Yep. Something can be great art but terrible entertainment. In fact, that is often the case.cardsfansince82 wrote: Malick's movies are boring. Cinematography only goes so far. You're using a weird definition of universal acclaim since maybe half of critics like his movies and absolutely no one goes to the theater to see them.
movies
- thrill
- bronoun enthusiast
- Posts: 30539
- Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
- Location: barely online
Re: movies
- JL21
- NPR & THT Contributor
- Posts: 36109
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
- Location: Chocolate City
Re: movies
I love Days of Heaven and like Badlands a lot. I also like Thin Red Line quite a bit. Tree of Life felt like directorial masturbation and I loathed it. I haven't seen his other films, but I'll say that I'm not especially a fan. I think he's got a tremendous eye for cinematography but I tire of his half nature documentary/half actual movie schtick, especially in larger doses.
Yeah, pretty much. BUT OMG, SHE'S SO QUIRKY, ISN'T IT GREAT?!?heyzeus wrote:Saw Frances Ha on Netflix over the break becuase it was on some peoples' year-end lists. My god. If you don't hate 20 somethings today now, watch this movie and you soon will. It is the riveting struggle of a privileged young woman to avoid a job she is offered yet still get her own apartment in New York.
Online
- heyzeus
- Everday Unicorn
- Posts: 43332
- Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
- Location: Austin, TX
Re: movies
So quirky that the director divorced his wife just after giving birth to their child to be with her!JL21 wrote:I love Days of Heaven and like Badlands a lot. I also like Thin Red Line quite a bit. Tree of Life felt like directorial masturbation and I loathed it. I haven't seen his other films, but I'll say that I'm not especially a fan. I think he's got a tremendous eye for cinematography but I tire of his half nature documentary/half actual movie schtick, especially in larger doses.
Yeah, pretty much. BUT OMG, SHE'S SO QUIRKY, ISN'T IT GREAT?!?heyzeus wrote:Saw Frances Ha on Netflix over the break becuase it was on some peoples' year-end lists. My god. If you don't hate 20 somethings today now, watch this movie and you soon will. It is the riveting struggle of a privileged young woman to avoid a job she is offered yet still get her own apartment in New York.
-
Vidor
- You've just been hit by...VidorSmarm™
- Posts: 22956
- Joined: June 10 10, 7:50 pm
Re: movies
As a movie, "To the Wonder" was a great perfume commercial.
- The Third Man
- It rubs the lotion on its skin.
- Posts: 8935
- Joined: July 17 06, 1:00 pm
Re: movies
Nah, [expletive] that. Assuming that we're not using a definition of entertainment that strictly means "fun" - rather, engaging, emotionally resonant, etc. - then a movie that is "terrible" entertainment is by definition not great or even good. If you wanna say a movie can display great artistry and be terrible, sure. By the same token, I don't buy into that "so-bad-it's-good" crap. It's just good - I don't care if perceived incompetence in terms of craftsmanship results in something entertaining. The ends justify the means. (Which is not the same thing as something being "intentionally" terrible, an argument which I would never ever make, especially since I don't care what somebody's intent is.)trill wrote:Yep. Something can be great art but terrible entertainment. In fact, that is often the case.
Also, my favorite Malick is The New World.
Well screw you too buddy!heyzeus wrote:Saw Frances Ha on Netflix over the break becuase it was on some peoples' year-end lists. My god. If you don't hate 20 somethings today now, watch this movie and you soon will. It is the riveting struggle of a privileged young woman to avoid a job she is offered yet still get her own apartment in New York.
- The Third Man
- It rubs the lotion on its skin.
- Posts: 8935
- Joined: July 17 06, 1:00 pm
Re: movies
Watched this this morning and couldn't disagree more with this characterization, but that's probably because I actually know people exactly like this (Hell, I've even had the exact same "Would you eat a domesticated dog?" conversation before) and don't agree at all that the film is wholeheartedly behind Frances. She's empathetic - lord knows I can relate to her stubborn refusal to ground herself, or the fact that she seems to be stagnating while all her friends seem to have the "adult" thing figured down - but there's a pretty strong sense of "This chick is a [expletive] airhead weirdo who needs to get her [expletive] together" at the same time. It's like Woody Allen: The Post-College Years and I love Woody so I'm down with it. Plus the B&W cinematography (shot on a camera that costs less than most of my friends' used cars) is gorgeous.heyzeus wrote:Saw Frances Ha on Netflix over the break becuase it was on some peoples' year-end lists. My god. If you don't hate 20 somethings today now, watch this movie and you soon will. It is the riveting struggle of a privileged young woman to avoid a job she is offered yet still get her own apartment in New York.
I can see why it rubs people the wrong way, though.
Bleh, I think "quirky" has become my second-most hated word in film criticism behind "pretentious." She's not some free spirit that we're supposed to cheer for as she flies through life avoiding the oppression of a white-collar button-down desk job. It's only at the end when she finally takes that desk job that she gets her [expletive] together, and realizes that life is more than the uncompromising pursuit of dreams - there's a time and place for both. Plus, look at the stares her dinnermates give her when she starts rambling that one night after her dance buddy invites her, or the fact that even her roommate's one-night-stand immediately calls her out on being somebody who completely doesn't have her [expletive] together.JL21 wrote:Yeah, pretty much. BUT OMG, SHE'S SO QUIRKY, ISN'T IT GREAT?!?
- The Third Man
- It rubs the lotion on its skin.
- Posts: 8935
- Joined: July 17 06, 1:00 pm
Re: movies
On a lighter note, I'm downloading the Female Convict 701: Scorpion series of films - four films of Japanese prison revenge sexploitation starring Meiko Kaji, aka that girl who sings the song in Kill Bill after Uma Thurman kills Lucy Liu, or, if you're a dork, the star of Lady Snowblood (which is where Tarantino cribbed the song from). And she looks (well, looked) like this:

So, should be a good time.

So, should be a good time.
Online
- heyzeus
- Everday Unicorn
- Posts: 43332
- Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
- Location: Austin, TX
Re: movies
I agree with you to some extent; the movie does gently call her out on her youthful obnoxiousness. For example, when she complains about being poor, and her friend tells her not to do that as it is insulting to actual poor people. But a movie can subtly take a few digs at the insufferable myopia of youth but, at the same time, be insufferably myopic. Much like how Family Guy takes an ironic/disaffected approach to, say, racial or juvenile humor, and thereby grants itself a pass to engage in material that otherwise it would be rightfully slammed for. Girls (the tv show) is way more guilty of wallowing in self-centered, oblivious elevation of mundane struggles to something Really Important. But Frances Ha is too. It tries to elevate the "struggles" of its protagonist to, for example, avoid a desk job and get her own apartment or see her BFF more often to something more significant than they are, which is off-putting. It was the movie equivalent of someone shouting "omg, the worst thing happened to me on Twitter today!"The Third Man wrote:Watched this this morning and couldn't disagree more with this characterization, but that's probably because I actually know people exactly like this (Hell, I've even had the exact same "Would you eat a domesticated dog?" conversation before) and don't agree at all that the film is wholeheartedly behind Frances. She's empathetic - lord knows I can relate to her stubborn refusal to ground herself, or the fact that she seems to be stagnating while all her friends seem to have the "adult" thing figured down - but there's a pretty strong sense of "This chick is a [expletive] airhead weirdo who needs to get her [expletive] together" at the same time. It's like Woody Allen: The Post-College Years and I love Woody so I'm down with it. Plus the B&W cinematography (shot on a camera that costs less than most of my friends' used cars) is gorgeous.heyzeus wrote:Saw Frances Ha on Netflix over the break becuase it was on some peoples' year-end lists. My god. If you don't hate 20 somethings today now, watch this movie and you soon will. It is the riveting struggle of a privileged young woman to avoid a job she is offered yet still get her own apartment in New York.
I can see why it rubs people the wrong way, though.
Bleh, I think "quirky" has become my second-most hated word in film criticism behind "pretentious." She's not some free spirit that we're supposed to cheer for as she flies through life avoiding the oppression of a white-collar button-down desk job. It's only at the end when she finally takes that desk job that she gets her [expletive] together, and realizes that life is more than the uncompromising pursuit of dreams - there's a time and place for both. Plus, look at the stares her dinnermates give her when she starts rambling that one night after her dance buddy invites her, or the fact that even her roommate's one-night-stand immediately calls her out on being somebody who completely doesn't have her [expletive] together.JL21 wrote:Yeah, pretty much. BUT OMG, SHE'S SO QUIRKY, ISN'T IT GREAT?!?
- The Third Man
- It rubs the lotion on its skin.
- Posts: 8935
- Joined: July 17 06, 1:00 pm
Re: movies
I can appreciate the perspective, I think it's gonna be difficult for anybody who isn't on the same wavelength as Frances and her friends to dig it.
Basically I'm calling you old. Burn.
Basically I'm calling you old. Burn.
Online
- heyzeus
- Everday Unicorn
- Posts: 43332
- Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
- Location: Austin, TX
Re: movies
But my immaturity keeps me relatively youthful!

