Matt Holliday

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by vinsanity »

jim wrote:TWho on here wasn't happier to see Craig in LF than Holliday game 7? I was. That speaks loudly I think.
Who would you rather have for 162 games in LF for 2012? 2013?

Craig was hot and Holliday wasn't healthy. We were all happy to see a healthy, hot bat in the lineup.

People complain if a guy sits when injured ala Drew, people complain if a guy complains he's benched from injury ala Rolen and people complain if a guy plays, but poorly, when injured ala Holliday.

Can't win.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31097
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by Popeye_Card »

Fat Strat wrote:Holliday was a beast in the NLCS -- .435/.500/.652/1.152. That's about as good as it gets. We don't make the WS if he doesn't play that way against Milwaukee.
Despite that nice looking stat line, he had a 0.025 total WPA in the NLCS. In 4 of the 6 games he was negative. He basically had 1 important game--Game 4, where he went 2 for 3 with a HR, a BB, and 1 RBI--and they ultimately lost that game.

So I'm thinking the Cardinals win that series with or without Holliday. But at the same time, he was sneaky valuable in the NLDS against the Phillies outside of 1 bad game (Game 5, which they of course won anyway). So it evens out.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by jim »

Fat Strat wrote:Just pointing out that judging players based on a few postseason ab's is pretty pointless and usually completely arbitrary.

Holliday was a beast in the NLCS -- .435/.500/.652/1.152. That's about as good as it gets. We don't make the WS if he doesn't play that way against Milwaukee.

Edit to add: It was Jim who said "Those series you refer to are called the World Series, and yes it does define entire careers." If we're going to judge players on their WS performance and allow that to define their careers, then we need to do it consistently -- thus, my reference to Ozzie's complete awfulness in the WS.
Fielding, baserunning, clutch hitting ... Ozzie > Holliday so far. Ozzie was the NLCS MVP. And judging players on their postseason play is not pointless imo at all. And I think we still get to the WS without Holliday in the NLCS. Here is some WPA info on Holliday in that 1.152 OPS series he had:

Game 1: +.05
Game 2: +.01
Game 3: -.09
Game 4: +.18
Game 5: -.04
Game 6: -.05

Total: +.06

Matt Holliday has a way of turning a 1.152 OPS into basically nothing about as good as any player I have ever seen. I'm waiting for the "randomness" of this to wear off, and look forward to when it swings back the other direction.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by jim »

Popeye_Card wrote:
Fat Strat wrote:Holliday was a beast in the NLCS -- .435/.500/.652/1.152. That's about as good as it gets. We don't make the WS if he doesn't play that way against Milwaukee.
Despite that nice looking stat line, he had a 0.025 total WPA in the NLCS. In 4 of the 6 games he was negative. He basically had 1 important game--Game 4, where he went 2 for 3 with a HR, a BB, and 1 RBI--and they ultimately lost that game.

So I'm thinking the Cardinals win that series with or without Holliday. But at the same time, he was sneaky valuable in the NLDS against the Phillies outside of 1 bad game (Game 5, which they of course won anyway). So it evens out.
I came up with a +.06. It was even less than that? I hand calculated mine so I may have screwed up.

You don't have to tell me what a great player Holliday is, I know that. I just hope the next time we get an opportunity he shows it, and I do think he has something to prove to the fans of St. Louis on the big stage.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by jim »

vinsanity wrote:
jim wrote:TWho on here wasn't happier to see Craig in LF than Holliday game 7? I was. That speaks loudly I think.
Who would you rather have for 162 games in LF for 2012? 2013?

Craig was hot and Holliday wasn't healthy. We were all happy to see a healthy, hot bat in the lineup.

People complain if a guy sits when injured ala Drew, people complain if a guy complains he's benched from injury ala Rolen and people complain if a guy plays, but poorly, when injured ala Holliday.

Can't win.

I would rather have Holliday for a 162 games than Craig because he's a better player. But game 7 of the 2011 World Series I wanted Craig. So I think that kind of says right there that Holliday hasn't done what we hoped for on the big stage, and because of that I think he still has something to prove in St. Louis.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by jim »

vinsanity wrote:
jim wrote:TWho on here wasn't happier to see Craig in LF than Holliday game 7? I was. That speaks loudly I think.
Who would you rather have for 162 games in LF for 2012? 2013?

Craig was hot and Holliday wasn't healthy. We were all happy to see a healthy, hot bat in the lineup.

People complain if a guy sits when injured ala Drew, people complain if a guy complains he's benched from injury ala Rolen and people complain if a guy plays, but poorly, when injured ala Holliday.

Can't win.

I would rather have Holliday for a 162 games than Craig because he's a better player. But game 7 of the 2011 World Series I wanted Craig. So I think that kind of says right there that Holliday hasn't done what we hoped for on the big stage, and because of that I think he still has something to prove in St. Louis.

User avatar
ilstu24
All-Star
Posts: 1344
Joined: September 24 08, 10:31 am
Location: Illinois St.

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by ilstu24 »

Jim, i'm with you. I love Holliday as a player, but when the going gets tough I always think he folds up like a lawn chair. He actually has a lot to prove this year, and I hope he sees this as an opportunity. First off he has to get healthy, which he should be going into the season. Then we will go from there. Baby Steps.

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by vinsanity »

jim wrote:Holliday hasn't done what we hoped for on the big stage, and because of that I think he still has something to prove in St. Louis.
I agree he hasn't had as much playoff success as we'd like but I'm not sure it leaves anything to prove. He was abysmal against the Dodgers in 2009. So was Albert and Ludwick and Capt Clutch Molina. Outside of Rasmus the team was pretty disappointing as a whole.

Then he was injured this year.

I guess I think saying he has to 'prove something', even come playoff time seems a little harsh. It's 26 PA's in the WS this year. You don't look at Craig's 42 PA's in August and say "Well he's got something to prove after that .702 OPS performance". He's been disappointing overall in big spots in the playoffs, but I think if he's healthy and the team makes it to the playoffs, he'll regress towards the mean.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by jim »

He's making like 8 billion dollars a year to produce, so please forgive my "harshness". And I'm all for regressing to the mean in this case. I'm glad David Freese didn't regress toward the mean after winning his NLCS MVP award.

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Matt Holliday

Post by vinsanity »

jim wrote:He's making like 8 billion dollars a year to produce, so please forgive my "harshness". And I'm all for regressing to the mean in this case. I'm glad David Freese didn't regress toward the mean after winning his NLCS MVP award.
:D

So if he has a .900 OPS and a walkoff hit in October this year he'll be worth $8 billion, but if he wins the MVP and has a .750 OPS in October he won't?

I guess I just don't understand what he has to prove. We agree that he's better than Craig, but a hot healthy Craig is better than an injured Holliday. That he can handle the 'pressure'?

Post Reply