RxOfCowbell wrote:vinsanity wrote:There's a difference between going after a QB at 100% and encouraging guys to take late hits and cheap shots to purposefully injure an opponent like Favre.
That's what penalties and fines are for. Any player who would willingly take a penalty or a fine for a cheap bounty is an idiot. Has there been evidence that the bounties included injuries caused from illegal hits? Especially since the coaches were involved, they'd have to be complete morons to implement something like that.
According to Easterbrook, if you go back and watch the Vikes/Saints games there were 4 or 5 roughing the passer calls that were missed. Apparently, after the first quarter Brett Favre was running backwards 10-15 yards to avoid hits. Even in the Vikes/Saints game, I don't think any fines were levied for the two late hits that were called, much less the 4 questionable ones that weren't.
I'm all for playing hard. I think bumping in to the QB after he throws the ball and getting flagged is crap. I also think some of those hits on Favre were malicious.
As to why? If you're a second or third stringer or on special teams, currying favor with the coaches to keep your job year-to-year. It's not to keep from getting axed, but if the coaches are offering up bounties and two players are on the cusp - one has gotten a player off the field and the other hasn't, whose more likely to be back?
McCray of New Orleans delivered two flagrant, late, vicious hits to Favre, one that was flagged and one that was not. McCray is a journeyman who saw the field occasionally for several teams, then was out of the NFL at age 29. For a player who is not a star, picking up a couple of thousand in cash tax-free could be attractive, as could playoff bonuses. Each Saints player received $121,000 in NFL-sanctioned bonuses for winning the NFC title game and Super Bowl that year. Such bonuses could mean a lot to journeyman players.
Again, there's a difference between running full speed at a qb, getting there a step after he throws and wrapping him up and taking him to the ground and wrapping him up and hurling him to the ground in anything that doesn't resemble a form tackle. I don't think it's necessarily contradictory to be ok with clean, legal, hard hits and find encouraging late hits and unnecessary roughness disturbing.
Food for thought, also from the Easterbrook article.
Michael Vick went to prison for nearly two years for harming dogs, which he should not have done. Williams offered players money to harm people.