devours the scenery which is awesome) or Forrest Gump or the Oscars in general, but I will go to my grave defending Titanic. I think melodrama gets an insanely bad rap and I can scarcely think of better modern examples. I've been meaning to do a lengthy write-up of it that really delves into it piece by piece but I tend to be really lazy about that sort of thing, and otherwise it becomes more difficult to elucidate why I feel so strongly about it.
Love Yi Yi and George Washington, for what it's worth.
Love Yi Yi and George Washington, for what it's worth.
- JL21
- NPR & THT Contributor
- Posts: 36109
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
- Location: Chocolate City
Re: movies
I'm kind of over this, both personally and big picture. Every schmuck who's seen a few Criterion films thinks they're a critic these days and gleefully bashes anything and everything possible that doesn't meet their subjective view of "great cinema". It's masturbatory blood sport. They're far too interested in crapping on a movie in a new and exciting way, full of cynicism, hyperbole, and vitriol, than they are actually asking themselves what the movie might have done well or gotten right.The Third Man wrote:Tearing into movies can be fun as hell.
Don't get me wrong- this isn't specifically aimed in this thread. It's a cultural thing. And it gives the good, real critics and film theorists who honestly want to know more about a film or study a film a bad name.
Basically, I would 1,000 times rather hear why someone loves certain films than I would why they hate everything about ____________.
- 33anda3rd
- Replies Authoritatively
- Posts: 8390
- Joined: April 7 13, 9:45 am
- Location: Chicago, IL
Re: movies
Ebert's "Your Movie Sucks" is fantastic fun.
Rosenbaum's "Movies As Politics" is also great fun, and a very intelligent look at why we should be critical of the politics of movies. To marry that to what's in this thread (re Gump and re JL's dislike for trashing movies) I do think it's important when you have something that, say, masquerades as a sweeping, entertaining, Important-with-a-capital-I movie and something more than a surface viewing reveals a politics that is incredibly arch or ugly or un-progressive in some way, that movie deserves to be called out.
Consider "Coyote Ugly," which came out in the height of the Britney Spears era. Young girl moves to the big city, a songwriter full of aspirations. Nothing happens. Til she starts dressing scantily and dancing on top of a bar and pouring alcohol into people's faces. Then everything takes off for her. If they had moved the politics of that movie just, like, 20 degrees to the left, you could have had a nice commentary on how we fetishize/sexualize young female pop stars. Instead, we get something ugly, an empty entertainment that says "this is how you young ladies can get ahead." It's not saying that explicitly, but it's in the underlying politics of the film, and it's ugly and worth calling out IMO.
Rosenbaum's "Movies As Politics" is also great fun, and a very intelligent look at why we should be critical of the politics of movies. To marry that to what's in this thread (re Gump and re JL's dislike for trashing movies) I do think it's important when you have something that, say, masquerades as a sweeping, entertaining, Important-with-a-capital-I movie and something more than a surface viewing reveals a politics that is incredibly arch or ugly or un-progressive in some way, that movie deserves to be called out.
Consider "Coyote Ugly," which came out in the height of the Britney Spears era. Young girl moves to the big city, a songwriter full of aspirations. Nothing happens. Til she starts dressing scantily and dancing on top of a bar and pouring alcohol into people's faces. Then everything takes off for her. If they had moved the politics of that movie just, like, 20 degrees to the left, you could have had a nice commentary on how we fetishize/sexualize young female pop stars. Instead, we get something ugly, an empty entertainment that says "this is how you young ladies can get ahead." It's not saying that explicitly, but it's in the underlying politics of the film, and it's ugly and worth calling out IMO.
-
Vidor
- You've just been hit by...VidorSmarm™
- Posts: 22956
- Joined: June 10 10, 7:50 pm
Re: movies
I liked "Titanic". And saying it wouldn't be good without the FX is like saying Kate Upton wouldn't be as sexy if she gained 200 pounds. The FX were what made "Titanic" a good movie, and they were tremendous.
That said, it did absolutely steal the Oscar from "LA Confidential". "Titanic" isn't as offputting as "Forrest Gump" and its "the secret to happiness is being an ignorant yokel" message, but it didn't deserve to win the Oscar. The Oscars get it right sometimes, like with "No Country for Old Men", but usually they don't.
That said, it did absolutely steal the Oscar from "LA Confidential". "Titanic" isn't as offputting as "Forrest Gump" and its "the secret to happiness is being an ignorant yokel" message, but it didn't deserve to win the Oscar. The Oscars get it right sometimes, like with "No Country for Old Men", but usually they don't.
- AdmiralKird
- MBA, CPA, CFA, CFP, JD, PE, MD
- Posts: 10178
- Joined: March 7 07, 4:50 pm
- Location: Tycho Crater, Luna
Re: movies
The thing about Titanic is period films are really difficult to make things feel authentic. You have to scrounge together old cars, clothing, sets, etc. and remove everything modern. It's such a barrier to entry that elevates content where a show like Mad Men wouldn't be worth half a darn if it was set in the 2010's.Vidor wrote:I liked "Titanic". And saying it wouldn't be good without the FX is like saying Kate Upton wouldn't be as sexy if she gained 200 pounds. The FX were what made "Titanic" a good movie, and they were tremendous.
The thing with Titanic is its a period piece set in an environment that is both lost to history and is extravagantly luxurious, even by today's standards. The effects combined with this make it feel special, real, and bring a unique tragedy unlike any other to memorizing life.
- slide_into_first
- is unaware that dangerous is the real Tyler Durden
- Posts: 14433
- Joined: June 10 09, 11:31 pm
- Location: In Chula Vista hanging with the Surenos
Re: movies
I saw american hustle today for the 1st time. Liked it
-
Jocephus
- 99% conan clips
- Posts: 64992
- Joined: April 18 06, 5:14 pm
Re: movies
them fightin' wordsslide_into_first wrote:I saw american hustle today for the 1st time. Liked it
- The Third Man
- It rubs the lotion on its skin.
- Posts: 8935
- Joined: July 17 06, 1:00 pm
Re: movies
I totally agree with you. I mean, I'll tear into movies, but almost every time I do, it's in a conversation with buddies where, ultimately, we're trashing things because we find it funny - like pointing out hilarious leaps of logic in the recent Batman films, e.g. in TDKR when Batman returns to Gotham to stop a giant fission bomb on a timer from going off but apparently spends several hours working up an elaborate gasoline Bat symbol on a bridge arch. Thing is, I still like those movies - but it's cathartic to point out how stupid parts of them are.JL21 wrote:I'm kind of over this, both personally and big picture. Every schmuck who's seen a few Criterion films thinks they're a critic these days and gleefully bashes anything and everything possible that doesn't meet their subjective view of "great cinema". It's masturbatory blood sport. They're far too interested in crapping on a movie in a new and exciting way, full of cynicism, hyperbole, and vitriol, than they are actually asking themselves what the movie might have done well or gotten right.
Don't get me wrong- this isn't specifically aimed in this thread. It's a cultural thing. And it gives the good, real critics and film theorists who honestly want to know more about a film or study a film a bad name.
Basically, I would 1,000 times rather hear why someone loves certain films than I would why they hate everything about ____________.
But ultimately I can't work up the passion to really spend time hating a movie. When I see something I think is absolute garbage - most recently, Killing Zoe - I just want to make my distaste for it known loud and clear and move on to the [expletive] I love. I'm an optimist at heart, which is why I'd way rather spend my time trying to get other cineastes to see my appreciation for Titanic or Spring Breakers or whatever than I would telling somebody why whatever genre blockbuster they like is garbage. (Granted, the more movies I watch, the more I find myself drawn to the smarter, more ambitious genre films like Dredd and whatnot.)
- The Third Man
- It rubs the lotion on its skin.
- Posts: 8935
- Joined: July 17 06, 1:00 pm
Re: movies
Also, I'm finally seeing Lucy tonight with a pretty girl, so that oughta be fun.




