Affleck is just kind of meh in his role - I don't want him to be the CIA equivalent of McGonigle on the Simpsons, brash and recklessly disobeying orders because he's right, but he sort of does that anyway and it's not that inspiring. And the US government just immediately bends to his will. Turns out that didn't happen at all, which I don't really care about, but it didn't ring true at the time either.
Reminded me a bit of Black Hawk Down in that it's more or less a point-to-point re-enactment of events without a the right amount of context to make it interesting. We have a larger picture of what's going on, but the Iranians themselves are nothing but mobs. And we don't come to know much about the hideaways, other than the one David Cross lookalike who initially acts like almost every person on the bus in Speed - "I have zero options, but dammit if I won't complain!"
I wouldn't have minded seeing the same story from the point of view of the housekeeper, as I found myself more invested in the few minutes she had than in any other individual's story.
The Hollywood side of it seemed to exist to leaven things a bit, but I found that sequence where Goodman and Arkin have to cross a movie set really strange. A makeup guy and a producer are the only two able to man phones for this operation, and this is all they do? Really all the last-minute barriers to the Americans leaving the country seemed contrived and cliched.
Did a search and someone mentioned Silver Linings Playbook being better, and I have to agree. Had cliches of it's own, but I felt invested in the characters in a way that I didn't feel here. I may sound like a fool here, but I'd even say Skyfall is a better film. But they're essentially both tense action movies, so why not?
EDIT - my favorite critic's review is I'd say dead-on
http://www.philadelphiaweekly.com/scree ... 80641.html
I liked this line:
and this part is all correct:It’s a clean, efficient studio crowd-pleaser aimed at adults. There probably should be at least 10 or 12 of these a year, but since there aren’t, let’s celebrate Argo,
Confidently helming his third directorial effort, Ben Affleck once again proves himself a genius with actors who are not Ben Affleck. A murderer’s row of supporting players fill out Argo, the aforementioned Arkin and Goodman doing their most playful work in years, backed up by an invaluable Bryan Cranston and too many more to mention. The only speedbump here is the star-director himself—much like in The Town, he just can’t resist soulfully mugging for the camera while granting himself iconic shots nicked from John Ford movies.
He also pumps the climax a little harder than he needed to, straying from the historical record in order to goose the audience along for the ride. No matter, as the first two thirds of Argo are sleek, machine-tooled Hollywood craftsmanship at its most purely entertaining, positioning Affleck as a filmmaker to be reckoned with—which is something I never thought I’d write.



