NFL Week 8

A forum for non-baseball sports
Post Reply
phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by phins »

PujolJunkie wrote:
lukethedrifter wrote:
PujolJunkie wrote:Steven "I'm gonna get my 80 yards" Jackson is the most overrated RB in the league.

Wondering how that crow tastes or if you even think you might need to eat some?

Seriously, playing running back in the NFL and getting lots of yards is not an easy thing to do. They have guys on the other side trying to stop you. SJ may not be the greatest back in the history of the NFL but I'll tell you what, he's a damn fine one and football people know it.
Maybe my main issue has been outlined in the posts that followed this one. I'm used to watching Rams football and seeing Marshall Faulk hit a hole, fly upfield and trot into the endzone like a friggin' cheetah. None of the "hop the side, stutter step, juke, spin, then hit the hole" things that Steven Jackson does seem necessary to me. But the main difference, as everyone has said, is that Marshall actually had an offensive line to provide him with opportunities. And they had a future HoF QB who opened up more than enough opportunities for Marshall to break things open on the ground. Steven Jackson has neither of these things.

I never said he wasn't a good RB. I just said that I don't feel like he's one of the elite. He's an above average RB who can have a good game when he gets the opportunities. But Marshall Faulk was probably the most elusive runner I've ever seen in my life. If the o-line slipped and he had 3 guys on him, he didn't panic, he didn't concede, he still ended up with 6 or 7 yards. He made his opportunities. Maybe I'm just spoiled by the Rams of old. That'll probably never change.
Barry Sanders must have been before your time...

User avatar
redbirdjazzz
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4921
Joined: April 17 06, 10:50 am
Location: Columbia, MO

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by redbirdjazzz »

phinstd wrote:
PujolJunkie wrote:
lukethedrifter wrote:
PujolJunkie wrote:Steven "I'm gonna get my 80 yards" Jackson is the most overrated RB in the league.

Wondering how that crow tastes or if you even think you might need to eat some?

Seriously, playing running back in the NFL and getting lots of yards is not an easy thing to do. They have guys on the other side trying to stop you. SJ may not be the greatest back in the history of the NFL but I'll tell you what, he's a damn fine one and football people know it.
Maybe my main issue has been outlined in the posts that followed this one. I'm used to watching Rams football and seeing Marshall Faulk hit a hole, fly upfield and trot into the endzone like a friggin' cheetah. None of the "hop the side, stutter step, juke, spin, then hit the hole" things that Steven Jackson does seem necessary to me. But the main difference, as everyone has said, is that Marshall actually had an offensive line to provide him with opportunities. And they had a future HoF QB who opened up more than enough opportunities for Marshall to break things open on the ground. Steven Jackson has neither of these things.

I never said he wasn't a good RB. I just said that I don't feel like he's one of the elite. He's an above average RB who can have a good game when he gets the opportunities. But Marshall Faulk was probably the most elusive runner I've ever seen in my life. If the o-line slipped and he had 3 guys on him, he didn't panic, he didn't concede, he still ended up with 6 or 7 yards. He made his opportunities. Maybe I'm just spoiled by the Rams of old. That'll probably never change.
Barry Sanders must have been before your time...
I think PJ said he was 18/19, so SAnders would've retired about the time he was 7 or 8. I remember watching Michael Jordan when I was 9, but the Lions weren't on TV in Missouri as often as the Bulls were in the mid-90s. It's crazy to think that Barry Sanders retired 11 years ago. I feel old.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by Freed Roger »

phinstd wrote:
PujolJunkie wrote:
lukethedrifter wrote:
PujolJunkie wrote:Steven "I'm gonna get my 80 yards" Jackson is the most overrated RB in the league.

Wondering how that crow tastes or if you even think you might need to eat some?

Seriously, playing running back in the NFL and getting lots of yards is not an easy thing to do. They have guys on the other side trying to stop you. SJ may not be the greatest back in the history of the NFL but I'll tell you what, he's a damn fine one and football people know it.
Maybe my main issue has been outlined in the posts that followed this one. I'm used to watching Rams football and seeing Marshall Faulk hit a hole, fly upfield and trot into the endzone like a friggin' cheetah. None of the "hop the side, stutter step, juke, spin, then hit the hole" things that Steven Jackson does seem necessary to me. But the main difference, as everyone has said, is that Marshall actually had an offensive line to provide him with opportunities. And they had a future HoF QB who opened up more than enough opportunities for Marshall to break things open on the ground. Steven Jackson has neither of these things.

I never said he wasn't a good RB. I just said that I don't feel like he's one of the elite. He's an above average RB who can have a good game when he gets the opportunities. But Marshall Faulk was probably the most elusive runner I've ever seen in my life. If the o-line slipped and he had 3 guys on him, he didn't panic, he didn't concede, he still ended up with 6 or 7 yards. He made his opportunities. Maybe I'm just spoiled by the Rams of old. That'll probably never change.
Barry Sanders must have been before your time...

Barry Sanders was incredible to watch. He gambled a lot with running East West and usually got away with it. He did get shut down though- playing for some terrible teams behind awful lines, being the lone offensive threat. Faulk was probably the closest in style to Sanders, and a money player. The nose for the goal line. Great receiver. Faulk was like a great closer in baseball, he would drain the last 5 minutes on the clock to get a win.

Payton was excellence personified - he was on the downhill side of his career when the bears won SB, but still very good. Have to admit OJ Simpson ranks up there with the best I've seen at RB.

I'd have a hard time picking one. different offensive realities they dealt with.

[/youtube]

User avatar
clevername
Bringer of FRBG
Posts: 10380
Joined: April 16 06, 7:13 pm
Location: Alabama

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by clevername »

I'm not a Rams fan and don't usually see much of their games, but I would think what Jackson has done with a crap team around him would indicate that he's quite a bit above average. Imagine his production if he had a line to block for him or if defenses had to respect the pass?

User avatar
epinephrine
Veteran Player
Posts: 772
Joined: August 4 09, 9:24 pm
Location: 815, IL

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by epinephrine »

It does. The only thing Jackson doesn't have in contrast to other top RB's is TD's. Most of that can be attributed to the fact that his offense leads the league in red zone turnovers (although he accounts for at least one of those, that I recall). Still ranks right up there with the elite RB's in the league, because he has the handicap of an inept passing game and an inconsistent offensive line.
Last edited by epinephrine on November 2 09, 5:08 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
epinephrine
Veteran Player
Posts: 772
Joined: August 4 09, 9:24 pm
Location: 815, IL

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by epinephrine »

this picture will tell you everything you need to know about Jackson:
Image

User avatar
Hungary Jack
Mother Earth
Posts: 19536
Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
Location: In Cognito

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by Hungary Jack »

epinephrine wrote:this picture will tell you everything you need to know about Jackson:
Image
Exactly. There's not a run blocker in sight.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by lukethedrifter »

Marshall Faulk was an incredible talent and a very different football player than SJ. And many of Faulk's yards came against defenses that were trying to stop on of the most prolific passing games in NFL history.

Everybody (read: most fans) yell and scream about backs not hitting the hole fast enough but the streets are filled with RBs that hit the hole immediately. Elite RBs are patient enough to let the play develop then hit the hole. And sometimes that hole doesn't exist or sometimes their instincts take them the wrong way and they lose yards. But if RBs ran the way fans bellowed for them to they would all be Jim Otis, a fine NFLer and Cardinal who would need 300 carries to get a 1000 yards.

User avatar
epinephrine
Veteran Player
Posts: 772
Joined: August 4 09, 9:24 pm
Location: 815, IL

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by epinephrine »

Hungary Jack wrote:
epinephrine wrote:this picture will tell you everything you need to know about Jackson:
Image
Exactly. There's not a run blocker in sight.
hahaha. Not exactly the vision I had in mind, but truthful. He has run blockers this year though. I've seen Jason Smith, Karney, and Jason Brown going downfield plowing fools over. That picture is misleading.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: NFL Week 8

Post by Freed Roger »

lukethedrifter wrote: Everybody (read: most fans) yell and scream about backs not hitting the hole fast enough but the streets are filled with RBs that hit the hole immediately. Elite RBs are patient enough to let the play develop then hit the hole. And sometimes that hole doesn't exist or sometimes their instincts take them the wrong way and they lose yards. But if RBs ran the way fans bellowed for them to they would all be Jim Otis, a fine NFLer and Cardinal who would need 300 carries to get a 1000 yards.
fans are narrow-minded about how Jackson should run purely straight ahead.. We used to hear a similar hollering "Why don't they hand the ball to Faulk every down.!?"

I'm guessing the fans were wrong, but on to something. Faulk should have gotten more carries. And Jackson did had a tendency for too much backfield dancing - I think he led the league in rushing attempts for losses in prior years. Yes Jackson's surrounding cast played a role in this, but so did he.

It really looks like he's figured things out-which speaks even greater for him considering the team circumstances. He seems more mature. Duly impressed that he's running amidst all this traffic and managing to not fumble as well.

Post Reply