JackofDiamonds wrote:I will really miss ICE's baseball insight and I think the board just became substantially less informed because of it. I didn't always agree with him, but he always backed up his arguments with research rather than anecdotal [expletive]. Caustic? Yes. Flippant? Of course. So what?
You hit the nail on the head with flippant. Over the course of his time here, ICE evolved into a posting style that became almost entirely flippant. His "insight" came with less and less evidence or knowledge and more and more condescending flippant remarks that would dismiss off hand whatever or whoever he disagreed with. He constantly harped on the same tired old tropes and added nothing constructive or new to the dialogue.
I understand how it can get frustrating disagreeing with the same people over the same things for years and how it easily becomes tedious to have to constantly explain the easily quantifiable to people who don't believe in what you're saying for ignorant or misguided reasons. But what our message to ICE always was, and to everyone on this board is, is that if you cannot deal with disagreements in a constructive manner, you need to refrain from posting flippant, dismissive replies. Being right doesn't give you license to add nothing but off-hand condescension to people you disagree with. Baseball knowledge isn't a license to spread an unwelcome tone to every thread you post in. Period.
He had
years to learn how to not post anything if he couldn't post anything thoughtful. Instead he insisted on thoughtlessly littering threads with his to quote you, flippant remarks.
This is why Snayke isn't here. This is why Boyer isn't here. This is why ICE isn't here and it may be why other people we now know and love aren't here in the future. Honestly if I spent more time in Baseball Talk, it would be why I'm not here.