Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑July 25 25, 9:13 am
The write up on JJ and Doyle from TheAthletic
Preseason 2025 Rank: 32
What if Wetherholt was, in fact, the best player in the 2024 draft class all along? He slipped to the seventh pick in large part because he was hurt so much of the spring with a recurring hamstring issue that dated back to the previous summer. He hit .300/.425/.466 in Double A this year, barely missing a day, and went 8 for 20 in his first six games in Triple A, with a .400/.500/.800 line there in the small sample. He’s probably going to move over to second base in deference to a plus defender at some point, but he’s an average or so shortstop with good instincts. The value here is the bat, and he can really, really hit.
Preseason 2025 Rank: Ineligible
Doyle was the top pitcher on my pre-draft board, as he had the draft’s most unhittable fastball, up to 100 with life up in the zone that hitters struggled to pick up out of his hand. He’s got a plus splitter to pair with it, working up with the heater and down with the split, along with a slider that doesn’t grade out that well on shape but that plays up because of the deception in the delivery and the way hitters were geared up for the fastball. Some teams didn’t love the delivery and thought he’d end up in relief; I see that possibility, but he also repeats his mechanics so well and holds his stuff deep into games well enough that he has to go out as a starter. The Cardinals might be the perfect spot for him to refine the slider and maybe make some small changes to the delivery to improve his odds of staying in the rotation. He has No. 2 starter upside and, at worst, looks like he’d be an animal out of the pen.
Most of us fall into the trap of liking information when it goes along with our thoughts and dismissing it when it doesn't (confirmation bias) and that is something I might be doing here, but this is exactly how I saw both players. I was absolutely over-the-moon with Wetherholt at 7. Especially for this organization and their development track record (the type of player Wetherholt is has shown great development with the Cardinals and the Charlie Condon types have not). They've already gotten more rotational acceleration out of Wetherholt (essentially this is proven by how he is now elevating the ball to the pull-side instead of constantly the other way).
Doyle has a fastball of death. The delivery is different and certainly has several of the markers that portend to future injury (if there was a way to accurately forecast injury you'd be a zillionaire and wouldn't be typing on GatewayRedbirds), but it's so athletic and strong that I think he can hold it and be a great starting pitcher. Not Skenes' level, but the next level down, which seems to be what Law is saying as well.
MLB drafting has gotten so much better since the data revolution (the hit rate is better, but in avoiding the landmines as well) and the Cardinals have really been great at not complicating things and just taking great prospects with reduced risk early. I loved Griffin last year, but the risk didn't show an expected value outcome that the Cardinals could risk in my view.
Look at this napkin math example:
Wetherholt with his skill and polish: ~25% 50FV, ~25% 55FV, ~25% 40FV, ~10% 60 FV, ~5% 20FV, ~10% 35FV = ~50FV
Griffin with his tools and physicality: ~5% 70FV, ~5% 65FV, ~10% 60FV, ~15% 55FV, ~15% 50FV, ~15% 40FV, ~20% 35FV, 15% 20FV = ~45FV
Right now, Griffin is tracking to hit somewhere in his 80th percentile outcome (60 FV) and that's great for the Pirates. The downside was his 50th percentile was more in the 40FV range, whereas Wetherholt's was more in the 50FV range (average starting MLB player).
We could be having the same debate in a few years over Seth Hernandez (coincidentally the same two teams), but it will still be a smart pick in my view because of the above calculations where the Cardinals needed to get an average or better starting player for cheap. The Pirates have to take swings for the 60+ FV types to ever be viable. This is merely my opinion, of course.